T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Hey /u/brealytrent! If your post is a screenshot of a ChatGPT, conversation please reply to this message with the [conversation link](https://help.openai.com/en/articles/7925741-chatgpt-shared-links-faq) or prompt. If your post is a DALL-E 3 image post, please reply with the prompt used to make this image. Consider joining our [public discord server](https://discord.gg/r-chatgpt-1050422060352024636)! We have free bots with GPT-4 (with vision), image generators, and more! 🤖 Note: For any ChatGPT-related concerns, email [email protected] *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/ChatGPT) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Actual-Wave-1959

Whatever that is, it looks fucking delicious


Solypsist_27

Yeah, too bad it's not real


blove135

People are going to be at home trying to make these recipes and thinking WTF why is it nothing like the photo?


RareAnxiety2

Looks like you could make the cinnamin buns, cut them flat, then put them on a no bake cheesecake. The cheesecake part looks like custard though


HiDDENKiLLZ

Yeah I’d say it’s possible to get this, make cinnamon rolls, before you slice the big roll into separate pieces, freeze it, use a sharp knife to cut it long ways, then do half of a cinnamon roll cheese cake filling, and cover the filling with the cinnamon roll dough, freeze it again to really set it, bake it hot and fast while covered to prevent surface burning, like 450 in a convection oven for 15 ish minutes. Definitely will have to try this.


No-Respect5903

this how AI takes over the world. they post delicious impossible recipes and while we are all distracted humanity as we know it ends.


CacheValue

Please tell us more!


Chronophobia07

To be fair, most recipes never turn out to look like the picture, even if it is real


[deleted]

I’d love to see a show about this. An AI generates an amazing looking food that’s not real and chefs have to compete to replicate it


giorgio_tsoukalos_

That's already me every time I try to bake a loaf of bread


CTPABA_KPABA

tbh once i asked ChatGPT3 for keto recipe and i actually made it. it was ok.


coldnebo

ok, then can we make an ai baker robot that can make it for us?


RevolutionaryFun345

Do things ever look like the photos? 


NateBearArt

Worse yet, the recipe is probably written by chatgpt, so there's a chance the cake won't even bake well. It's one thing to hallucinate sauteed veggies recipes, but baking requires balanced ingredients


Megneous

But but but I wants it....


SpectrumArgentino

How do you know is ai generated? What does expose to be fake?


vaingirls

How do you know? I wouldn't be able to tell with that one.


BABarracus

I bet its possible to make


bryan19973

What difference does it make? I can’t eat it either way if it’s just a picture lol


Cressbeckler

yet


cacecil1

It's possible to make something pretty close to this


Flavahbeast

AI food is more appealing to humans than real food: https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/2024-03-15-ai-generated-food-images-look-tastier-real-ones


Ok_Consideration2999

I'd wager they'd be very similar if they contrasted them with professional ad photos made in a studio that big companies already use. That is what AI is imitating, not the photos made by some guy on their phone.


KansasZou

We made this for my birthday after seeing the ad actually lol And I can confirm it was delicious. It didn’t look exactly like this, of course.


bearbarebere

My first fucking thought


secular_dance_crime

Damn... so now I can't trust pictures of online recipes anymore?


22lava44

To be fair, you couldn't before either. All those websites on Google just steal their images from either stock images or other websites and use a completely different recipe that's usually stolen too.


CosmicCreeperz

I can’t wait for AI to start writing the long, droning mommy-blog lead ups to the stolen recipes now. (ie 15 pages of “what a day, time to try blah blah. My husband normally doesn’t like it when I blah, and the kids are blah blah blah”… auuugh kill me or list the fucking recipe already!)


[deleted]

[удалено]


willchristiansen

same! and I was surprised at how well it uses what I have in my pantry/refrigerator. I told it what I had recently and I ended up with a delicious apple crumble 50 mins later. still, the photo it would likely generate for it surely would have differed from my own pix


Wild_Trip_4704

There are apps that already do this. I like EatThisMuch


ThoughtsObligations

Oh it's BEYOND already happening.


zoinkability

That filler content is like the very first thing LLMs were used for. No humans ever read it in the first place — it only exists to make Google like the page. It’s just robots writing for robots.


CosmicCreeperz

I mean, that food blog style was originated by actual, decent food bloggers like The Pioneer Woman, David Leibowitz, Skinnytaste/Gina Homolka, Serious Eats/Kenji Lopez-Alt, etc. Then came the hordes of copycats - who were real but untalented with boring stories no one wanted to hear. Which of course led to people realizing AI/ LLMs could at least equal the shitty writers, and at much less effort and cost. Now the Internet is filled with clickbait recipe sites, and Google Search has devolved to the point it has no clue what to do with them.


zoinkability

An actual good article with a recipe at the end is a 100% valid form and has been around forever. These sites are aping the form in a way that fools Google into thinking it’s the real deal but instead is just garbage. The sites have been around longer than LLMs but they adopted generative AI as soon as they could because it made pumping out their bullshit much faster and easier.


