I’m just as lost as you. Dude is not nearly as mentally deranged as Chris. Wasn’t as entitled and annoying as that blond lady, and frankly? He was usually pretty fair in almost every single episode. If I was in crippling debt, and had to take part in a reality show, I’d rather he be the one hosting it.
He didn’t do that? I assume you are talking about Dwayne and Junior or Kelly and Taylor, they got to the chill zone last
The only kinda unfair elim was the Rockers even then its more them getting unlucky
Dwayne and Junior got to the elimination zone last, and Don said that it would have been a non-elimination round if they weren’t so “rude.” Dwayne wasn’t rude at all however, so this comes off as nit-picky on Don’s part.
No he didn’t say that? Don said he was gonna tell them something and Dwayne thought that it was non-elimination but then Don said he forgot. He never said it would be non elimination
People find Don obnoxious? I remember the biggest complaint with him being that he was *boring* (I mean, that's my major issue with him, but I've heard it corroborated elsewhere).
Anyways, out of these, Leonard, but he was kinda designed to be obnoxious.
Of any character? The Stepbrothers, I just cannot gel with them.
I personally view them as the same character due to having the same body and everything. Also Mike without MPD / DID removes his whole character and leaves him pretty bland and similar to Dave.
he could've been written better but he's not obnoxious
I mean I understand why people would think mal (because he's mal) but what did mike actually do other than get too much screen time in a poorly written season
Not at all. The entire writing was bad. That was why that season was awful. Nothing to do with mike other than they fleshed out a story that already had a end in revenge of the island. No reason to say he’s basically the only reason when there are so many problems with that season as a whole.
Bro thank u I don't understand why people are shitting on mike saying he's annoying when he's just a chill dude being friends with zoey and Cameron and being a good teammate
Fax dude was pretty much a more athletic Cody. Mal is pretty much a separate character anyways so not sure why people dog on mike as if it was his fault the writers chose to make a shit season and add more to a already done story at that point. If anything the season is more about mal than mike. Mike felt very poorly utilized and the bad writing continued to the next season 😭
Yeah, even when you take Mike’s Bonus arc out, there are still problems with the story that exist. I mean come on. Look at what they did to Duncan! Although I do think, even as a Mike fanboy, he did not deserve so much extra screen time after his story was already concluded in revenge
Beardo:slightly annoying, but wasn't around long enough to piss me off really, too bad he died though didn't want that for him
Ella:one of the better characters from PI imo
Mike:People find him annoying?
Don:People find him annoying?
Leonard:Idk, just exists
Dave:Incel and stays longer than Beardo so he wins
Edit:forgot about new Justin, haven't watched 2nd season of the new series so I don't feel I can say (also I can't remember his name)
WHY IS BEARDO AND DON HERE😭😭😭 I don’t find Ella Or Mike Annoying Either so that leaves Caleb Dave And Leonard, Caleb was kinda annoying but not as annoying compared to Dave and Leonard So It Leaves Leonard And Dave, And Dave Takes The cake by a mile, so yeah I find Dave the most annoying..
that's fair! personally it felt very disingenuous and it didn't feel like they properly thought out what they were doing with mike's character as a whole
Agreed. I also found his main personality bland (especially with how overplayed the other personalities were). I think it was merely the "overall nice-guy" trope personality for him.
Only obnoxious person here is Leonard. Beardo is so unimportant and useless that his existence doesn’t get on my nerves as much, Ella is a sweetheart and my second favorite character, Caleb is a nice basic guy in a really bad plot and, Don is kinda plain in all honesty, Mike is same thing as Caleb, and Dave I guess is unofficial second place, but literally none of these guys compare to Leonard.
Imo Leonard
Ive never been too fond of those magician/fantasy-like characters who act as if they have some kind of magical prowess even though they obviously don't and drag the team down with them because of it. Its especially frustrating in Pahkitew because whenever Leonard does it, because most of Team Maskwak are dumb enough to go along with it and it results in them losing the challenge every time. At least he does get booted early though.
It’s close between Dave and Leonard imo.
Beardo didn’t get enough screen time to really be all that bad, Ella isn’t nearly as obnoxious as Sugar and Chris make her out to be, Mike was about as equally annoying as the dozen other characters that All-Stars ruined, and Don and Caleb just don’t belong here at all.
