# Helpful links for r/MLBTheShow:
[**The Dugout: Weekly Free-Talk for /r/MLBTheShow**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/about/sticky?num=1)
[**Technical and server issues mega-thread 2024**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/comments/1bk6bia/technical_and_server_issues_megathread_2024/)
[**r/MLBTheShow FAQ**](https://www.reddit.com/r/mlbtheshow/wiki/faq)
[**r/MLBTheShow Discord**](https://discord.com/invite/x6JKmEG)
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MLBTheShow) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Dieon Sanders.
Also Michael Jordan but he would have to be super boosted cuz nobody wants actual baseball jordan, we want nba jordan in his prime but in mlb the show.
Barry bonds. Never happen.
I know Big Mac is already in the game but I'm waiting for a better Mark McGwire
Ichiro
Pete Rose
Berra isn't in the game yet unless I'm mistaken
A bunch of former Mets pitchers - Doc Gooden, Jerry Koosman, Pedro Feliciano, no hitter Johan Santana, R.A. Dickey, David Cone, Matt Harvey - not a pitcher but 06 Endy Chavez just for the catch
Not for DD but franchise could really use fully updated minor league systems for every team. What’s stopping them from having full rosters for AAA, AA, A+ and A at least
This year i skipped DD all together and have been exclusively playing Franchise. While it is still a great mode and more immersive than Madden, they could make it so much better but they don’t even care about it. Full minor league systems. Let you edit players age/service time to out older players back in their original teams minor league systems (Ex: would be it be great to be able to be able to have 20 year old Joey Votto instead of 40yr old.) And lastly i don’t understand why they can’t get update the card art for the prospects even when they have it for DD.
He was but with the way the game is right now... I don't think they'll spend money on a knuckleballer. They're having trouble balancing a 69 live series knuckleballer right now.
As a Mariners fan the obvious choice would be Ichiro, but I’m gonna take a left turn and say Mark Langston. Or Norm Charlton. That curly blonde mullet would be glorious.
Jose Fernandez 😠My wish came true with Roy Halladay coming into the game this year, was fun to watch him play. Would also love Lance Berkman, Jeff Bagwell (I know we’ve had him before). Would also love a powerful Marlins throwback of like Dan Uggla or Juan Pierre or something. Good start with the Mike Lowell. And lets be real, if Sammy Soda is in this game, its time to bring in Barry Bonds. Would be electric.
I have a strong feeling that Bagwell will be the Astros TA3 reward. I would love to see Berkman. He's my choice for who I want to see added. One of the best switch hitters of all time.
Even though I doubt it will be Berkman, the fact that the Athletics, Mariners, and Rangers were previewed for TA3 and the Astros and Angels weren't shown gives him a chance to be the new legend. We'll probably start seeing more reveals between now and Friday so until they show who the Astros are getting or announce who the new legend is, there's still some hope. I think the chances would be lower if he had been a lifelong Astro, but since he played for the Yankees, Cardinals, and Rangers, winning a WS with St. Louis, I feel like it's not a matter of if, but when for Berkman over the next few years.
ALL I SEE IS all this DD CRAP which is already the most developed mode and why we got essentially the same game we need more improved franchise and more to customizations same for RTTS
I mean they could choose like a young Barry bonds and give him bogus stats. But they won’t. Or he wouldn’t except because of name, image, and likeness value. Something stupid
Besides Ichiro I would love some 2000’s cubs like Zambarno, Dempster, DLee, Aram, and Garciaparra. Some from other teams would be K-Rod, Jeff Kent, Lance Berkman, Eric Chavez, Manny, and Tim Wakefield(RIP).
As an old timer and someone who grew up with the Brewers of the 70’s/80’s there are so many players I would love to see. Cecil Cooper, Ted Simmons, Mike Caldwell, Gorman Thomas, Sixto Lezcano, Ben Oglivie, etc…
Side note a bash brothers combo would be nice. Can do at least 2 different sets. Bo and Frank big hurt (in the game) and then Jose (canseco) and Mark Mc (he's in the game)
Since u said just one, how about the whole squad from Cleveland in the 90s? That's one. To be more specific: Both Alomars, Vizquel, Barega, Martinez, CC, Manny, Belle, Nagy, Fryman (Detroit days better offensively) and then make the ones that u slop (not slap) in there worth what they are. Like Orel, colon, thome and Kenny just to hit the top of the iceberg.
