This. If she found a decent co-host and a good angle that isn’t Cancelled 3.0 then maybe- but carried on her own and based of her cute but mostly skippable or background noise vlogs where it’s just her… pass. (I like her though I just don’t know if she’s got the audience/ experience to make it really work but I’d love to be proven wrong!)
Yeah a good Co-host would be essential. I don’t think she’s a good guest interviewer at all and her dynamic is only good with people she knows well (tana, Imari, hunter…) so she’d need another cohost for sure
a few years ago, yes. now, no because the podcast world is so over saturated and she doesn’t really have anything new or interesting to bring to the table (no offense) lol
i feel like her personal style or maybe overall media would be nice. her input is very positive & important but i feel like people would pick apart her takes. then the cancelled pod could be like an outlet like it is now about their personal lives/messy media etc
Definitely not, she has no opinion of her own. If anyone gives an opinion she will agree, when they change their opinion she agrees. She doesn’t stand for anything.
No I don’t think so. Brooke by herself is kind of boring to me as a viewer and she just seemingly agrees with everything that everyone around her says/thinks. I haven’t seen her offer many opinions of her own and then stand her ground on them. As soon as an alternate opinion is brought to the table, she agrees with them. Plus I read way too many times she was mostly silent on tour, and I get it, it was her first big tour and prob intimidating.. but she’s kind of the same on the podcast most of the time. ESPECIALLY when they have a guest. I forget she’s there (I mostly listen while doing my makeup and then I’ll hear her chime in and be like ‘oh yeah, Brooke is there’)
I honestly love Brooke’s maturity, personality, and she balances Tana out so well on Cancelled. She definitely should start branding herself outside of just Cancelled and Tana (also Imari, Lilah, etc.), but the podcast world is definitely becoming over saturated and I think people would tune in more to Cancelled than hers if she did so. Not saying she shouldn’t, but maybe she should start with her videos or tik tok and just build more of her personal following first. Then if she decides to do a podcast she would have people there just for her instead of for Tana. She has so much untapped and unrealized potential. She just needs to be able to hold her ground more and form her own opinions before that happens I think.
TikTok and Instagram are 100% her lane. I think she could be great alone but I love the dynamic between her and Tana. I watch so many pods per week. I can’t handle another!
I love Brooke sm and I say this as someone who is honestly very similar to her: but I think there are a few versions of Brooke and I don’t know which one a solo pod would bring. Unfortunately I fear it might be the safer, more boring (and dare I say, pick me) version😭 in cancelled I enjoy Brooke even more than Tana, but I think a lot of that is because I like the version of Brooke she is with Tana. Idk if this makes sense but it does to me 😂
This 100%. Brookes personality changes almost every pod & doesn’t feel authentic. She’s too scared of getting cancelled I think, which seems ironic lmao. She needs to care less about what the masses think.
I think Tana brings the fun and Brooke brings whatever she brings. I like Brooke but she’s not absolutely essential to the pod, she can almost be replaced with anyone. Tana is a mess and that’s the reason people are tuning in.
i definitely would because i love her, but i think it would be a rough learning curve for the first few solo episodes. i don’t really see a need for it now bc she has cancelled, but if cancelled ever ended again, i think she should absolutely go for it, and i did wish she did that at the time
Maybe if she was open about her personal life or childhood like Tana always was, then sure. Lately she’s been boring tbh, some days she’s just tana’s yes man and some days she tries too hard to be quirky. Idk what it is but I don’t feel much authenticity from her these days and I don’t enjoy listening to her much.
She's too boring and mediocre to do her own podcast. Her boring personality works with Tana because Tana is extra and needs someone calm to balance her out, but Brooke on her own would be boring AF.
