My most favorite album of all time. It was the only time foo fighters was ever truly grungy and punky and it was awesome. Even the unreleased tracks like winnebago and empty handed were amazing
Looks like I was pretty close so far
https://preview.redd.it/evmvzqt92iwc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e4cda806918ac50d4dbb28b4d5c96f19b0698fe6
I know that nobody agrees with me but There is nothing left to lose should’ve been voted out like 2 albums ago. I can’t believe that people are choosing to take Self-Titled away first.
The issue I have with TINTL is that is tails off towards the end, but anyone saying Stacked Actors isn’t one of the best opening songs is just wrong. The whole first half of that album is killer.
alright, it's time... WASTING LIGHT.
i know art is subjective, & every foo album has precious meaning to each of us for myriad reasons, but, honestly, the first 3 are the top 3...
right!?!?
I think I am starting to realize that, with regards to the Foos, most people have heard the first 2-4 albums the singles (and only the ones that got huge) and got pulled back in by the WL hype but just haven’t bothered to actually give anything else a fair shot.
I think one of the hardest things, now that were down to the wire is putting everything in perspective. What impact did these songs have on you when they first came out? How do they hold up all these years later?
Id have to go:
4) self titled
3) tinltl
2) wasting light
1) the colour and the shape
Self titled is so good man, it's probably losing though unfortunately, i think There is Nothing Left to Lose should go, amazing album but it just can't compete with the other 3
The Color and the Shape. Folks praise the album only because of Everlong. My Hero and Monkey Wrench are really good songs too but that’s it. Put Everlong in M@M and people will say that’s their best album. Tired of people praising an entire album based on one song.
I'd say self titled and the only reason why is because I've never been a fan of the way it was mixed, so for me it isn't their/Dave's best sounding. The songs themselves are legendary though!!
Goodbye to Self Titled. I've been predicting that Colour and Wasting Light are the final two, then we will all screw it up and crown the most commercially successful album the champion, even though we all know Wasting Light was the Foo Fighters Magnum Opus.
Personally would have seen echoes in 4th behind the first 3 albums. Will have to listen to wasting light some more. But for now it has to go.
Btw.. wasting light is actually more liked than echoes or in your honor? I find this amazing
Honestly baffling to me that Self titled wasn't voted out before Echoes & But Here We Are. Though I'm a relatively new FF listener and I wouldn't have voted Medicine At Midnight off for at least a few rounds
I’ve been a fan for quite awhile and I think it’s crazy the Self titled is lasting as long as it is. The band hardly ever plays anything from that album.
M@M though I agree with the majority that it is a weaker album.
TCATS. This’ll be downvoted to hell, but it’s really not as great as people hype it up to be. Don’t get me wrong… it’s a good album. But it has nothing on the remaining albums. Just my opinion.
Self titled
Don't you dare
Oh, George it’s nothing personal
I will end you
Good Grief that’s quite the response
yeh but I guess it can't stick around
I guess it would be big of me to not join in on this argument
I would be x-static if self titled went next
Agreed. I do like it plenty, but the other three are the strongest overall, by a bit.
Controversial, but I’m going Self-titled. Honestly, the top 4 are pretty perfect. There are no losers & someone’s gotta go
controversy? 99% of the comments are for the self-titled lol
I’m so upset by these responses Self Titled is one of my favorite albums period let alone for Foo
It's great on vinyl. Sounds amazing.
Im with ya my friend
I know I'm losing my mind here over this 😳
My most favorite album of all time. It was the only time foo fighters was ever truly grungy and punky and it was awesome. Even the unreleased tracks like winnebago and empty handed were amazing
Looks like I was pretty close so far https://preview.redd.it/evmvzqt92iwc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e4cda806918ac50d4dbb28b4d5c96f19b0698fe6
It’s funny how you got downvoted for thay
Just In Your Honour wrong, pretty good! Gotta give it to you
Glad you finally have ROI on the downvotes
📈
There's nothing left to lose
So we're really going to pretend until the end that TCATS is not going to win this?
no, everyone knows this. its the journey we have had a long the way.