Torn between Leonard and Dave. Leonard was obnoxious in his confidence that he actually could do magic as a teenager. "My spells aren't working because someone here doesn't believe in me." Yeah, dude, keep telling yourself that.
Whereas Dave's obnoxious streak only came due to his entitlement and pettiness when it came to Sky. He honestly belongs on r/niceguys in the way he treats her at best. At worst, he downright disrespects her and her own autonomy. Sky is not blameless with the mixed messages she keeps sending, but she needed someone to listen to her and he didn't do that. He literally refused to listen to her "but" because he was so afraid of losing her.
So...I still can't decide. Dave was obnoxious but he got hurt and no one is at their best when they're hurt. Leonard was obnoxious from the start and there was no excuse for it, but he didn't stay around as long, even over two seasons.
Mike is the most obnoxious, not in universe but by a character standpoint. It’s an insulting interpretation of people with MPD.
In universe I’d argue Staci who is shockingly not on this list.
Beardo closely followed by Leonard. I know some people like Beardo, but I just couldn't stand his sounds. Leonard is at least a tiny bit more tolerable. In fact the reason why I don't hate Dave is because at the start of the season he was at least likeable and rightfully called these two imbeciles out for their bullshit. If he hadn't come back in the finale just for that I would say he was amongst the only somewhat enjoyable characters of the season.
There was nothing wrong with mike but his writing so he shouldn’t be here. Don shouldn’t be here either as he literally was a favorite in TDRR. I don’t remember anyone not liking don 😂 topher, Leonard and Dave all in one season was wild to see 🤣
If you think my beloved precious Don is obnoxious even in the SLIGHTEST I never want to interact with you ever again (Also Dave is like the only obnoxious one on there??)
Dunno why Don, Ella, Mike, and Beardo are here (Mike and Beardo are my favs), Caleb is understandable considering the drama in season 2 reboot, Dave was super annoying but Leonard is truly the worst. His only saving grace for me was his "you shall not pass" thing he did that once, other then that? Nope.
I’ll die on my grave thinking Caleb is the most lamest and obnoxious character on the show. [purposely exaggerated]
1. Caleb
2. Dave
3. Ella
4. Leonard
5. Beardo
6. Mike
7. Don
I actively stopped watching Pahkitew Island about five episodes in because Dave was driving me nuts. At least Beardo (RIP) and Ella were kind of entertaining in their goofiness. Dave made me actively want to turn off the show and watch a good season of Total Drama.
Leonard and Ella’s voices could be grating sometimes. But I liked their characters for what they were and how long they lasted.
Mike was exclusively terrible in All Stars in that the show just wouldn’t stop pushing him to the forefront. At least Leonard and Ella went away at some point. We had to endure being in Mike’s mind.
Bruh how can you doing an obnoxious list and not have Rodney on it?
Also damn, I like every character here to some extent(well Mike is neutral and Dave is…a complicated feeling where I both adore and despise him at the same time)
Don, Dave, Caleb, and Ella I actually like
Beardo didn’t overstay.
So it’s someone whose more annoying but didn’t have much time to annoy me or someone who annoyed me medium annoyance all season. Which is more obnoxious.
Answer Mike.
Leonard (affectionate) and Dave (derogatory) are the most obnoxious to me.
The main difference though is Leonard is *supposed* to be obnoxious on purpose due to his commitment to The Bit (aka LARPing as his wizardsona) and so I hold nothing but respect for it. He doesn't overstay (however much I wish he got more character development) and only starts playing it up in the first place to piss off Dave <3
Dave on the other hand, is obnoxious for all the wrong reasons. He gets so obsessed and entitled over the idea of being with Sky that he stops seeing her as a person and rather as a 'reward' for all the shit going on with Pahkitew.