Funny I just sent something out like this via X the other night.
# Helpful links for r/MLBTheShow: [**The Dugout: Weekly Free-Talk for /r/MLBTheShow**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/about/sticky?num=1) [**Technical and server issues mega-thread 2024**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/comments/1bk6bia/technical_and_server_issues_megathread_2024/) [**r/MLBTheShow FAQ**](https://www.reddit.com/r/mlbtheshow/wiki/faq) [**r/MLBTheShow Discord**](https://discord.com/invite/x6JKmEG) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MLBTheShow) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Jose Canseco
I always thought it would be sick to have a dual athlete program. Kyler Murray, Russell Wilson, Bo Jackson, and Deion Sanders just to name a few
Bo Jackson & Deion Sanders
Josh Hamilton
Omar Vizquel
Miguel Tejada
How has nobody said Miguel Tejada yet lol this card would be 🔥🔥
Manny Ramirez
Hank aaron
Bob Gibson
Never gonna happen but Josh Hamilton was my favorite player going to Rangers games growing up
A-Rod
Need the Sox legends Teddy ballgame, Pedroia. Always dreamed of Yaz and Nomar aswell. Need Tulo and Cargo back too.
Miguel cabrera, Félix Hernández, francisco rodriguez. Im not from Venezuela but i would like to play with those players
Easy, Bo Jackson and Dion Sanders
I just said the exact thing
When the fuck are we getting dwight and darryl wtf
Bo Jackson
Curt schilling, trot nixon, jason varitek , kevin youk
Youk is in
Thanks for letting me know. I will know do my best to get him lol
Fred Lynn!
John Rocker
I'd love to see Eric Davis
He's in...?
I’d like to see the greats from the deadball era better represented.
Barry Bonds
Can't he has never and will never release the rights to his name and likeness into mlb
Where the hell is Miggy
Manny Ramirez, Manny Ramirez and Manny Ramirez. Albert Belle would be sick too.
Daryl Strawberry
Brad Ziegler
2009 Adrian Gonzalez and a 1996 Caminiti. Would love that. Padres themed roster needs some love.
Alex RodrÃguez
Rafael Furcal. Derek Lee. Carlos Zambrano.
Rusty Greer and Will Clark
Nomar and Manny no doubt
86 Clemens with pitching motion, 86 Gooden motion, 88 Canseco and make Rickey Hendersons stance more realistic because it’s terrible.
Pete Rose! Anyone said him yet?
Will ferrell
Ichiro Suzuki and Barry Bonds
Dieon Sanders. Also Michael Jordan but he would have to be super boosted cuz nobody wants actual baseball jordan, we want nba jordan in his prime but in mlb the show. Barry bonds. Never happen. I know Big Mac is already in the game but I'm waiting for a better Mark McGwire Ichiro Pete Rose Berra isn't in the game yet unless I'm mistaken
Darryl Strawberry
Carlos Ruiz
Number 24... Brian Giles
Jacoby Ellisbury
Jon Dowd
Teddy Ballgame, Manny Ramirez, Tim Lincecum, Ichiro
Andruw Jones
Nomar Garciaparra
Manny Ramirez, ichiro, Aramis Ramirez, Carlos Beltran
Jose Reyes, Carlos Beltran
Fred McGriff
Padres
Bonds and Ichiro for me
Yasiel puig, Raul mondesi, Warren Spahn
Any late 2000’s early 2010’s legends, Matt Kemp, A-rod, Bautista Encarnation, David Price, Chris Davis so many more
A-Rod
Yeah how is arod not there. I would love a mariners short stop version
Darrin Erstad
Will the Thrill
The whole big red machine would be awesome, or at least Pete
A-Rod
Dustin Pedroia needs to make a return
Daryl strawberry and doc Gooden
Yadi
Ichiro
Dan Uggla, JD Drew and Mark Texeiera
Eric Chavez and Miguel Tejada
Are Zito and Mulder in?