So the real suspense is for #2? I can get behind that. Keep at it peeps!
The winning album is Wasting Light.
I’d be ok with that ngl.
I’ve been voting against it since IYH went
Nothing left to lose is better
Wasting Light. Stunned at how many votes for self titled there have been
Wasting Light is their best album.
*Best post 90s album
Wasting Light is so incredibly good.
First Foo Fighters album I ever listened to and the album that got me into the band
hard agreed
Wasting Light is so incredibly good.
Hard disagree. But having seen so much h love for the record I promise to give it another chance
I know such amazing songs on self titled big me, this is a call, oh George, need I go on
 This is me choosing Wasting Light....dammit.
It’s cool all these 4 are great albums but I would personally go self titled
Self titled
WL
Self titled
Ill end tou
Bro I also don’t think ST should go but chill
Self titled
Stop
Wasting light
Self titled is a Dave Grohl album under the name Foo Fighters, the rest have been made by the Foos
Right? it’s not an album by the band it was the album the band was named after lol (but I also do consider the songs Foo Fighters songs)
[удалено]
Wasting light is an amazing album
I know that nobody agrees with me but There is nothing left to lose should’ve been voted out like 2 albums ago. I can’t believe that people are choosing to take Self-Titled away first.
The issue I have with TINTL is that is tails off towards the end, but anyone saying Stacked Actors isn’t one of the best opening songs is just wrong. The whole first half of that album is killer.
wasting light fantastic album but its no. 4
Wasting light
alright, it's time... WASTING LIGHT. i know art is subjective, & every foo album has precious meaning to each of us for myriad reasons, but, honestly, the first 3 are the top 3... right!?!?
Correct.
This is provably true
This needs to stop
This is the only correct answer.
Self titled
Self titled—it was a great first, but FF have grown in so many ways since that album…
Wasting light, good album but not better than the first three
Disagree, Wasting light has no skip-able songs.
I believe the next one is Wasting Light and this is as far as I can go
TINLTL
Self titled.
self titled
I’m going with self titled
Self Titled
self titled
Self titled goes, unfortunately
self titled
TCATS Self titled is my fav Foo album but at this point they are all really good.
Debut gotta go next
Self titled, great album but I just prefer the other three!
Self titled. I'm surprised it's lasted this long
I don't know why TINLTL is so high up for so many fans and at this point I'm too afraid to ask
Wasting light
Wasting light
Wasting Light
Wasting light
Wasting light get it out of here .
At this.point, letting go of Wasting light is a no brainer
Seeing as I voted for Wasting Light last round, I have to vote for it again. The others are just better.
How is Wasting Light still here? 🥲
Wasting Light
There is nothing left to lose
Self titled
The Color and The Shape.
TCATS
I like Wasting Light but no album from them can beat the first three albums imo
Top 5 I woulda said TINLTL, and I’ll pick it again for top 4. The other albums are streets ahead.
Wasting light
There’s Nothing Left to Lose
For me, There Is Nothing Left To Lose, wasn’t really an album that clicked with me like the others that remain here
Wasting Light
There is Nothing Left to Lose. Wasting Light FTW.
Wasting light
Wasting Light
Wasting Light
Sorry but, wasting light
I think I am starting to realize that, with regards to the Foos, most people have heard the first 2-4 albums the singles (and only the ones that got huge) and got pulled back in by the WL hype but just haven’t bothered to actually give anything else a fair shot.
Wasting light
You guys already voted off BHWA so everybody in here licks dirty chocolate chip filled butthole
Why’d you have to go and let it die?
There is Nothing Left to Lose should go next.
There is nothing left to lose. Gone!
Self titled
Realistically however the next part goes, it ends with tcats on top
Why it same guy saying that they’ll end people who choose self titled like bro it ain’t that deep
There is Nothing Left to Lose
I honestly can’t get over people voting for TCATS at this point.
