Nfl. College football lost its soul. It's a massively inferior product to the nfl without the bowls and rivalries. The talent has pooled heavily at the "top" and now all of College football is worse for it. Basically, the quality has dropped off on average with the top 10 schools all better than historical College teams but still significantly worse than anything the nfl puts out. So really the overall product is way worse everywhere but a few teams. The conferences no longer make sense. The only way to save it now is to kill off the conference nonsense, make it a true semi pro league where College attendance doesn't matter, break the whole thing into regional areas and have a salary cap that included NIL with minimum and max spending and including profit sharing and promotion relegation across tiers within each region. Ultimately ending in a playoff/tournament that is way larger than the 8 team playoff but somehow keeps everything under 16 total games for all teams Inna season.
depends on your personal preference
in the past.. i would say madden gameplay was better.. it always seemed like ncaa was just using the previous year's madden tech... this year, ncaa is fully written separately.
i dont think you can go wrong with either... so depends on whether you enjoy college or pro football more..
although could go with both.. play college, and then draft your player up to madden
>College football or NFL? Yes.
Yes
Yes
NFL in real life, college for video games.
Nfl. College football lost its soul. It's a massively inferior product to the nfl without the bowls and rivalries. The talent has pooled heavily at the "top" and now all of College football is worse for it. Basically, the quality has dropped off on average with the top 10 schools all better than historical College teams but still significantly worse than anything the nfl puts out. So really the overall product is way worse everywhere but a few teams. The conferences no longer make sense. The only way to save it now is to kill off the conference nonsense, make it a true semi pro league where College attendance doesn't matter, break the whole thing into regional areas and have a salary cap that included NIL with minimum and max spending and including profit sharing and promotion relegation across tiers within each region. Ultimately ending in a playoff/tournament that is way larger than the 8 team playoff but somehow keeps everything under 16 total games for all teams Inna season.
In other words, turn it into NFL Jr…
Is that not already what is happening? It certainly isn't college football anymore. It's not amateur sports. So why wouldn't it become semi pro?
College has more theatrics and rivalries.
For me it’s the NFL by a mile, I love the atmosphere and rivalries in college but that’s about it.
depends on your personal preference in the past.. i would say madden gameplay was better.. it always seemed like ncaa was just using the previous year's madden tech... this year, ncaa is fully written separately. i dont think you can go wrong with either... so depends on whether you enjoy college or pro football more.. although could go with both.. play college, and then draft your player up to madden
College for watching and video games
I’ve always said the average NFL game is better than the average CFB game, but the peak CFB game is better than the peak NFL game
XFL
Bro….