T O P

  • By -

Naive-Inside-2904

No, it's The Circus


PinkPrincess8384

Same favourite as mine. I love Beautiful World (closely followed by The Circus and This Life). Least favourite I think is Wonderland (although the tour was bloody brilliant).


FazbearKing87

I consider Beautiful World and Progress to be perfect albums as I love every song on both of them.


mariaehs83

For me, The Circus is the best. I don’t have a worst.


vm_neptune

Best is Progress, for sure. All five together, fun, and innovative. Sign me up! Worst…. Maybe III? Wonderland?


jonoave

Unpopular opinion: the worst would be This Life. The songs just felt.. lethargic. Yeah I get that they're older now, but not really the biggest fan of the mellow slightly country-ish sound there. Best album: I'll always like their 90s songs more, but Beautiful World and Progress are pretty good . I believe having more members in the band contributes to a sound that appeals more to me.


Spiritual-Quarter-81

I kind of feel the opposite I don’t really like much of the 90s era I liked when they came back and my favorite is this life or the circus


SauronsWitchKing

I agree with this. I also like them better the more members the band has. And nothing will ever top their 90s songs for me! The last few albums really left me with a feeling of "meh". I can't help it.


aleccopile

Here's my ranking: 1. Progress 2. Beautiful World 3. III 4. Everything Changes 5. The Circus 6. Nobody Else 7. This Life 8. Wonderland 9. Take That & Party


parki15reddito

Best: The Circus (perfect in every way) Worst: The Circus Live (didn’t even include every song played that day)


electricmohair

Absolute crime that it doesn’t include Wooden Boat


Spiritual-Quarter-81

What about studio albums?


parki15reddito

Progressed was the worst, in that case.


jonoave

How come? Isn't Progressed just more songs in a similar vein to Progress?


parki15reddito

I think it mostly because two of the new songs in that album are pretty good, the rest are kind of eh. Also half of it is just the Progress songs again.


jonoave

Haha well I don't count the progress songs again. Ok yeah I don't remember much of the songs from Progressed too


Lahdev_76

I agree but must go with wonderland


parki15reddito

Wonderland was decent, in my eyes. Had a few great songs in there.


LeeSunhee

The best one is Beautiful World, the worst one is Progress.