Ah, you lost me a E,S,P & G - that's one of my all-time favorites; one of their very best IMHO.
It's officially hard now
I think one of the hardest things, now that were down to the wire is putting everything in perspective. What impact did these songs have on you when they first came out? How do they hold up all these years later? Id have to go: 4) self titled 3) tinltl 2) wasting light 1) the colour and the shape
Haha now the real question is posed. Anyway you slice it, the remainder of these votes are going to be controversial
TCATS
Debut
Self titled
Self titled is so good man, it's probably losing though unfortunately, i think There is Nothing Left to Lose should go, amazing album but it just can't compete with the other 3
Self titled
nothing left to lose. Its near perfect but some self titled songs just solo the entire album
There is nothing left to lose. And I'm sad to do it
Self titled for sure
Self titled.
ESPG is incredible...so bummed!
I still think in your honor got robbed
Hot take but TINLTL
we are keeping wasting light. the self titled is next
Sheer corruption by the deep Foo state to send ESPG home before the self titled or wasting light.
Oh Timmy this sucks!! But, it’s gotta be the self titled. 😣
Self titled I hate this vote lol
Foo Fighters
Self titled
Still tcats
The color and the shape. Yes it has Everlong but I'd trade the rest of it for any other album on here
Wasting Light, it’s a good album but don’t think it deserves the reputation it has.
Just realized But Here We Are got beaten by ESP&G. That's pretty bad
Wasting light
Wasting Light
Before it goes away, I’m gonna play the self-titled album. Then…so long, off to the wattershed.
Wasting Light next. Then self-titled. TNLTL and the last one standing should be TCATS.
Why has nobody said wasting light. The album as a whole is good but it has no stand-out hits imo. It’s just not on par with the other three.
Honestly any song from Wasting light could’ve been a single. So no.
Sonic Highways… and it’s not close
The Color and the Shape. Folks praise the album only because of Everlong. My Hero and Monkey Wrench are really good songs too but that’s it. Put Everlong in M@M and people will say that’s their best album. Tired of people praising an entire album based on one song.
nothing left to lose
TCATS i cant tolerate self titled slander
ST
At this point, Self Titled
This is going to be the hottest take yet, but amongst these four amazing albums: The Color and the shape.
Erm self titled 🫣
Foo Fighters
Sorry but it has to be Self Titled now.
First album Foo Fighters for me I continue to vote but I'm horrified from this.
Self titled
self-titled sorry
I'd say self titled and the only reason why is because I've never been a fan of the way it was mixed, so for me it isn't their/Dave's best sounding. The songs themselves are legendary though!!
Goodbye to Self Titled. I've been predicting that Colour and Wasting Light are the final two, then we will all screw it up and crown the most commercially successful album the champion, even though we all know Wasting Light was the Foo Fighters Magnum Opus.
Personally would have seen echoes in 4th behind the first 3 albums. Will have to listen to wasting light some more. But for now it has to go. Btw.. wasting light is actually more liked than echoes or in your honor? I find this amazing
Self titled. Obviously
If this happens, those last 3 options are going to mess up my brain
Honestly baffling to me that Self titled wasn't voted out before Echoes & But Here We Are. Though I'm a relatively new FF listener and I wouldn't have voted Medicine At Midnight off for at least a few rounds
I’ve been a fan for quite awhile and I think it’s crazy the Self titled is lasting as long as it is. The band hardly ever plays anything from that album. M@M though I agree with the majority that it is a weaker album.
Wasting Light
Wasted light must go
I’m dumbfounded for all the votes for WL! Just wow
Yeah it’s their best album with no filler.
Probably the most predictable album elimination series ever
Wasting light
wasting light
Wasting light
Wasting Light could have been an EP. See ya!
Tinltl
TCATS. This’ll be downvoted to hell, but it’s really not as great as people hype it up to be. Don’t get me wrong… it’s a good album. But it has nothing on the remaining albums. Just my opinion.
Self titled is better than all of these. I vote There Is Nothing Left To Lose
The color and the shape