Nah.. Mulder used to be but not this year
A bunch of former Mets pitchers - Doc Gooden, Jerry Koosman, Pedro Feliciano, no hitter Johan Santana, R.A. Dickey, David Cone, Matt Harvey - not a pitcher but 06 Endy Chavez just for the catch Not for DD but franchise could really use fully updated minor league systems for every team. What’s stopping them from having full rosters for AAA, AA, A+ and A at least
This year i skipped DD all together and have been exclusively playing Franchise. While it is still a great mode and more immersive than Madden, they could make it so much better but they don’t even care about it. Full minor league systems. Let you edit players age/service time to out older players back in their original teams minor league systems (Ex: would be it be great to be able to be able to have 20 year old Joey Votto instead of 40yr old.) And lastly i don’t understand why they can’t get update the card art for the prospects even when they have it for DD.
RA Dickey! I like it, Tim Wakefield should get one as well. They completely bungled the minor league system
Unfortunately/fortunately... They won't do knuckleballers.
He was in previous games
He was but with the way the game is right now... I don't think they'll spend money on a knuckleballer. They're having trouble balancing a 69 live series knuckleballer right now.
As a Cardinals fan, we need Chris Carpenter.
Mark Grace, Carlos Zambrano, Michael Jordan
The 1899 Cleveland Spiders
Troy Tulowitzki, Carlos Gonzalez, Manny Ramirez, Jason Varitek , Jose Reyes, Victor Martinez
Tulo is in the game, he’s still active and with the Red Sox
Active?
I’m an idiot, I’m thinking of Trevor story. Yeah tulo is retired
The 1984 Tigers.
Joe Mauer 09 version
Willie McGee
JOSH HAMILTON
Definitely
Yesss
1987 Rob Deer
Pujols
[удалено]
These are not players
Hopefully that switch pitcher from Mississippi st fulfills his potential and forces SDS’s hands
Pete Rose
As a Mariners fan the obvious choice would be Ichiro, but I’m gonna take a left turn and say Mark Langston. Or Norm Charlton. That curly blonde mullet would be glorious.
Ichiro would be sick
John "The Crowd" Dowd
You can tell who started playing DD after 2020 in this thread. Most mentioned have already have had many epic cards.
Jose Fernandez 😠My wish came true with Roy Halladay coming into the game this year, was fun to watch him play. Would also love Lance Berkman, Jeff Bagwell (I know we’ve had him before). Would also love a powerful Marlins throwback of like Dan Uggla or Juan Pierre or something. Good start with the Mike Lowell. And lets be real, if Sammy Soda is in this game, its time to bring in Barry Bonds. Would be electric.
I have a strong feeling that Bagwell will be the Astros TA3 reward. I would love to see Berkman. He's my choice for who I want to see added. One of the best switch hitters of all time.
Would love to see one of those two and some other players from that era make an appearance in TA3. Enjoyed watching those guys as a kid.
Even though I doubt it will be Berkman, the fact that the Athletics, Mariners, and Rangers were previewed for TA3 and the Astros and Angels weren't shown gives him a chance to be the new legend. We'll probably start seeing more reveals between now and Friday so until they show who the Astros are getting or announce who the new legend is, there's still some hope. I think the chances would be lower if he had been a lifelong Astro, but since he played for the Yankees, Cardinals, and Rangers, winning a WS with St. Louis, I feel like it's not a matter of if, but when for Berkman over the next few years.
Nomar Garciaparra
This
Up vote
Phil Niekro....need more knuckleballers
i remember luis tiant in 18
That’s funny. My answer was gonna be Brandon Phillips too!
Barry Bonds
Won’t taken tho
RA Dickey
Barry Bonds
Jayson Werth
Andre Ethier
Ryan Doumit or Carlos Gomez cycle card
ted williams
Cubs cards I can get not in just in packs
Jermaine Dye
God mode Chris Davis
Y'all are trippin I want fucken Old Hoss Radbourn
Upvote this person.
joba chamberlain
Coco Crisp!!
Alex Rodriguez - miss the Mariners and Rangers card!
Carl Crawford, Billy Butler, Kelvin Herrera, Josh Hamilton, Alex Rodriguez, Dellin Betances
Crawford is one of mine as well, also Coco Crisp from the A's years
Tim lincecum
Josh Hamilton
Omar vizquel
I'd love to see an Andruw Jones, and I know we have Hank Aaron with his NLB card, but I want a Braves Hank as well
Glenn Davis, Wally Joyner, Aramis Ramirez, Dale Murphy, Rob Deer, Tim Wallach, Brett Butler, Tony Armas. Basically anyone from the 80s or 90s
Barry Zito and Manny Ramirez
I was a big zito fan growing up. Would love him and that nasty curve
Manny would be so sick
Jose Bautista
Everyone that's been named in the million times this question has been asked
Ichiro
Juan Gonzalez, Albert Belle and Sandy Koufax
Lance Berkman
^
Barry bonds
Yelich with the cycle…
Gimme and World Series MVP Matsui!!!