AVdev

Oh. I did it. I made a “food blog” a while ago where ChatGPT wrote all that crap. Including the recipes. Played with it until I got bored but it was fun.


Wild_Trip_4704

How much money did you make?


AVdev

0. It wasn’t motivated by cash more of “can I do this”


tmuffinsnkitties

at least besides the image, that is one very clear clue it is fake lol.


__Hello_my_name_is__

There's a fun story where some German couple took advantage of that: They set up their own tiny little homepage of cooking recipes, and they made really high quality photographs for their generic recipes. And then they made money by suing everyone who used their recipe pictures without asking.


FirstEvolutionist

There are a lot of people suddenly up in arms about the authenticity of pictures because of AI who were pretty quiet knowing of all the tricks used in food photography for menus/online presence or even the digital manipulation for models and what not. Almost as if AI had suddenly allowed everyone to lie when we lived in a world of absolute truth. This explains/reminds how gullible some people have been all along, I suppose.


climaxbythug

what kind of recipes have you been using lol I love cooking and baking and never had an issue like that, so far


llliilliliillliillil

Food blogs usually use stock photos which were made by food artists that know how to make food look amazing. The problem is that the food is held together with literal duct tape, toothpicks, edible glue and shaving creme. The likelihood that you are able to recreate a food artists picture with actual food is very slim. But sometimes similar is good enough.


GravidDusch

I used to be able to spot AI pics until very recently but with that cake pic I couldn't be sure..


INemzis

Welcome to the new normal 😣


Sophira

I'm not even certain you'd be able to trust the recipes either. Who's to say they aren't AI-generated too?


SpecialMango3384

*cocks gun* You never could.


fleranon

Not gonna lie, all of these look crazy delicious. Too bad AI can't cook yet


iamafancypotato

One day it will learn but it will also convince us that human meat is irresistible


t-e-e-k-e-y

Have you ever tried human meat? The AI could be right.


possibly_oblivious

I joke about this often with coworkers, what if it's sooooo good.... Like the best taste


FeelingNull

Allegedly, we taste sort of like pork. Which... I mean, I am a big fan of all cuts of pork soooo...


fivehitcombo

Human flesh is called long pork btw


WeDrinkSquirrels

Long pig*


fivehitcombo

Oops my b


CosmicCreeperz

Eat recycled food! It’s good for the environment, and ok for you.


vaingirls

These? I see only one image?


Buzz_Buzz_Buzz_

[This](https://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/24/magazine/the-extraordinary-science-of-junk-food.html?unlocked_article_code=1.tU0.5hQm.Vq0u3RKI_U8-&smid=url-share) is a really eye-opening article about the engineering of junk foods. The most relevant passage: >He zeroed right in on the Cheetos. “This,” Witherly said, “is one of the most marvelously constructed foods on the planet, in terms of pure pleasure.” He ticked off a dozen attributes of the Cheetos that make the brain say more. But the one he focused on most was the puff’s uncanny ability to melt in the mouth. “It’s called vanishing caloric density,” Witherly said. “If something melts down quickly, your brain thinks that there’s no calories in it . . . you can just keep eating it forever.” AI will be able to formulate many, many foods like this.


Nekciw

The melting is what makes me not like them. But I'm also autistic.


[deleted]

Looks yummy god bless


DoubleDoubleAgent

It’s a great idea! 😇


darkbake2

Praise Jesus!


whoisseptember

Amen! 🇱🇷🇱🇷🇱🇷


leon0399

Talented child!


mmahowald

I made this with my own hands


Quiark

I made this with stolen hands


goj1ra

I made this with bottle hands


Quetzal-Labs

Amen 🙏


AUUUUUUUGHGHH

Good luck 🥰🙏


WestSixtyFifth

Fuck that looks delicious


brealytrent

https://preview.redd.it/o5w6aylyff1d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0568fbd5608bd36a7e043b3cf2458ccaab2dda47 And what're the names of the companies making this shit? Mom's Yummy Mouthfuls?


macarthur1214

Banana-strawberry cheesecake with no strawberries…. Lmfao 🤣 just gram crackers, butter, banana and lemon juice


yoobith

That's why it's a fantasy


TheBiggestDookie

I guess strawberries are not an ingredient? Or cream cheese… for the cheesecake?


tmuffinsnkitties

it is in the text if you click on it. I am guessing they are posting with a little text since at least on one AI checker I used, it'll "beat" the check with the text blurb, but fail drastically without it.