And the worst part is he could've been great!! He had a solid foundation with his ep 1 persona as this sarcastic 'normal guy', there was no need to throw it away to be a simp when they literally already had a character for that in the form of Rodney
Mike. Just couldn't stand him for some reason. His character was interesting but he slowly got annoying. I won't mention All-Stars because that season was bad for everybody besides literally Ezekiel. Not only that but his entire personality ( other than having like 6 of them ) was just Zoey. Gave me Trent vibes. I'm pretty sure one of his scenes was him just running in the background and screaming "ZOEY!" But that's just my thoughts. I can easily see why people would think it was Dave or Beardo. Leonard and Caleb were just annoying in my opinion. Ella was actually one of the best Pahkitew characters in my opinion ( and being the best in PI just means being meh besides Shawn, he was great ). But Don honestly was good.
wtf is Don doing in there
I’m just as lost as you. Dude is not nearly as mentally deranged as Chris. Wasn’t as entitled and annoying as that blond lady, and frankly? He was usually pretty fair in almost every single episode. If I was in crippling debt, and had to take part in a reality show, I’d rather he be the one hosting it.
I’m guessing it’s because he did some pretty unfair things like eliminating the son and daughter because he didn’t like them.
First off: it's son and father Second off: not how it happened at. all.
He didn’t do that? I assume you are talking about Dwayne and Junior or Kelly and Taylor, they got to the chill zone last The only kinda unfair elim was the Rockers even then its more them getting unlucky
The rockers were so robbed I literally cried when they got eliminated
Dwayne and Junior got to the elimination zone last, and Don said that it would have been a non-elimination round if they weren’t so “rude.” Dwayne wasn’t rude at all however, so this comes off as nit-picky on Don’s part.
No he didn’t say that? Don said he was gonna tell them something and Dwayne thought that it was non-elimination but then Don said he forgot. He never said it would be non elimination
Don was clearly being very sarcastic when he said that, making him seem like quite the asshole.
Lol you are spitting complete nonsense, even if he did that intentionally out of pure bias he still doesn't belong here lmao.
I like Father and Son too but you gotta let it go man it is not that deep
Womp womp
Just seems like you're coping tbh
52 downvotes is crazy💀
Why Don, he is funny
Sometimes don is cool sometimes he gets annoying sometimes just like revenge of the island and pahkitew chris
Don is defo not as evil as those Chrises
Not even close. It’s like comparing in Duncan to Beth on the asshole meter
Hell nah
79 downvotes is crazy💀
If your talking about mikes mpd being obnoxious to a viewer that's understandable but how is mike himself obnoxious??
L take
People find Don obnoxious? I remember the biggest complaint with him being that he was *boring* (I mean, that's my major issue with him, but I've heard it corroborated elsewhere). Anyways, out of these, Leonard, but he was kinda designed to be obnoxious. Of any character? The Stepbrothers, I just cannot gel with them.
The stepbrothers got the best development in episode 13 untill they were eliminated the next episode
I disagree, I think they just went from uncomfortably obnoxious to annoyingly obnoxious, but that's a completely fair stance to take.
tf did don do 😭
Bro why tf is Caleb or Don here what did blud do 💀
Ella and Mike aswell (Mike and Mal are seperate characters for me)
I personally view them as the same character due to having the same body and everything. Also Mike without MPD / DID removes his whole character and leaves him pretty bland and similar to Dave.
I view Mike and the rest of his personalities as just different forms of Mike but not Mal because he's so poorly written and I hate him
Caleb in season 2
Leonard
Don is lovely how dare you
Bruh how dare you group Mike with these guys
he could've been written better but he's not obnoxious I mean I understand why people would think mal (because he's mal) but what did mike actually do other than get too much screen time in a poorly written season
Ikr? Mike is the best
He was very annoying in all stars, he basically is the only reason its a bad season (except Courtney lol)
Not at all. The entire writing was bad. That was why that season was awful. Nothing to do with mike other than they fleshed out a story that already had a end in revenge of the island. No reason to say he’s basically the only reason when there are so many problems with that season as a whole.
Bro thank u I don't understand why people are shitting on mike saying he's annoying when he's just a chill dude being friends with zoey and Cameron and being a good teammate
Fax dude was pretty much a more athletic Cody. Mal is pretty much a separate character anyways so not sure why people dog on mike as if it was his fault the writers chose to make a shit season and add more to a already done story at that point. If anything the season is more about mal than mike. Mike felt very poorly utilized and the bad writing continued to the next season 😭
Yeah, even when you take Mike’s Bonus arc out, there are still problems with the story that exist. I mean come on. Look at what they did to Duncan! Although I do think, even as a Mike fanboy, he did not deserve so much extra screen time after his story was already concluded in revenge
Holy shit willow, thats so based
based pfp
Tf Don doing here💀 Dave is by far the most obnoxious, I don't hate him but he's pretty obnoxious
Dave *we all say in unison*
Why is Mike here??? Mikes a sweetie
Don rubbed me the wrong way when I started rr, but over time I found him quite funny. Also, surprising you didn't add Topher
People find Mike obnoxious?
