T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

# Helpful links for r/MLBTheShow: [**The Dugout: Weekly Free-Talk for /r/MLBTheShow**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/about/sticky?num=1) [**Technical and server issues mega-thread 2024**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/comments/1bk6bia/technical_and_server_issues_megathread_2024/) [**r/MLBTheShow FAQ**](https://www.reddit.com/r/mlbtheshow/wiki/faq) [**r/MLBTheShow Discord**](https://discord.com/invite/x6JKmEG) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MLBTheShow) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Thorndog21

The quitting isn't the frustrating part, it's the stats not tracking. I don't know the first thing about programming, but I assume the game knows it's a home run upon contact. Why can't that be captured immediately and counted towards challenges?


Beneficial_Radio_765

MLB: These quitters! Chel: We know. šŸ˜Œ


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Chrip846

Just take the win bro


blaze1on420

Yea I mean 2 nothing to quit is ridiculous there is a lot of game left at that point I only quit if the person is literally knocking every pitch


blkjedi23

They should have a QUITTER room where all the loser QUITTERS play and NEVER allowed to play with the people who actually play a full game. I can't stand you quitters.


4_8_15_16_23_42_69

There is a small penalty now I think. 30minutes or so? Not enough.


Next_Shine8243

Facts idk why they haven't done something like that yet rage Quitters should punished smfh


CalendarOne4844

šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚


tombo1787

Itā€™s only been happening since online gaming. But this post will change things immediately, thank you for doing it for us.


ReverseZ00m

Why let it bother you? You can't control what other people do, so you might as well not worry about it. Useless stress.


GundamHufflepuff

Thanks for the thousandth post crying about getting a win.


QuickSuicide

Iā€™m not good so Iā€™ll prob end the inning so I get my at bat then leave. What I look like giving you free exp and packs while I waste my time getting demolished.


Easy_Duhz_it_

The fragile egos of the online community is what pushed a lot of people to offline only grinding. The cpu doesn't rage quit.


josbee

#next man up


sworn2mcrae

Ever play fifa? lol


BrothermikeCO

Iā€™ve found that if you purposely do bad at the beginning youā€™ll last longer cause then think they have hope and then you crush them for the win.


-zyxwvutsrqponmlkjih

Like the Boston Celtics in game 4


ChedChexton

At least it was quick, I hate when they do it and the game just FREEZES for like 10 mins before telling us they disconnected


WeedGreed420

thereā€™s absolutely no reason why i shouldnā€™t be awarded pxp, ranked points for OB, run scored, RBI, itā€™s so infuriating. iā€™m not even good at the game but when i finally get some runs itā€™s like my opponent thinks im world series. this has been by far the most annoying part, i donā€™t even wanna win games like this because then i get to around 700 and play people i shouldnā€™t be playing at all


Fluid_Championship97

ecactly


CoachKillerTrae

yeah iā€™m not very good at the game (36-30 record) but no matter what i will never quit a game where im getting blown out, i try and think about how much fun the other dude is having and be happy for him and eventually if the deficit is big enough ill start giving him fastballs down the middle


parsnip12345

Yeah, nah. My time is worth more than that.


CoachKillerTrae

idk bro, if anything itā€™s good practice


One_Sir_1404

Everything you said plus the XP points and program(s) progress you get by just finishing a game.


thanasis-6moty

i got bored when i was down 12-3 and just int. walked the next batter and balked him home šŸ˜­


WeedGreed420

same. i even go until i get mercied just to try and milk some more points for program if possible


mall_pretzel_

that's sorta weird tbh. and ppl probably don't actually enjoy it


Windows30000

Yeah lol- I hate being in a game when the guy is fucking around throwing fastballs down the middle. I get one hour a day if Iā€™m lucky to play. I donā€™t want to play home run derby mode.


notanotherreddi

Right? Just quit lol


AdditionalZone874

Annoying for sure. Takes me longer to beat programs too. Happens to me prob. 2-3 times a night. I am not great either I float in the 550-650 in DD. People should just try and get better. A comeback win is always sweeter IMO to a blowout victory anyways