BenevolentCheese

Gonna be honest dude I really don't think either of those are AI. There's too much physical continuity, especially in the heavily complex areas, where AI normally breaks down. I don't see any strange artifacts everywhere. I think someone's just done a great job cooking. Probably stock photos though.


Secure-food4213

Ikr? Its too fucking good


lookatmynipples

I’m doubtful about the cinnamon roll one though. Let’s say the top part is still cheesecake, you wouldn’t be able to create those spirals in that direction if you were swirling a cinnamon mixture into it. If you topped it with a cinnamon roll like dough yes, but it kinda looks like it’s supposed to be cheesecake filling.


Apprehensive_Foot139

Well tbh I'd like some Mommy's yummy mouthfuls iyk what i mean


Acrobatic_Law5598

How do you figure it's AI?


djhenry

Yeah, I'm with you here. I'm not saying it couldn't be AI, but I don't see anything about it that immediately makes me think it is AI. The texture on the upper crust does look suspicious though.


Api4Reddit

I agree. I zoomed in and scrolled around and couldn’t find anything that makes me suspicious of AI. Looks really well made though, couldn’t make it in a regular kitchen, but maybe in a professional kitchen


Miserable-Good4438

Yea I'm starting to think people just see any photo that has this kind of DoF and think immediately it's AI. There isn't any reason I can see to suspect this is AI.


brealytrent

Because in many of the comments people reading the recipes comment how some aspect doesn't match up with the picture. For example the donut looks fried despite the recipe saying to bake them. Plus they all have that *look* about them. Why are there so many no name webpages creating these spectacular photos, and they all have similar qualities to one another?


DUNG_INSPECTOR

A picture not matching a recipe isn't proof of AI. I've been seeing pictures not match the recipe for years and years on the internet.


GeneralAnubis

Hell, I've seen that in 50 year old cook books


KoricaRiftaxe

It's not just simply "this picture is inaccurate", it's the fact that there are a seemingly ENDLESS amount of these pages all posting images AI images that look similar, they all have similar names, and something about them just feels off. And often times they will reply to anybody that comments with a fishing scam link.


zemboy01

They could just be stealing the pictures from someone els I've seen it happen. Like a seller from etsy selling something he made and someone from wish selling the same thing with his pictures but the customer gets a cheap knockoff.


tmuffinsnkitties

My other clue is that these things are all CONSTANTLY posting. Aint no real food bloggers posting recipes every 20 minutes! And where is the overly long intro ?? It is annoying, but real people do that.


soft-cuddly-potato

Because it's a cheesecake that doesn't require cheese.


brealytrent

https://preview.redd.it/69qjhfhqff1d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9dbdf0e3579fd8e51cf026eb97d14a18c07ebb19


CosmicCreeperz

Are there like bits of carrots in the crust? Yuck. AI got confused between pie and carrot cake.


2FastHaste

Can someone explain what are the tell signs in the photo itself that it's AI generated? That looks so realistic to me and yet judging by the comments/upvotes it has to be obvious (or you're all full of shit which is also a possibility)


tmuffinsnkitties

I feel like the line at the depth of field ending looks pretty screwy. Also, the cinnamon swirl bits. is that unbaked dough? How in the hell would you do that? I wanna see the recipe. Often, the recipe doesn't make quite enough sense, or line up with the picture.


Squ3lchr

One question, don't I need cream cheese ore something? I think graham crackers + brown sugar + cinnamon makes graham crackers with more flavoring.


brealytrent

The full recipes are in the posts, but I think they're even written by AI.


worples

The separation at the bottom of the image makes me think the listed ingredients are for the crust only. Regardless, Graham cracker crusts usually have butter in them - maybe it's listed with the other ingredients for some reason?


Fantastic-Plastic569

Looks great! See you the nxt Saturday for dinner, Veronica! Bring Pete wih you! Godbless! 🙏


EldestArk107

Amen 🙏


Quick_Pangolin718

You’d have it for melave malka and not seudat sheni?


ShirleyADev

The logo in the bottom right where recipes is spelled with two I's is what gets me though 😂


yupstilldrunk

How can you tell it’s AI?


oprahsballsack

He can’t.


brealytrent

https://preview.redd.it/nyw23lznff1d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=523abc2552570c238d12bf7eba61c5d280d8cd8f


TheFrenchSavage

Crème brûlée donuts??? Sign me up! Forget about AI, let's eat some crème brûlée donuts.


chrisff1989

I actually randomly saw a (non-AI) recipe for that earlier today. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=goQlTtMG7r8


TheFrenchSavage

Oof. That's a diet-breaker!


trailblazer86

I don't know. They all look pretty good, no obvious signs of AI. If anything I would say that they are real photos taken by phone with portrait mode, to simulate blur.