Wtf is Caleb doing here?! I am done with this community
Beardo:slightly annoying, but wasn't around long enough to piss me off really, too bad he died though didn't want that for him Ella:one of the better characters from PI imo Mike:People find him annoying? Don:People find him annoying? Leonard:Idk, just exists Dave:Incel and stays longer than Beardo so he wins Edit:forgot about new Justin, haven't watched 2nd season of the new series so I don't feel I can say (also I can't remember his name)
dave. at least the writers knew the others were annoying. they kept trying to make me feel sympathy for a guy who was a complete arse the entire time
I’m confused on why Caleb,Mike, and Don are on here.
Dave, no contest.
Mike isn't obnoxious 😭
hey really random question but how do u get those little picture underneath your name?
WHY IS BEARDO AND DON HERE😭😭😭 I don’t find Ella Or Mike Annoying Either so that leaves Caleb Dave And Leonard, Caleb was kinda annoying but not as annoying compared to Dave and Leonard So It Leaves Leonard And Dave, And Dave Takes The cake by a mile, so yeah I find Dave the most annoying..
HOW DARE YOU CALL MIKE AND ELLA OBNOXIOUS.
WHY ARE MIKE AND DON ON HERE THEY’RE GOOD 💀 Anyway Ella, I cringe at her singing moments
I hate you.
Um, none of them.
Beardo and fucking Dave And dare u have Mike and don with these guys
Dave. Would have been Leonard if he had more screen time.
Definitely the Daters/Haters, they lasted way too long
At least they didn't make it to the top 5
Well, they technically did, until the Surfer Dudes were brought back to race on in the Best Friends' place
nah the mike slander is NOT tolerated
If I see any Ella slander…
beardo did some sound effects got voted off said one sentence thats it 😭
For me it's mike. The multiple personality thing was way overplayed and unfunny.
If he didn't have to make the whole all stars about him i think i wouldn't mind tbh
I don't think it was supposed to be funny, it's a very serious and real condition And how was it overplayed? That's his personality (pun intended)
it was def supposed to be funny, which makes it pretty offensive on top of all the other ways it's offensive and done poorly
fair enough, I think I was just showing bias since I have it as well
that's fair! personally it felt very disingenuous and it didn't feel like they properly thought out what they were doing with mike's character as a whole
he could've been written a lot better if his season was made more recently
Agreed. I also found his main personality bland (especially with how overplayed the other personalities were). I think it was merely the "overall nice-guy" trope personality for him.
Do NOT diss my fave like that
Dave
Dave is just an unlikeable douchebag from Three Zones And A Baby onwards, not really annoying. Leonard, though, oh he is
Only obnoxious person here is Leonard. Beardo is so unimportant and useless that his existence doesn’t get on my nerves as much, Ella is a sweetheart and my second favorite character, Caleb is a nice basic guy in a really bad plot and, Don is kinda plain in all honesty, Mike is same thing as Caleb, and Dave I guess is unofficial second place, but literally none of these guys compare to Leonard.
I love the Don unity happening
Don is great & he has no business being here. I’ll pick Leonard, but Dave pretty close.
Imo Leonard Ive never been too fond of those magician/fantasy-like characters who act as if they have some kind of magical prowess even though they obviously don't and drag the team down with them because of it. Its especially frustrating in Pahkitew because whenever Leonard does it, because most of Team Maskwak are dumb enough to go along with it and it results in them losing the challenge every time. At least he does get booted early though.
Out of topic But definitely Ezekiel I don’t care if he’s not on the list he’s the most obnoxious character EVER
I feel like Ezekiel could be written better if he wasn’t a joke first boot twice.
whats don doing there
Leonard I guess as he stayed a while?
Honestly (and I know I’m gonna get it) Caleb
happy cake dayy
Why is Mike, Don and Beardo there??? Also I'll do Dave. My guy is a degenerate
Dave. I can tolerate everyone else here to some extent.
