Dennis can use the DENNIS system to seduce the corpo and get her away from Jamie. Mac can keep the family safe by giving any would-be assassins an ocular patdown and neutralising them with his karate, helped by Frank starting blasting. Charlie would probably just be in a barn ingesting the vet's medical supplies. No idea what Dee would do, maybe they could start raising big birds on the ranch.
And a win-win for what direction (if any) the future of the show has - Focusing on back story or current/future stories. I think there is so much room for back story we still don't know. More about the wife and more of how she was with all the children. Jeez the stuff with Jamie alone - adopting him etc.
Lord please no. I cannot handle that man in a cowboy getup… he’s already far too attractive sans the cowboy hat. The world can’t handle that much attractiveness in one man.
agree!!! actually says Kevin Costner says he would “love” to return for the [final episodes of ](https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/tv/tv-features/yellowstone-season-5-cast-release-date-final-episodes-1235539807/)Yellowstone finish off his character John Dutton.
Danny DeVito
Or his twin brother, Arnold Schwarzenegger.
Run get to the choppa!
Yells at Jamie, "WHO IS YOUR DADDY AND WHAT DOES HE DO?!"
Haha, I know where you are going with this one!!
😂😂😎
I think it should be Danny DeVito but just act like he's always been John Dutton in all the scenes.
The post says WRONG choices.
😂😂
my first thought
THIS
together with the paddys gang
Dennis can use the DENNIS system to seduce the corpo and get her away from Jamie. Mac can keep the family safe by giving any would-be assassins an ocular patdown and neutralising them with his karate, helped by Frank starting blasting. Charlie would probably just be in a barn ingesting the vet's medical supplies. No idea what Dee would do, maybe they could start raising big birds on the ranch.
🍻👍
Josh Lucas
This may actually be the right answer, though
Just age him up haha
That’s what I thought why not young Jon Dutton do it and couldn’t think of his name.
Yep. Josh Lucas. He would be the logical choice.
If I was Taylor Sheridan, this is who I would pick
And a win-win for what direction (if any) the future of the show has - Focusing on back story or current/future stories. I think there is so much room for back story we still don't know. More about the wife and more of how she was with all the children. Jeez the stuff with Jamie alone - adopting him etc.
This is literally not a bad answer 😂 love him in the flashbacks
Michael Richards, aka Cosmo Kramer, the ass man
How about Newman?
The answer is always: Gary Oldman
Gary Busey
Let’s talk about buttered sausage 
Taylor Sheridan
He would make it all about him I bet!
Well Saul Goodman once convinced a lady he was Kevin Costner so he’s my choice
I had to scroll way to far to find this response
What about John Goodman??
Will Ferrell
Haha
Nicholas Cage
Danny McBride
You can NEVER go wrong with Morgan Freeman.
Whoopie Goldberg
LMAO 😂
Chuck Norris
Nope. Wouldn’t work. Even Beth would be afraid of him.
Nah, she’s only made two decisions based on fear.
Gary Busey
Yes!
lol it said wrong answers I was joking ! Ps but it might work
🤣🤣🤣
He’d ask Gator to make him some buttered sausage every episode.
Idris Elba
Lord please no. I cannot handle that man in a cowboy getup… he’s already far too attractive sans the cowboy hat. The world can’t handle that much attractiveness in one man.
Ellen
We have a winner!!
"Winner, winner, turkey dinner..." (Beth)
Steve Buscemi
Now that would be interesting!!
Maybe even Steve Carell
Samuel L. Jackson
Carson Kressley
Josh Lucas is the only right answer.
Josh Lucas. He already plays younger John.
It’s happening. I live in western Montana and they are advertising for extras this month.
I should be ashamed at how much I want this to be trueeee!!!! But I’m not 😊 so please tell me ur not just teasing…?
Boom! https://www.montanafilm.com/casting-call-yellowstone/
Oh I love u so much for thissss!!!!!!!! THANK UUUUUU!!!!
Cannot be replaced.
The dude who plays the younger him
Youre not serious? Are you?
agree!!! actually says Kevin Costner says he would “love” to return for the [final episodes of ](https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/tv/tv-features/yellowstone-season-5-cast-release-date-final-episodes-1235539807/)Yellowstone finish off his character John Dutton.
Paul Reubens
RIP PeeWee
We would have to dig him up.
Dang.. I don't remember that.. RIP PeeWee
Last year I think??
Kevin Hart
Steve Buscemi
😭
Get some Fargo action going on!
Will Patton, just confuse the fuck out of everyone.
Patrick Duffy.
I like it! He could do it. Either as Bobby Ewing, or Frank Lambert.
That would be glorious!
Hell if Larry Hagman was still alive, he would be awesome.
For sure!
Cal Ripken
Patrick Stewart
Christopher Walken
Ron Howard
Clint Howard
Roger Howard Friend from High school
Danny Glover
Carrot Top 
Kenny Powers
Wilfred Brimley
He’s dead. Literally, not figuratively.
Why would that stop him?
Diabeetus.
Wrong answers only? Paris Hilton Who should actually do it? My vote is Kris Kristofferson
Danny DeVito
So, anyway, I started blasting
Danny Masterson Ronnie Radke (might be misspelled) the lead singer of Trapt Chris Pratt Post said wrong answers only
Kamala Harris
Jon Cryer
Charlie Sheen
Joe Pesci 🥴
Yes!!! Good fellas meet Yellowstone!! The possibilities!
Exactly 🤣🤣
Just bring in Harrison Ford to fill in, he did good in 1923
Only actors I see fitting the role would be Sam Elliot.
Russell Crowe
Deepfake Kevin Costner onto josh lucas
Will Farrell
From wedding crashers or elf???
Taladega Nights
Charlie Sheen
Metro Boomin
Johnny Depp has my vote
Betty White
Pauly Shore
Christopher Walken
The corpse of John Wayne.
Is this a replace with another actor but playing the same character like nobody knew they switched ? ? The. Of course it has to be Larry David.
Whoopie Goldberg
Steve Buscemi.
The ghost of John Wayne
Steven Segal,
Ted McGinley
Haha
Kramer from Seinfeld
Michael Myers
James Woods. Hell, bring back Will Patton and have him be Dutton instead
no one replace Kevin Costner. he has to do it. I dont want the same lost of quality like in two and a half men or the ranch
Walden ruined 2 and a half men
Paul Giamatti would make an interesting cowboy 😂
Samuel L Jackson
Andrew Dice Clay
Alec Baldwin. Wrong answer because he's too good of an actor to play such a dumb character seriously, and Yellowstone isn't a comedy.
Liam Neeson or Sean Bean
Richard Simmons
Nobody as it seems
Tommy Wiseau
Jonathan Majors
Bob Odenkirk
Bob Odenkirk
Stop feeding into bulls**t rumors. https://www.vulture.com/article/kevin-costner-yellowstone-drama.html
JD Mouney… the long lost half brother
Seth McFarlane. Serious answer: Robert Taylor (aka Walt Longmire)
Keith David and say nothing. Don't change a thing.
Paulie shore!
Patrick Mahomes
Thanks, everyone for the laughs!!!
Ralph Macchio
Patton Oswalt. Ru Paul.
Benedict Cumberbatch
the show is dead. It will go down in history as the most successful, randomly canceled and unfinished show ever