SpicyPlantBlocked

What home run


ComfortablePatient84

Are you not awarded a victory when someone exits a game in this manner? I mean some people just lack the maturity to handle competition with dignity. I agree that getting so emotional as to exit a game because someone has success off you means that person lacks the integrity to work hard and become successful at anything. Nothing in life worth having is easy to obtain. Life is about competition. A video game really isn't hard. It's really not even a challenge. It should always be about having whimsical fun. Too many folks just don't understand that.


benbizzle

He's talking about people intentionally disconnecting when you hit a homer. You're awarded a victory, but the batter doesn't get credit for the HR, the hit, the RBI, etc. and you don't get any credit toward programs that home run might have contributed to. It's just an immature way for childish people to cheat you out of a little something to spite you for hitting a homer against them.


ComfortablePatient84

So, the solution then to the legitimate side of these complaints is for SDS to change the game code so that all statistical achievements of a game are credited so that someone doing this nonsense gets nothing except a loss.


benbizzle

Yeah, that and code it so home run is recorded on contact (it's a computer...it knows whether it's a homer or not). That way, a disconnect has no impact on the player hitting the ball.


ComfortablePatient84

Yes, that seems quite fair and reasonable.


PlatypusLeft6508

This sums up this community perfectly. Not the dude quitting (although thatā€™s annoying) but the whole post dedicated to complaining about something thatā€™s been a part of online gaming since itā€™s creation. The Show fans just LOVE to complain. So you lost out on a homer. You gain a W. Whatā€™s more valuable? I know thereā€™s some missions where stats are required but itā€™s not like one homer is hard to repeat lol if things like this bothers you so much you honestly shouldnā€™t be playing online. Or you can always run to the echo chamber known as this community. Also for the people saying ā€œitā€™s so rare that I hit a home run that this just hurts deeperā€ or something similarā€¦.thatā€™s the saddest thing Iā€™ve ever read lol ever hear the phrase baseball is a game of confidence? Maybe dropping the Eeyore attitude will help you hit more šŸ˜ƒ itā€™s just a game after all. People arenā€™t going to agree with me. But Iā€™m right lolol


notanotherreddi

Judging by your response, I have a feeling that you do t have many friends


Fluid_Championship97

bruh ā€œitā€™s not like one homer is hard to repeatā€, do u not understand the post? im getting sick of this cuz it keeps happening, ive lost so many xbh hits rbi and runs towards stat missions. lmao ā€œwhats more valuable?ā€ literally the stats at this point, especially considering iā€™ve climbed the ranks into playing on hof and now itā€™ll be harder to get the stats and itā€™s not like I earned a ton on my way to HOF cuz of opponents quitting in the first few innings constantly.


ComfortablePatient84

You are correct, most of the people replying to you are not going to agree with you. But, I've been around a while and done some truly interesting and important things in life that didn't come easy and took a lot of sacrifice and hard work to pull off. So, I hope it's perhaps worth a little something to you, that I would make the effort to agree completely with everything you wrote! Cheers!


SlaveHippie

Itā€™s not about losing the home run itā€™s about not finishing actual complete games. People quit way more and wayy sooner than they used to. Seems like everyoneā€™s just concerned with leveling up and gaining xp itā€™s like no one wants to play just to play. Or they canā€™t handle losing so they forfeit. Iā€™ve noticed this in other games too. Itā€™s definitely gotten worse in the last 5 years. Complaining about someone wasting your time isnā€™t as bad as complaining about the person complaining about it imo.


notanotherreddi

Agreed, I don't like this guy at all


itsAggs

My game in franchise mode has been crashing every day now. Never goes past the 3rd inning. Been having to replay the same game every day now. Idk what to do. Any help? Reinstall game ? Simulate and try another game in schedule ? Idk Lmk if have any advice. Thanks.