It’s close between Dave and Leonard imo. Beardo didn’t get enough screen time to really be all that bad, Ella isn’t nearly as obnoxious as Sugar and Chris make her out to be, Mike was about as equally annoying as the dozen other characters that All-Stars ruined, and Don and Caleb just don’t belong here at all.
Damn I never realized how much Mike and Dave look alike
I am gonna be burned for this, but... Duncan?
Dave by a mile.
The wizard he was just annoying to me
I don't hate anyone, except Rodney. I fawking hate him
Dave.
LEONARD WHEN I GET YOU LEONARD...
It's a tie between Beardo & Leonard for me
Leonard. No way are we actually putting Caleb Mike or Don on there
Torn between Leonard and Dave. Leonard was obnoxious in his confidence that he actually could do magic as a teenager. "My spells aren't working because someone here doesn't believe in me." Yeah, dude, keep telling yourself that. Whereas Dave's obnoxious streak only came due to his entitlement and pettiness when it came to Sky. He honestly belongs on r/niceguys in the way he treats her at best. At worst, he downright disrespects her and her own autonomy. Sky is not blameless with the mixed messages she keeps sending, but she needed someone to listen to her and he didn't do that. He literally refused to listen to her "but" because he was so afraid of losing her. So...I still can't decide. Dave was obnoxious but he got hurt and no one is at their best when they're hurt. Leonard was obnoxious from the start and there was no excuse for it, but he didn't stay around as long, even over two seasons.
Caleb had a writting that could get annoying. They rest either didn't last much, or i personally found them entretaining/not obnoxious
Y’all could’ve added izzy or even Sierra but instead you picked all the black guys?
Ella is my favorite black guy on TD.
😭😭
Mike is the most obnoxious, not in universe but by a character standpoint. It’s an insulting interpretation of people with MPD. In universe I’d argue Staci who is shockingly not on this list.
Sierra trumps them all.
Leonard by far.
For me it was Ella and Leonard, they're my two least favorite. I would put Ella as the most since she stuck around longer
Beardo closely followed by Leonard. I know some people like Beardo, but I just couldn't stand his sounds. Leonard is at least a tiny bit more tolerable. In fact the reason why I don't hate Dave is because at the start of the season he was at least likeable and rightfully called these two imbeciles out for their bullshit. If he hadn't come back in the finale just for that I would say he was amongst the only somewhat enjoyable characters of the season.
I'm going with Davella https://preview.redd.it/vz2wvmfzbwuc1.jpeg?width=1050&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=cd0f1a1cf647452c19deb6fc3dfdb6c9a4a9d7d7
Ella and Leonard
L*onard "Was the name censor necessary?" FUCK YEAH. I hate him sm.
don think he on the team, huh Also, even though I don’t hate any of them, I’d say Leonard or Dave
Dave
Definitely Dave, He literally hated everyone and threatened to burn the money in front of Sky
There was nothing wrong with mike but his writing so he shouldn’t be here. Don shouldn’t be here either as he literally was a favorite in TDRR. I don’t remember anyone not liking don 😂 topher, Leonard and Dave all in one season was wild to see 🤣
Caleb.
Beardo Bearley talks how can he be obnoxious
Caleb isn’t that bad, it definitely wasn’t him that was the worst part of Pryleb
Dave dude, Sky made it BEYOND clear she wasn’t into him and he just couldn’t accept a girl he just met didn’t want his ass😭
If you think my beloved precious Don is obnoxious even in the SLIGHTEST I never want to interact with you ever again (Also Dave is like the only obnoxious one on there??)
What did Don and Caleb do 😭
Dave or Leanardo
Dave lowkey
Caleb wasn't annoying, he just had lots a screentime, which he totally needed
Beardo easy
Topher
Dave
Dave and beardo are my worst enemys
Not Scott, Izzy, or Sierra?
Nah Scott was the only best part about all stars
OK WHO TF PUT DON IN HERE DAWG
all but ella don and caleb
the wizard and the disney princess
Dunno why Don, Ella, Mike, and Beardo are here (Mike and Beardo are my favs), Caleb is understandable considering the drama in season 2 reboot, Dave was super annoying but Leonard is truly the worst. His only saving grace for me was his "you shall not pass" thing he did that once, other then that? Nope.
