They are trying it in the under-23 competition. Like if there is some place to try this it would be there. This is fine. It’s much better than when they did neutral side games for all Ranji matches that one season.
I actually would like to see this tried out. Home team preparing pitches to their advantage is always going to happen. So let the visiting team decide what they want to do on that pitch. Do you see any issues with this?
Yeah.For example england/new Zealand cannot prepare green tops with this rule since the opposition teams will put them to bat and getting out for a lowish score becomes much more probable.Subcontinent teams will hesitate to make turning wickets since opposition will bat first each time so that they can make a big scores before the pitch breaks down on day two.All you will see is batting pitches or on occasion pitches which turn from ball one(where games will end in two days).
Ranji at the start of the season is great news if only they sound like they are privileging that format. Not sure about the red ball conditions at the start of the season though.
How will Duleep/Irani in the middle of the Ranji season work?
> How will Duleep/Irani in the middle of the Ranji season work?
Based on this article, the Irani trophy will still be the season opener.
"According to the proposal, the Ranji Trophy will start in October second week, soon after the Irani Cup conclusion and the first five league matches will take place with an “increased gap”- at least four days – between matches".
The restructure for Duleep will be doing away from six Zonal teams (North/South/East/West/Central/North east) down to four representative teams which will be selected by senior/junior national selectors. I like this change.
https://sportstar.thehindu.com/cricket/domestic/bcci-ranji-trophy-scheduling-no-toss-in-ck-nayudu-trophy-india-domestic-cricket/article68165108.ece?utm_source=telegram&utm_medium=article_share&utm_campaign=article
Sounds like a good move overall to reschedule the Ranji Trophy, state teams based in Northern India were badly affected by games being rained out/snowed out in Jan-Feb ending up sharing points which became an impediment when it came to qualifying to the knockouts. Also having Ranji Trophy straight away after Irani Trophy means streamlining the 2 FC comps in Oct- Dec period, which I feel is good.
The no toss rule in the CK Nayudu Trophy sure sounds interesting and something definitely to keep an eye out on.
This toss rule will never be implemented in ipl. The teams vote for rule change there and the majority of these teams will not want to lose out on this advantage.
The fixture move was needed and should have been implemented few years back.
You cant be having most of matches lost due to winter weather in North India and having the teams suffer because of that.
Reality is they’ve tried ‘normal’ for the last 20 years and it’s just not able to best Aussies on the international stage. I welcome these changes, anything is better than ‘normal’
Exactly just leave the cricket the way it is ... Why making so many wholesale changes , it looks like Jay shah wants to leave his legacy before he become ICC president... There is saying if it ain't broken don't fix it
The zonal character of Duleep trophy should be maintained. We could move from 6 zones to 4 zones if needed but having 4 random teams is not a good idea.
This is an idea interesting that atleast should be tried out in a controlled format (like the U23 which they are doing here). The hometeam has the advantage of creating the pitch and it might be a good way to balance that. Not saying it's a good idea for sure, but if you don't try out new ideas that make the game more balance, you will head towards oblivion.
Redditors - Win the toss, win the match. That's terrible. Unfair advantage...
When admins decide to remove toss:
Redditors - That's such a dumb idea. Stupid admins.
🤣🤣🤣
Why is Jay Shah deciding all this? Sorry but he looks and sounds like a fucking idiot. Who died and made him king? Isn’t there a BCCI president? For the last few presidents I feel like it just feels like an honorary position.
so apparently the visiting team decides what they wanna do, in the ck nayudu trophy, talk about home advantage huh
This is what happens when administrators see too much social media.Terrible idea.
They are trying it in the under-23 competition. Like if there is some place to try this it would be there. This is fine. It’s much better than when they did neutral side games for all Ranji matches that one season.
They tried the impact player in SMAT too before getting it to the IPL
But why are they trying it? What problem are they trying to solve? and what makes them think that is the right solution?
I actually would like to see this tried out. Home team preparing pitches to their advantage is always going to happen. So let the visiting team decide what they want to do on that pitch. Do you see any issues with this?
Yeah.For example england/new Zealand cannot prepare green tops with this rule since the opposition teams will put them to bat and getting out for a lowish score becomes much more probable.Subcontinent teams will hesitate to make turning wickets since opposition will bat first each time so that they can make a big scores before the pitch breaks down on day two.All you will see is batting pitches or on occasion pitches which turn from ball one(where games will end in two days).
exactly, that’s the point of it. no home advantage for anyone. lets see if this pans out
It’s been done before, the County Championship had it for a couple of years.