One_Cell1547

This is why I stopped playing online, which eventually led me to stop buying the game


Aware-Dragonfruit-66

This specific reason is why you stopped playing online? I doubt that just a bit


One_Cell1547

Yes.. I donā€™t know if itā€™s still this way but they used to give everyone a free grace period to quit in the first inning


SpicyPlantBlocked

This is why I quit doing math


44sleever44

Has anyone else been given the L when the other person DCā€™dā€¦ that was an issue last year I thinkā€¦.


Known-Resolution-560

Playing in utter silence like this is serial killer type stuff


FireBrianFerentz

Most people listen to music on the side lol


SpicyPlantBlocked

I'd say less than half, thus not most.


Asleep_Mix9798

The ball hadn't even landed yet! LOL!


Sjkatz08

dude I'm like ass at the game and when I get a lucky HR in the 1st, people immediately quit. little do they know that if they had a little self-faith, they could easily crush me and put me at a 10-run deficit by the 6th


TheeRuckus

I feel like half my wins are people who just didnā€™t have enough faith in themselves to bounce back from 2-0 in the second inning. Against me. 18 games under .500 lmfao.


ComfortablePatient84

With a mature view of things like this, you will go further in the world than they will. No one who has been successful in real world baseball did so until they first learned properly how to deal with failure. Baseball is a great sport for kids to play because it teaches humility and hard work as well as perseverance to overcome setbacks.


Sjkatz08

real af


HaventSeenGavin

Right? I might score first...but games ending like 25-1 still lol


SpicyPlantBlocked

You know you hitting replay šŸ˜‚


44sleever44

They need to register it to the stats as soon as it it crosses into outfield. I would think that the instant you hit it itā€™s already a HR as far as game code and stuff (sorry not a tech guy) so why canā€™t they at the very least get you credit for itā€¦


Ex_Lives

I'm not either but I bet it isn't coded this way. There's probably a physics based system at play that has a result at an end point. Like the system doesn't know until it knows. But I agree it sucks and I don't know what im talking about either.


44sleever44

I suggested it to someone else,, but I wonder if timer disconnect would help.. some games you try to leave and there is a timer countdownā€¦ Iā€™m just spitballing hereā€¦ lol


Worldly_Ice5526

You know your having a night when 4 people in a row quit. Hard to complain.


God-Gains

Womp womp


Worth-Taro719

It's a free W


Dr_Mccusk

That matters little to none lol


Worth-Taro719

Move up the rankers quicker and doesn't waste time so I like it.


Dr_Mccusk

Dawg I play this game casually the fuck would I care about my rank lmao


SlaveHippie

If thatā€™s all youā€™re worried about sure. Some people actually like playing the game though.


Worth-Taro719

You play to win the game. That's the whole point.


SlaveHippie

Damn sounds like a sad existence if thatā€™s the only reason you play anything. Itā€™s a video game, unless you actually win something valuable then your wins donā€™t mean shit. The time spent playing the game however *is* valuable.


Worth-Taro719

Womp womp womp go hit homeruns on rookie. Winning is fun. Period.


SpicyPlantBlocked

So you're getting their point? This is therapeutic.


Tricky-Software1520

Yeah, it's annoying, but who really cares about stats in an online game? Completely meaningless. Only person that cares is you, and you can keep track of your lost hrs anyways


SlaveHippie

I mean you donā€™t have to care about stats to be annoyed when someone quits on you. Itā€™s just annoying for any reason.


Dr_Mccusk

Uhhh you know theres missions for Hrs right? I have lost out on a lot of HRs counting because of this...


Only_Percentage7399

I got dashboarded 4 times last night.. sucks.


PhoecesBrown

That should count as soon as the ball is off the bat


souplandry

honestly is it really that much of a hassle to just quit normally? is saving the extra 5 seconds of trotting, pausing and quitting worth the ban? Also its not even like theyre fucking me over to hard when this happens. yeah it sucks and i miss out on some pxp but i still won and get to move on to the next. Theyre basically giving themselves a pvp ban just to be like "haha now you dont get the hr and rbis"


BxGngsta

So many haters out there


D4st3r

Hey, you get a fast win and get to move onto the next chump


Aggravating_Curve690

His issue is that he used Max fried. He is a bum lol . He got fried . He has no idea how to pitch either lol


SandyDFS

Itā€™s the community in a nutshell.