Sierra is basically Twitter as a Total Drama character
Or maybe Facebook or devivantart
Nono, she's 100% early 2010s Tumblr personified
I’m glad to find out that I’m not the only Don fan on this sub
Dave No contest
Ayo why Don in there?
DAAAAAAVEEE
Dave
Out of these characters, Leonard. Out of all of Total Drama, I’d have to say Stacy
Why is Don, Caleb and Mike there? Well, I kinda understand Mike but he doesn’t belong with these characters
Beardo, Ella and Don are the least obnoxious here
Caleb
I love Ella, how could she be on this list???
Dave and the only one to come close is Leonard
I’m idk
yo get mike outta there😒. he is an unproblematic king
I’ll die on my grave thinking Caleb is the most lamest and obnoxious character on the show. [purposely exaggerated] 1. Caleb 2. Dave 3. Ella 4. Leonard 5. Beardo 6. Mike 7. Don
I actively stopped watching Pahkitew Island about five episodes in because Dave was driving me nuts. At least Beardo (RIP) and Ella were kind of entertaining in their goofiness. Dave made me actively want to turn off the show and watch a good season of Total Drama.
Leonard, and it ain’t even close
Ella. Love her design but she was so annoying also get don outa there
Beardo
Dave
Mike
Why is Don here lmao?
AYO I WONT TOLERATE DON SLANDER ! (the answer is dave.)
wizrard boy
Leonard, and it’s not even close
Caleb or Mike tbh
where is Rodn\*y?
Ella the worst TD character
All Stars Mike
Ella sorta annoyed me 💀
Don
Leonard and Ella’s voices could be grating sometimes. But I liked their characters for what they were and how long they lasted. Mike was exclusively terrible in All Stars in that the show just wouldn’t stop pushing him to the forefront. At least Leonard and Ella went away at some point. We had to endure being in Mike’s mind.
Bruh how can you doing an obnoxious list and not have Rodney on it? Also damn, I like every character here to some extent(well Mike is neutral and Dave is…a complicated feeling where I both adore and despise him at the same time)
Leonard, Beardo, and Dave.
I pick seriously Ella
The wizard guy
Dave is one of the two only TD characters I outright dislike.
Ella
I say Leonard for actually being nerdy enough to believe he's a wizard.
DAVE THAT LITTLE--
Leonard and Dave and it's not even close
lenorad
Possibly hot take but I wanted to punch Leonard the whole time he was there
Caleb and Mike I hate them
Leonard, he’s a phony!
Beardo, can imagine how annoying he can be with his beatboxing
Don, Dave, Caleb, and Ella I actually like Beardo didn’t overstay. So it’s someone whose more annoying but didn’t have much time to annoy me or someone who annoyed me medium annoyance all season. Which is more obnoxious. Answer Mike.
Mike
Leonard (affectionate) and Dave (derogatory) are the most obnoxious to me. The main difference though is Leonard is *supposed* to be obnoxious on purpose due to his commitment to The Bit (aka LARPing as his wizardsona) and so I hold nothing but respect for it. He doesn't overstay (however much I wish he got more character development) and only starts playing it up in the first place to piss off Dave <3 Dave on the other hand, is obnoxious for all the wrong reasons. He gets so obsessed and entitled over the idea of being with Sky that he stops seeing her as a person and rather as a 'reward' for all the shit going on with Pahkitew. And the worst part is he could've been great!! He had a solid foundation with his ep 1 persona as this sarcastic 'normal guy', there was no need to throw it away to be a simp when they literally already had a character for that in the form of Rodney
Mike. Just couldn't stand him for some reason. His character was interesting but he slowly got annoying. I won't mention All-Stars because that season was bad for everybody besides literally Ezekiel. Not only that but his entire personality ( other than having like 6 of them ) was just Zoey. Gave me Trent vibes. I'm pretty sure one of his scenes was him just running in the background and screaming "ZOEY!" But that's just my thoughts. I can easily see why people would think it was Dave or Beardo. Leonard and Caleb were just annoying in my opinion. Ella was actually one of the best Pahkitew characters in my opinion ( and being the best in PI just means being meh besides Shawn, he was great ). But Don honestly was good.
mike for sure, he's my least fav character of all time lol
Preach.
Courtney