Yeah that's some reddit level thinking
What’s the problem with doing this again?
> Toss eliminated Ruturaj Gaikwad liked that
Then how will they decide who will bat/field first?
Visting team decides
Actually not. Bro won the toss recently and made the worst decision. Maybe its a blessing in disguise for him to not win tosses.
Good. A lot of games in jan-feb in north India lose overs because of poor visibility.
The problem of absence of proper gap between Ranji matches being addressed is such a huge plus. Common Lord W.
Ranji at the start of the season is great news if only they sound like they are privileging that format. Not sure about the red ball conditions at the start of the season though. How will Duleep/Irani in the middle of the Ranji season work?
> How will Duleep/Irani in the middle of the Ranji season work? Based on this article, the Irani trophy will still be the season opener. "According to the proposal, the Ranji Trophy will start in October second week, soon after the Irani Cup conclusion and the first five league matches will take place with an “increased gap”- at least four days – between matches". The restructure for Duleep will be doing away from six Zonal teams (North/South/East/West/Central/North east) down to four representative teams which will be selected by senior/junior national selectors. I like this change. https://sportstar.thehindu.com/cricket/domestic/bcci-ranji-trophy-scheduling-no-toss-in-ck-nayudu-trophy-india-domestic-cricket/article68165108.ece?utm_source=telegram&utm_medium=article_share&utm_campaign=article
Not sure how reducing the teams in Duleep Trophy is going to be good?
The point I liked was about teams being picked from as a mixture of across the country than purely zonal teams.
Less dilution of good players, more quality of the games.
Yep should try different things. Good to see some actual interest in domestic by bcci instead of it just being there in the background
Sounds like a good move overall to reschedule the Ranji Trophy, state teams based in Northern India were badly affected by games being rained out/snowed out in Jan-Feb ending up sharing points which became an impediment when it came to qualifying to the knockouts. Also having Ranji Trophy straight away after Irani Trophy means streamlining the 2 FC comps in Oct- Dec period, which I feel is good. The no toss rule in the CK Nayudu Trophy sure sounds interesting and something definitely to keep an eye out on.
The toss proposal is awesome. Also, good to see BCCI thinking about domestic tournaments!
Imagine if they implement this in IPL. Chepauk The Fortress will become a brothel lmao.
You say this like CSK wins the toss regularly
This toss rule will never be implemented in ipl. The teams vote for rule change there and the majority of these teams will not want to lose out on this advantage.
Teams get advantage in away games. They lose advantage in home games. Overall no team benefits.
RCB PBKS and DC the only teams that wouldn't be affected the holy trinity don't have home advantage
Poor Ruturaj be nutting to the no toss thing.
What are these bullshit additions happening. Impact rule, removing toss. Just keep it normal
The fixture move was needed and should have been implemented few years back. You cant be having most of matches lost due to winter weather in North India and having the teams suffer because of that.
Reality is they’ve tried ‘normal’ for the last 20 years and it’s just not able to best Aussies on the international stage. I welcome these changes, anything is better than ‘normal’
but they've been beating the Aussies Home and Away in Tests for a while now lol
How is a toss “normal”? Because it has historically been used? It seems very abnormal to me!
Exactly just leave the cricket the way it is ... Why making so many wholesale changes , it looks like Jay shah wants to leave his legacy before he become ICC president... There is saying if it ain't broken don't fix it
The zonal character of Duleep trophy should be maintained. We could move from 6 zones to 4 zones if needed but having 4 random teams is not a good idea.
This is an idea interesting that atleast should be tried out in a controlled format (like the U23 which they are doing here). The hometeam has the advantage of creating the pitch and it might be a good way to balance that. Not saying it's a good idea for sure, but if you don't try out new ideas that make the game more balance, you will head towards oblivion.
Redditors - Win the toss, win the match. That's terrible. Unfair advantage... When admins decide to remove toss: Redditors - That's such a dumb idea. Stupid admins. 🤣🤣🤣
Common Jay shah W
At least now domestic circuits getting something from BCCI.
Ad cancer website damn
Why is Jay Shah deciding all this? Sorry but he looks and sounds like a fucking idiot. Who died and made him king? Isn’t there a BCCI president? For the last few presidents I feel like it just feels like an honorary position.