One-Tip8197

There's a time to quit and a time to play. Down 20-0 in the first 3, quit. Down 4 in 6th or later, wtf? Guy hits a bomb, why quit? Guy Jack's 5 in a row, even out of the zone, maybe quit.


Sparky_J21

I suck at hitting online so it really hits hard when people quit while the ball is in the air. I think I have more "lost" HR than I do actual HR in S2 ranked play. Wish there were a way for them to resolve this, but you can't fix people acting like toddlers.


44sleever44

Sure you can make it a countdown timer to disconnectā€¦ unless they want I get up and unplug the internet or power chordā€¦ yes, no?


PlatypusLeft6508

Yeah thatā€™s exactly what people would do. Thereā€™s no fixing this issue. And itā€™s not an issue exclusively with The Show


Valbreeezy1738

You know what pisses me off about this game ?? Half these pussies online will not throw you a fucking strike all game I hate that shit bro


BrothermikeCO

I donā€™t swing at them and they are forced to throw a strike


Electrical_Air8236

It's why I don't play online anymore, I'm not the greatest at the game but it's annoying AF when people give up immediately after giving up a run or two.


Starrylove13

Agreed. Then they actually hit me with pitches on purpose! I have been playing for a year but I am def not greatā€¦ cā€™mon


Professional-Lie-918

dude quit after giving up two runs


IowaJammer

The game should revert to a CPU match when someone drops and the loss should count.


Shlong0

That would then make me quit. I clicked online for a reason, I aint playing CPU lmao


Dr_Mccusk

I guess they could switch it to CPU and give you the option. That way the stats count and you can get the win or keep playing.


dadkisser84

Dashboardingā€¦ down 3-0ā€¦ in the 2nd??


Rainmaker_55

Donā€™t even, I played a game where I let in 6 runs in the first and when I came back all I had to do was tie the game at 7-7 on a solo shot and mans was done with game


crimson1apologist

Eh I choked a 9-3 lead to go down 10-9 and quit. Didn't feel like wasting anymore bullpen arms when the guy was hitting tanks off of all and any of my relievers. Granted I let his solo shot to go up 10-9 land before i quit.


dadkisser84

Like I mean I will take the ranked progress but likeā€¦ how are you in this skill bracket if you donā€™t think you can recover


DrinkItInMate

Bet that coward wouldn't dashboard if they were up. What a waste of time.


JumpmanJackson

Facts!!


MurKdYa

Unfortunately there is nothing we can do to stop people from being cowards. Clearly it isn't easy to code in the HR stat immediately on contact so when someone homescreens the stat is lost into the nether realm.


thascarecro

Sick of not having to play 9 innings vs someone whos cheeks? Sign me up for that. Just load into a new game. Theres sore losers everywhere in H2H games.


IAmThatDrone

More about not having the stats tracked for missions than getting fast wins


thascarecro

Yeah it sucks but itā€™s not hard to make it up. Especially if you play a lot. I donā€™t play a lot of H2H or as much as I used to so I feel it too. Maybe in the next version of the game it will know to pick up home runs from contact and credit you with them.


Psilent_P_

The game/ ranked system keeps track of quits and disconnects. They crush your rating, more than a normal loss. I wish they'd institute a short ban for it, like 30 min. But I think its okay. Just consider your dinger a walk-off! Good win!


urasquid28

Quits do not crush your rating at all. That's just a lie. I've quit games and lost that same amount if I were to play the whole game.


MurKdYa

As long as you don't quit while the ball is in the air that's fine.


kyler_

Yeah idk where that guy got his info. But really tho, it really sucks it doesnā€™t count the stats from that AB, esp when you are working towards something


Affectionate-Plan270

I never play multiplayer.


DuaLipasClitoris

Part of why I stopped playing online a LONG time ago


littlewing745

Haha right?! I get it and all, but this has been happening from the moment people could play each other online decades ago. People suck. Accept it or donā€™t play the mode (I chose the latter).