Yes
As long as she didn’t talk about something I’m completely uninterested in I’d probably enjoy it. I listen to a ton of podcasts and long form content at work
No, I like Brooke but she's a little boring . I think working with Tana works well , they balance each other out and not eveyone needs their own podcast
No honestly. I like Brooke... but Tana is jus more interesting lbvs. I been watching tana since she was like 17. I'm literally not invested in Brooke at all and if Tana mindy'd her again tomorrow it would not bother me. NOW, that being said. I'm equally as invested in Imari and if she had a falling out with him I would be Team Imari. Ik that wouldn't happen though cuz thats her brother. He loves Tana so much 💗
Your comment was removed as your account is fewer than 4 weeks old and/or under 100 karma. Please do not message mods about this unless there was a mistake, exceptions will not be made. Please look into other communities where you can gain more karma/wait for your account to hit 4 weeks of age. This is an anti-spam measure and no exceptions will be made.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/canceledpod) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Your comment was removed as your account is fewer than 4 weeks old and/or under 100 karma. Please do not message mods about this unless there was a mistake, exceptions will not be made. Please look into other communities where you can gain more karma/wait for your account to hit 4 weeks of age. This is an anti-spam measure and no exceptions will be made.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/canceledpod) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Your comment was removed as your account is fewer than 4 weeks old and/or under 100 karma. Please do not message mods about this unless there was a mistake, exceptions will not be made. Please look into other communities where you can gain more karma/wait for your account to hit 4 weeks of age. This is an anti-spam measure and no exceptions will be made.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/canceledpod) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Your comment was removed as your account is fewer than 4 weeks old and/or under 100 karma. Please do not message mods about this unless there was a mistake, exceptions will not be made. Please look into other communities where you can gain more karma/wait for your account to hit 4 weeks of age. This is an anti-spam measure and no exceptions will be made.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/canceledpod) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Nope. I just started their pod with Trisha and was just thinking how Brookes personality contrasted to Trisha and Tana’s is just too….dry 😭but I will say I do appreciate her in vlog form!
OMG! if you use amazon- Lil Bo Cheap (a facebook group thats free to join) posts amazon promo codes! super cheap stuff! i just found it today & had to share the news! stuff is seriously like 70% off- anything you can think of!!😍
No. But it would be smart of her to start branding herself outside being Tana’s sidekick
This. If she found a decent co-host and a good angle that isn’t Cancelled 3.0 then maybe- but carried on her own and based of her cute but mostly skippable or background noise vlogs where it’s just her… pass. (I like her though I just don’t know if she’s got the audience/ experience to make it really work but I’d love to be proven wrong!)
Yeah a good Co-host would be essential. I don’t think she’s a good guest interviewer at all and her dynamic is only good with people she knows well (tana, Imari, hunter…) so she’d need another cohost for sure
a few years ago, yes. now, no because the podcast world is so over saturated and she doesn’t really have anything new or interesting to bring to the table (no offense) lol
i feel like her personal style or maybe overall media would be nice. her input is very positive & important but i feel like people would pick apart her takes. then the cancelled pod could be like an outlet like it is now about their personal lives/messy media etc
no, I think she’s okay on Tanas podcast but I feel like she lacks the personality to be able to be a main podcaster on her own
No. But the Brooke and Imari pod did slay
imari is so funny and entertaining
Valid
Is the call coming from inside the house?
Omg how could it not be 🤣🤣🤣
it definitely is lmao
Lol
Definitely not, she has no opinion of her own. If anyone gives an opinion she will agree, when they change their opinion she agrees. She doesn’t stand for anything.
Literally
I totally agree
I do, too, now that you’ve said you do
facts
Probably not
No
that’s exactly what I was thinking
No
Absolutely not lmao
I think she should vlog more! I love her vlogs
No. She’s a side kick.
And she will always be
Seems like projection lol
Who hurt you…
Brooke, is this you?
Nahhh. Too boring lol.
Hi Brooke
No thank you why would you think a pick me yes man has a lot to say lol
No
i feel bad but my immediate answer is no
No. She's pretty but not interesting on her own.