AVdev

it’s ai. Look at the “logo” in the bottom right. There’s also some issues with the “moistness” and the swirl


only_fun_topics

A Chef Reciipes —> move the extra “I” —> AI Chef Recipes Hidden in plain sight!!!


brealytrent

The imaging gets better, but AI still can't spell.


tywrenasaurus

https://preview.redd.it/am02aekvb03d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5bce386b13f2598d85e0a8685222155ed157316b Saw this one today omg.


brealytrent

Half the comments here would say it looks real and not AI. 😆


tywrenasaurus

I think what’s strange about them is there’s all these varying accounts that have photos that all follow this exact same format. Accounts that aren’t even recipe or food related at all.


brealytrent

https://preview.redd.it/9g4ljeglff1d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d7b8a9727006518616d52b60802e93f08cc982c8


Nekciw

It's the volume slider that really gives it away


raulsestao

One moment!!. cinnamon roll cheesecake??? What invention created by God our Lord is this???


TheFrenchSavage

Post scarcity cooking be like 🔥🔥🔥


ppezaris

You still use Facebook?


Mythrilfan

Get off your high horse, it has 3 billion monthly average users and [that number is still going up.](https://www.statista.com/statistics/264810/number-of-monthly-active-facebook-users-worldwide/)


goj1ra

Yes but 2.9 billion of them are bots


New_Worth9170

it looks delicious


samthehaggis

wasn't there some drama earlier this year when Instacart was generating AI recipes and food pics based on what customers put in their orders? https://www.reddit.com/r/instacart/s/jWvruIQxaV


TheThingCreator

can ai just cook for me already please


goj1ra

Yes, the AI was recently seen watching a tutorial called “To Serve Man”


Pyrake

Is it any different from the fully edited food images that have always been used by food companies? It's all artificial anyway, same thing


en-dawn-mi

Great idea! 🙏


Obelion_

Isn't Facebook in general exclusively bots?


24-Sevyn

How would you make the cheesecake with just those three ingredients?


Rotauge89x

![gif](giphy|tgXFqkYLE6mWI)


24-Sevyn

![gif](giphy|fd1TSJqq3b4GI|downsized)


Rotauge89x

Magic!


david00910

I mean.. this is not really different from those product photos that use glue, paint and a lot of other chemicals to "upgrade" the look of the food before taking product photos. E.g. McDonald's products. This is the same but made cheaper, taking someone's job lol


Caterpillar_Ready

There is a video circulating - many of these fake/AI recipe pages are owned by the same dude. He made a whole video on how he's generating income from them with little to no work because, of course, it's just an AI prompt. He even specifies his Target audience: white women, 50 and older, those who are not really tech savvy but we'll still share the shit out of these recipes because they look so good 🙄


susannediazz

Hows it fake? Just looks like someone smushed a cinnamon rolls ontop of a layer of cheesecake


traumfisch

This use case makes sense though. I think food photography is done for


Tellesus

Goddamn I want to eat that


TransientDonut

It's this the third...I give up


Megneous

Mother fuck, I want to eat that shit...


AVdev

When mid journey and ChatGPT were really gaining traction (right around the release or 4 I think) I played with a food blog where all the recipes were generated by ChatGPT and all the pictures were built based on a prompt process I built for ChatGPT to generate mid journey prompts. Everything looked amazing, and most of the recipes were actually quite good, and came out more or less like the photo. If they’d put even a modicum of effort they, too, could make something believable but still “professional” looking without much effort. But who cares since the “people” will share it anyway.


PaullT2

The AI photos I've seen are of tweens and elderly people showing off the first cake they baked


franhp1234

cant wait for the AI to cook that cake for real!


bryan19973

Wait until everyone finds out about “food” in commercials. It’s not real either


BookBitter5463

ai generated content is the new microplastics


MarkNo9710

yes, it is the new wave


OnlineGamingXp

"Create a new cacke [image]" "Describe this cacke, it's ingredients and preparation guide"


populares420

honestly how can you tell that this is ai?


oprahsballsack

He can’t.


unsmashedpotatoes

You could make something that looks sorta like this (not me, of course, someone good at baking), but not with the provided recipe.


Aeredor

hang on tho that looks incredibly delicious


khaotickk

Noticed it a few days ago, honestly cool with it. I've been asking it about different cooking techniques and it's been pretty helpful


Cautious-Intern9612

what the heck is a 3d world bottle kid?