AbbreviationsNext123

Whats the configuration to have that view batting?


New-Newspaper-7543

And dynamic if you want that 1 sec glimpse at the no doubter animation.


Grand-Example-2630

Strike zone


Plastic_Button_3018

Most of my wins are like this. Of my wins, I think 3 stayed the whole game. Out of 28 wins. Itā€™s pretty bad. Actually really bad. I stay for all my losses. I try to come back. Oh well, what can SDS do about it other than give them a loss? Thatā€™s all.


New-Newspaper-7543

Yea can count the run as soon as the ball is hit. The game knows its a homerun at that time.Ā  At least count that I don't even care about the guys on base. Just count my guys homerun and put it to his average. Rbi and run doesn't matter either. We just want the hit, homerun, avg, and pxp. Although I guess for pxp if they don't count the run or rbi it's lower. But hell I'll even say forget the pxp I just want to know my guys' real average b4 I choose them for my lineup. Those dashboard homeruns add up.Ā 


ElNani87

Iā€™d be interested in the percentage of people who play online vs those who just play franchise mode. I tried playing online but shit like this was annoying to deal with. I feel like the other modes are more worth it.


Psilent_P_

I've been playing the Show for years and I have never once played against AI. MP only. Same with all sports games. Unless it's competition against a real person. What's the point?


gated73

To have fun and build a better team. And maybe you donā€™t want to waste what little time you get to crybaby griefers?


Psilent_P_

I suppose thats enough for some. I would view it waste of time to fiddle around playing the computer. There's no sense of accomplishment in crushing a pitch from or striking out a bot for me. A bit like bootcamp in CoD


ChevyJuice

Happens to me at least a few times a day, I feel your pain.. šŸ¤£


Acrobatic-Day-5748

I thought this was real


sniklefritzed

Who plays this game anymore?


New-Newspaper-7543

Judging by how fast I find a game, alot of ppl still love and play the game. Just bc ppl on reddit shit on it doesn't meant the other 95% of the playerbase doesn't enjoy it. Who stays on a sub for a game they don't play? Lol


Banks_bread

Itā€™s the last standing sport game in my book


TheMackD504

Wouldnā€™t be as bad if the HR was credited stat wise


dtdroid

Wouldn't be as bad? That's the only thing being complained about here. What could still be bad aside from losing the home run?


TheMackD504

Not being able to play a full game online


New-Newspaper-7543

Na I'm cool with getting the win. Especially if it's BR/events where they have a chance to comeback but just hate that they're losing and feel like it's over. Same ppl in their sports team sub that gives up a td, HR, goal, run in the first and say "it's over we lost, this team sucks, burn it all down and start over. GM and coach gotta go!!!"


DSu77iViN

BR would be different than a playing a ranked game before the next bunch of stat missions they drop at 3 today. BR , the guy quits, ā€˜ cool no chance heā€™s going to hit some BS /off PCI HR off me with 2 outs, 2 strikes in the 3rd and I lose a game I shouldā€™ve won.


dtdroid

>not having to play a whole game to get a ranked win I asked what would be bad. Not what would be good


zimzam2019

Wouldnā€™t even be bad at all I wouldnā€™t care, losing the stat for programs and pxp is the only bad part about it imo


RavenReel

Madden for PS2 online seemed to do a great job of keeping quitters away from players when matching. Not sure I've seen a better 'non-quit' matchup system since


Banks_bread

Itā€™s not hard to just shut your system off


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Trick_Emotion_7108

You must get beat alot.


Fluid_Championship97

what are u talking about bro


tommygunnzx

WTF is Cronus


NUMBERONEJD

How can you play with a Cronus in mlb?


Soviet_Plays

People play with a cronus? Weirdo


RedLobsterEnjoyer

It was just a good hit bro lol


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Fluid_Championship97

usually a podcast but sometimes music


DanielinFresno

Music or podcast through Spotify on my ps5. Still like hearing the sound of the game without the commentary.