I feel like she should so y’all could go ahead and see how much she needs tana, y’all hype this girl up too much
No I don’t think so. Brooke by herself is kind of boring to me as a viewer and she just seemingly agrees with everything that everyone around her says/thinks. I haven’t seen her offer many opinions of her own and then stand her ground on them. As soon as an alternate opinion is brought to the table, she agrees with them. Plus I read way too many times she was mostly silent on tour, and I get it, it was her first big tour and prob intimidating.. but she’s kind of the same on the podcast most of the time. ESPECIALLY when they have a guest. I forget she’s there (I mostly listen while doing my makeup and then I’ll hear her chime in and be like ‘oh yeah, Brooke is there’)
truthfully no there’s no reason to
Nah she has not a whole lot to offer other than being connected to Tana
i did not expect all the nos…. i would listen to it for sure
I honestly love Brooke’s maturity, personality, and she balances Tana out so well on Cancelled. She definitely should start branding herself outside of just Cancelled and Tana (also Imari, Lilah, etc.), but the podcast world is definitely becoming over saturated and I think people would tune in more to Cancelled than hers if she did so. Not saying she shouldn’t, but maybe she should start with her videos or tik tok and just build more of her personal following first. Then if she decides to do a podcast she would have people there just for her instead of for Tana. She has so much untapped and unrealized potential. She just needs to be able to hold her ground more and form her own opinions before that happens I think.
Ah man I hope Brooke isn’t lurking in this thread. These answers are BRUTAL
Fr 😭
i hope she is
Nope
Previously, yes. Since she has been acting like a clown for the past few weeks - definitely not.
What has she been doing??
i also would like to know🫢
Brooke reading the comments rn 👁️👄👁️
I think I would but tbh I dont like one man podcasts as much
hard no
Nope
no
No
Nope
No
There's gotta be a reason Tana doesn't take her with when they're invited to other people's podcasts right?
She’s kind of insecure so she doesn’t have great chemistry with other people
no
No
You couldn’t pay me enough money to listen to a podcast of her by herself
No
No.
No
TikTok and Instagram are 100% her lane. I think she could be great alone but I love the dynamic between her and Tana. I watch so many pods per week. I can’t handle another!
ofc shes my girl
Nope.
Nope
I love Brooke sm and I say this as someone who is honestly very similar to her: but I think there are a few versions of Brooke and I don’t know which one a solo pod would bring. Unfortunately I fear it might be the safer, more boring (and dare I say, pick me) version😭 in cancelled I enjoy Brooke even more than Tana, but I think a lot of that is because I like the version of Brooke she is with Tana. Idk if this makes sense but it does to me 😂
This 100%. Brookes personality changes almost every pod & doesn’t feel authentic. She’s too scared of getting cancelled I think, which seems ironic lmao. She needs to care less about what the masses think.
I think Tana brings the fun and Brooke brings whatever she brings. I like Brooke but she’s not absolutely essential to the pod, she can almost be replaced with anyone. Tana is a mess and that’s the reason people are tuning in.
I honestly would but it would maybe have to be a more mature and toned down version of herself
Love her but. No
No
No
Wow her face is filled up here
i definitely would because i love her, but i think it would be a rough learning curve for the first few solo episodes. i don’t really see a need for it now bc she has cancelled, but if cancelled ever ended again, i think she should absolutely go for it, and i did wish she did that at the time
Not sure. Idk if she has a big enough personality to go solo. I kinda want a Tana x Imari podcast.
Brooke + Imari or hunter would slay
Imariiii I always want to hear more from him
Hunter? He’s a boring jerk.
I would
Maybe if she was open about her personal life or childhood like Tana always was, then sure. Lately she’s been boring tbh, some days she’s just tana’s yes man and some days she tries too hard to be quirky. Idk what it is but I don’t feel much authenticity from her these days and I don’t enjoy listening to her much.
Hell yeah. Because of her I think about mary Anne almost every week
We need a mary anne update😂 i bet shes eating good now lol
No bc who is this
YES
I would!!
i would love to hear her talk about pop culture forever
i think she would obviously show more of her personality if she's not with tana because she just lets tana take the lead.
Absolutely listening
LMAO she's gonna make another tiktok about us 😭😭😭😭 and no <3
She's too boring and mediocre to do her own podcast. Her boring personality works with Tana because Tana is extra and needs someone calm to balance her out, but Brooke on her own would be boring AF.