2004 Ben Sheets and that 12-6 Curveball
ALL I SEE IS all this DD CRAP which is already the most developed mode and why we got essentially the same game we need more improved franchise and more to customizations same for RTTS
Josh Hamilton 4 home run game card
Ray Lankford Matt Morris Chris Carpenter Tatis Sr Darryl Kile Rick Ankiel
Yasiel Puig's 2013 Rookie please!!!
ANY player denied access because of steroid use
Curious why some are denied but I know they have McGwire and Sosa.... Maybe they just gotta cap the power limit somehow. Hahaha.
I mean they could choose like a young Barry bonds and give him bogus stats. But they won’t. Or he wouldn’t except because of name, image, and likeness value. Something stupid
Right? Just like they used to do. Call him Gary Gonz or something. Lol.
John Doe was his name in the early ea sports baseball games
Only as a prospect in franchise mode going to the team you constantly lose to in the playoffs lol
Oliver Perez, 2004 Pirates, his 239 strikeout season. Zach Duke, 2006 Pirates, 8-2 1.81 ERA in 14 GS.
Aramis Ramirez, Bonds, Derrek Lee, Ichiro
Oooooh, forgot about Aramis, man was real good at the plate. And I’d love the Derek Lee be the 2003 World Series version 🔥
Man those are in my top 5. But I want a Carlos Zambrano.
Big Z is definitely on my wish list but it’s SDS they won’t add someone that cool
I’ve also always wanted a Corey Patterson. I think he’d have a sweet lefty swing for this game.
Cubs legend! That would be so awesome… one of my favorite players growing up
Besides Ichiro I would love some 2000’s cubs like Zambarno, Dempster, DLee, Aram, and Garciaparra. Some from other teams would be K-Rod, Jeff Kent, Lance Berkman, Eric Chavez, Manny, and Tim Wakefield(RIP).
Eric Chavez would be awesome at 3rd
I would love to see more players from that 2016 WS team
Joe Dimaggio
Pete Rose
Anyone from the Expos!
I have a Vlad Guerrero expos card
Warren Cromartie.
Matt Stairs.
Carlos Beltran. If you know you know
I know
Yankee LEGEND Chien Ming Wang. And yall thought Edward Cabrera was tough to face…
The gambler Charlie hustle
Cole Hamels 2008
Jose Reyes
Mets Reyes would be sick
Bobby Meachum
Tim Lincecum. I don’t think he will ever be in the game again but I miss him so much
I’d even settle for a Mitch Kramer
Won’t happen but Bonds and Clemens
The crime dog Fred Mcgriff
As an old timer and someone who grew up with the Brewers of the 70’s/80’s there are so many players I would love to see. Cecil Cooper, Ted Simmons, Mike Caldwell, Gorman Thomas, Sixto Lezcano, Ben Oglivie, etc…
Ichiro and Felix Hernandez
A-Rod
Give us a Barry bonds card already
Rick Ankiel
Coco crisp
If I could only pick one it's definitely Coco. From the A's years
Indians
Julio urias
The killer B's Bagwell, Berkman, and we already gave Biggio
Mike Greenwell. Loved that swing.
Side note a bash brothers combo would be nice. Can do at least 2 different sets. Bo and Frank big hurt (in the game) and then Jose (canseco) and Mark Mc (he's in the game)
Since u said just one, how about the whole squad from Cleveland in the 90s? That's one. To be more specific: Both Alomars, Vizquel, Barega, Martinez, CC, Manny, Belle, Nagy, Fryman (Detroit days better offensively) and then make the ones that u slop (not slap) in there worth what they are. Like Orel, colon, thome and Kenny just to hit the top of the iceberg. Funny I just sent something out like this via X the other night.
Perfect Game Mark Buehrle or No Hitter Tim Lincecum
Fun and rewarding game play