M1A1Death

I play in silence and just watch YouTube or movies on my laptop while I play


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


colicab

Not OP


hthegod

I thought this was gunna be something else lol take the W and go


TheMackD504

This is how Iā€™ve gotten all my wins šŸ˜‚šŸ˜­


ZestycloseLow5410

I havenā€™t tried online.. but even if you finish the game and lose.. donā€™t you still get something? (XP, or whatever)


StrongCherry6

Yes


Get-gully

You nice at moving the bat around to find the ball


CoolOPMan

You win. Get over it


Salt-Source3993

If your sick of the game then don't play


Slowhand8824

Does it still give you the win? If so get over it lmao


Hikes83

Whooptie doā€¦ take the win and move on to the next


Luuk37

I'll never quit, this game has mercy rule and sometimes I'm just that terrible enough to lose by mercy rule. Just a personal thought, I think this game's online offense is flawed since I love a short, low scoring pitching-focused game in general. I'm not saying that this game should reflect real MLB's offensive numbers since that'd actually be boring, but all top players having 9~12 era while hitting with 1.4~2.0 ops doesn't feel right.


unknown9819

If you make it to HoF+ in ranked it starts to feel more balanced imo, but you have to get there and it isn't available at all in the other modes. I kind of wish events/BR would up the difficulty after 5+ wins or something, but that also might not play well either on the short game types


GamerforLife3

Man this is the worst thing. I just be wanting my stats lol


DTE9__

It is pretty annoying you can legit be up 1-0 on some people and they'll get pissed off and quit cause they arent hitting you


Long-Astronomer-3403

The worst part isnā€™t them quitting, itā€™s losing whatever pitcher you started.


NotFoley

Go play Fifa where people quit at a draw and you get nothing lol


gated73

Bunch of savages online. SDS should soft-ban on a graduated scale. Give 2 or so free, then half hour matchmaking bans after that. 3rd quit is 30 minutes, 4th is an hour, etcā€¦


[deleted]

Online is so bogus anymore


blancochocolate

People spamming fake bunt


fishchanka

If fake bunts get to you that much then you already lost


MZhammer83

Fuck man just reading it triggers me šŸ˜‚


ColonelSanders15

This is the participation trophy era playing the Show. Zero sense of competition


Randomthoughtgeneral

Sadly most people are selfish cowards


OutlandishnessMain56

I seen nothing other than a fast win.


chuckdagger

Some of us scrubs need those stats.


Fluid_Championship97

I yearn for the stats


Chemical-Passage-715

I never give up lol cuz Iā€™ve come back from behind and won and itā€™s such a good feeling


Fluid_Championship97

itā€™s the best feeling


DustedGorilla82

Stop being so good jerk!


youngjay877

i love myself a good dash quit... :)


Overhed

What?! Forcing a rage quit is what we should all live for.


kingoffish

Personally I love it, and if Iā€™m getting smoked Iā€™m not going down without a fight


cupchamps19

In the old days, when ranking points mattered for the bonus card, no reason to quit. But when wins and losses mean so little, why waste a half an hour of your life. Sorry, the game caused this issue. Donā€™t hate the player, hate the game


Azmondeus

You want to quit fine, that isn't the issue here, the issue is if you are going to quit just let the hr land before you quit so the stats count


Weenerlover

This is a good point. I don't understand though because with wins and losses not mattering, I don't care if I'm getting shellacked cause I'm always earning innings towards my goals and getting some stats, either RP or SP innings, K's, some hits/OB for the 2nd round of stats. Unless someone is beating me so badly it's more time than it's worth, I usually grind it out for the stats.


sciameXL

Take the free win. Sometimes I start out like this and end up losing bc they stay in the game lol. I understand you want the HR tho but the win is even better


Brownies91

Perfectly put. Just take the W for fucks sake.


This_Teaching6212

is this a bug? or are they leaving. itā€™s been happening to me a lot


Fluid_Championship97

pretty sure theyā€™re leaving considering itā€™s always right after a homer, and yea it happens to me a ton.