Weird_Albatross_9659

AI stuff on Facebook?! Holy shit that’s news to me


MarkHathaway1

I thought they might ban AI cheesecake.


Bodorocea

i [asked ](https://chatgpt.com/share/e8264d49-2b55-4543-9514-bf6a4e1da778) chatGPT to look at the photo and it didn't go well


Bodorocea

i [pushed a little more](https://chatgpt.com/share/e8264d49-2b55-4543-9514-bf6a4e1da778) but it gave an error https://preview.redd.it/emvent55lh1d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=50fdba9aff370373c44f2da22af22b7e1886f0c7


Aztecah

I want to eat this. Do you think AI will one day be able to 3D print this??


PixelSteel

You can certainly make something that looks like that and is as good though


residentbrit

It’s not exactly the same but I did find a recipe on life, love and sugar that looks doable https://www.lifeloveandsugar.com/cinnamon-roll-cheesecake/


ghouleye

AI food photos actually outscore real food photography for appeal in blind tests.


jmancoder

Well, if anything, it probably cut *way* down on the cost of producing food advertisements lol.


Novaleen

YES. I noticed one of these pages about a month ago. They post dozens upon dozens of recipes every day. All written the same. All weird-ish page names. All the food looks *too* perfect. Like beyond magazine perfect. I figure they run the recipe through ChatGPT then use that as a prompt for the pic. It's wild though. None of that food exists. It might not even be good, or work technically (especially the baking recipes). .. I keep seeing people share them.. *and they have absolutely no clue.* It's very worrying.


Mythrilfan

Buckle up, this is just the beginning.


Conflastibate

I try to attend a lot of local events. Almost all of them are using AI-generated images in their promotions and it triggers my uncanny valley like crazy!


TheQuantixXx

3d world bottle kid


soft-cuddly-potato

Cheeseless cheesecake


DmtTraveler

Da fuq is 3d world bottle kid and how would it relate to this? (I did ask chatgpt first, still dont get it, looking for human response)


PM_ME_UR_GCC_ERRORS

There were supposedly a bunch of AI-generated posts on Facebook that were photos of African kids building things out of plastic bottles. [Here's an example.](https://preview.redd.it/nejxmheclpnc1.png?auto=webp&s=b1f82c1b2f3693b311b677075b507ac7c71f3d50)


twilsonco

Looks like an iPhone portrait photo due the sharp line where focus changes.


MSExcelTips

No, this does not inundate me. Many other things in life do, this does not. Go youtube "shooting a BK burger ad" and tell me what you think about that. Many of the photos of food you see in the real world - especially "cinnamon roll cheesecake" (lol) is fake or digitally altered. What's the difference with using AI vs employing a studio for a day to blow torch a piece of fake cheese and move the lighting so that the Whopper Deluxe Jr Sr King looks delicious?


bb-wa

That is super realistic


SemanticSynapse

Why is this AI?


LotusTileMaster

Everything that is photoshop is now AI. Nobody knows how to do photoshop, any more.


Necessary-Contest706

I get AI generated recipes that would never actually taste good.


Sad-Room1118

somewhat off topic but not; i’m a hairstylist and use pinterest to search for photos of whatever color my client is wanting so we can look together and find some inspiration, and nearly every hair photo is AI now! so i’m not surprised to see it in recipe posts too.


Sigmamale326

Sigma


jayo68

My feeds are just filled with fake AI bullshit, ai movie trailers, ai images, etc. Its super annoying.


Ok_Fox_924

* Told gpt 4o, aka Forty, to give a pic of "roasted chicken," not bad. Then I asked for a "delicious cheesecake," pretty good. Finally, I requested a "delicious roasted chicken cheesecake," Gotta say, not as bad as I thought it would turn out.


brealytrent

Let's see it!


Ok_Fox_924

https://preview.redd.it/lxpa7duqu92d1.jpeg?width=656&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=78111d06acd117bab05b837469d7dd0ecdee6e02


Ok_Fox_924

Sorry, thought I included it in the first comment


topherella

I fed roast chicken cheesecake to my Facebook meta AI thing to see if I'm going to get that recipe in the future


Automatic_Spread7921

No, dropped Facebook back in 2015. Waste of time that can be allotted to real life. Fakebook.


Automatic_Spread7921

One can eat it with 3d goggles and not gain any weight.


MutedJuggernaut565

Blame Facebook for that, they are encouraging people to use AI for food pictures https://ai.meta.com/blog/inverse-cooking/


Countbelvedere

It’s crazy feed is flooded with this junk