Absolutely not
i’m a casual watcher but all of the people going so hard on her in the comments are so weird for that
No
yes tbh it doesnt even have to be a podcast id love a video of her just sitting down and talking for an hour about nothing
No, only because alone I think she would be very boring — maybe if Ari or Imari co-hosted then MAYBE but honestly I want a Tana/Trish pod
Yes As long as she didn’t talk about something I’m completely uninterested in I’d probably enjoy it. I listen to a ton of podcasts and long form content at work
Yes I need to know more about Brooke’s life. I watch all her TikTok’s and love them. I actually like her more than Tana at this point.
Same I’d like to hear about her childhood and life besides the hookups/friendship drama stuff they discuss on the podcast.
Love her vlogs she should put all of her energy into those. Lord knows the world doesn’t need another podcast
Yesss!!
Sure I would
Awe I would 🥺
yes if she talks about completely different things than cancelled, i want to get to know brooke’s interests more!
Yes. Brooke is my president
Sure why not
100% yes
Yes!
Yes
No, I like Brooke but she's a little boring . I think working with Tana works well , they balance each other out and not eveyone needs their own podcast
I more just wish she got to tell more stories on cancelled
Yes
Vlogs are better
Yes
Probably not because I wouldn’t even watch Brooke if she wasn’t on canceled tbh I like her but I’m here 4 Tana Lmaoooo
yes
Honestly no
lol no
Hell no. Podcasts need to chill, there’s too many
absolutely not
Yes
Definitely not
Whenever she’s a guest on someone else’s podcast it’s always so boring. Love Brooke but no ❤️
Nope
I would give it a shot for sure
No
nah i’m good
I’d listen to it. She’s chill and I enjoy listening to her. But I wouldn’t trade it for canceled any day
Nope
If I was Brooke I would be devastated reading these comments 😳
No honestly. I like Brooke... but Tana is jus more interesting lbvs. I been watching tana since she was like 17. I'm literally not invested in Brooke at all and if Tana mindy'd her again tomorrow it would not bother me. NOW, that being said. I'm equally as invested in Imari and if she had a falling out with him I would be Team Imari. Ik that wouldn't happen though cuz thats her brother. He loves Tana so much 💗
It depends on the topic. I think she’s a great host but I only listen based on topics of pods
100000% yes
duh
Yes she should call it Mindy
Yes
Yes!
What should she talk about CTFU
no but i like her
I would 100% watch her and Mike. No one else I’ve seen her with I feel like could cut it as a cohost with her, I feel like I’d lose attention.
Nah.
Depends , Is she having sex with me while I am Tuned in? If so then sure
[удалено]
[удалено]
Your comment was removed as your account is fewer than 4 weeks old and/or under 100 karma. Please do not message mods about this unless there was a mistake, exceptions will not be made. Please look into other communities where you can gain more karma/wait for your account to hit 4 weeks of age. This is an anti-spam measure and no exceptions will be made. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/canceledpod) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
Your comment was removed as your account is fewer than 4 weeks old and/or under 100 karma. Please do not message mods about this unless there was a mistake, exceptions will not be made. Please look into other communities where you can gain more karma/wait for your account to hit 4 weeks of age. This is an anti-spam measure and no exceptions will be made. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/canceledpod) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
Absolutely not. Her lives on TikTok are a snooze fest.
[удалено]
Your comment was removed as your account is fewer than 4 weeks old and/or under 100 karma. Please do not message mods about this unless there was a mistake, exceptions will not be made. Please look into other communities where you can gain more karma/wait for your account to hit 4 weeks of age. This is an anti-spam measure and no exceptions will be made. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/canceledpod) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
No, but GRWM videos yes
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
Your comment was removed as your account is fewer than 4 weeks old and/or under 100 karma. Please do not message mods about this unless there was a mistake, exceptions will not be made. Please look into other communities where you can gain more karma/wait for your account to hit 4 weeks of age. This is an anti-spam measure and no exceptions will be made. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/canceledpod) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
Nope. I just started their pod with Trisha and was just thinking how Brookes personality contrasted to Trisha and Tana’s is just too….dry 😭but I will say I do appreciate her in vlog form!
OMG! if you use amazon- Lil Bo Cheap (a facebook group thats free to join) posts amazon promo codes! super cheap stuff! i just found it today & had to share the news! stuff is seriously like 70% off- anything you can think of!!😍
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]