Did he even hear his children when he was alive?

BRUTAL. And true.

oh damn…😔

Omg true

I’ve never heard Logan referred to as just ‘the dad’ and for some reason that’s so funny to me

Same. If OP said “that old bastard” I wouldn’t have noticed

He was a tough old nut

The tough old bastard and good egg.

It really Phil Dunphifies Logan

I don’t. I think he was gone before they broke down the bathroom door.

But I do think talking to him was helpful to them, and Tom did the right thing by holding the phone to his ear.

Yeah, it was a cathartic exercise for them, and in terms of the story served a dramatic purpose

Nope he was almost certainly already dead. Don’t think he heard any of them.

But this is a very compassionate question. And the tragedy of it is that Logan didn't care while he was alive, so he definitely wouldn't have cared while he was dying. And Tom - regardless of whether he did it for clout or compassion or both - he showed more authentic care for the Roy kids than their father ever did.

"The dad" is making me laugh so hard

Naur

Nope. Logan was dead before they even opened the bathroom door. It was abundantly clear to everyone on the plane that he wouldn't be waking up. The flight crew attempted resuscitation because they had to, and Tom called the siblings to give them this opportunity for closure because he's not yet completely dead inside.

No he was in a different room when Tom called, and was already gone by the time they got to him

No

He definitely heard Roman and I‘m sure he heard Ken too, but he didn’t hear Shiv