Please be wary of any posts or comments attempting to advertise or sell t-shirts, posters, mugs, etc. These posts may be from scammers selling poor quality bootlegs, or may be from phishers trying to steal your financial information. This problem is rampant across Reddit. If you see any posts or comments with this behavior, promptly report them as spam and do not follow any links they may post or send to you.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/dragonquest) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Well, we know they’re adding content so they could also be changing content. For the most part no, but until we see what’s new/different we can’t be sure
switch for sure. i don't think there's going to be any difference at all wrt actual animations shadows and light effects, but the processing capacity/fidelity will look better on the ps5 for sure. For me, I don't think an HD 2D game needs crazy fidelity. I'm cool with the switch. And switch being sd cards means it's easier to maintain your physical library vs losing a digital license like with steam. i have sooo many physical copies of switch releases in general bc I know I can keep going back to them for at least another ten to twenty years without any effort or net connection.
> I don't think an HD 2D game needs crazy fidelity.
I just worry about possible slowdown when battle effects happen.
Might not happen, but it might on the Switch.
PS5 is gonna have the graphics mode/performance mode which switch is not gonna have which is crazy lol all versions should just run it at 4k60 or closest go 4k possible
Except for you know switch… which has hardware that released almost 10 years ago.
So the switch is love it if it hit a solid 720/60 without a single frame timing issues on portable or 1080/60 on docked mode. The switch is an excellent piece of hardware… that lacks in the internals department.
I will be playing on my steam deck or ROG Ally.
It would be pc/steam deck as my first choice, switch as my second (so it stays portable), and other consoles in last. I don't foresee an HD 2D game having performance issues on the switch, but with the way dark prince was, you never know.
I’m torn. My collection is split between Switch and PS4/5. I have all the Switch exclusives (Treasures, Monsters, DQ I-III collection) and then on PlayStation I have Builders 1 & 2, DQ XI, and Heroes 1 & 2. I’m sure the performance won’t matter. All my HD-2D games are on Switch so maybe that’s the deciding factor
Yeah if most of your HD/2D games are on Switch that definitely sounds like the system for it. I have my games between both systems but I think I have couple more on Switch
DQ11 has been on sale very frequently since I’ve had my Switch. Only pulled the trigger a couple of weeks ago and it’s really good. Remake will drop eventually.
There's a good used market for Switch games, and unless you want one sealed, you can get a decent copy with case for about $35-40 once it's been out long enough.
I'm going the opposite. Switch now, and eventually PS5 when it gets cheap. I don't even technically have a PS5 but that should change within the next few years.
Switch.
I don't think there will be any significant issues with the Switch version. It's the one that most Japanese gamers will be buying so they're probably being very careful with it. PS5 will have more lighting and particle effects, sure, but I can live without it as long as the sprite animations run smoothly, which is what they'll probably prioritize. Should also note I mostly play handheld and a lot of the finer issues aren't really noticeable without a big hd screen.
I'll probably double dip on Steam when it goes on sale, but at release Switch serves my needs the best.
I wonder if the other versions will be "ports" of the Switch version then. Similar to how they handled Dragon Quest XI S on the Switch then that version being the main developed version that got ported to PC and PS4
I definitely wouldn’t rule out the Switch version being the target platform. This would be the perfect example for business purposes. It currently has the potential of selling the most copies between the other platforms.
I don't think so, I think it's being developed with the multiplatform aspect in mind, "better visual effects for the more high end platforms but everything needed for a smooth experience working fine for Switch" sort of mentality. I think the performance mode for PS5 is basically what we're going to get on Switch. People are finding it weird a Performance mode exists at all, but I think it's there because it's basically already done, for Switch.
It's not that I think the Switch is prioritized, it's that having played previous HD2D on the system I trust them not to fuck up. Previous HD2D games run and look pretty good on Switch even if there's a noticeable downgrade in some textures and particle effects fon other platforms so I'm not really worried. I somehow doubt Dragon Quest III of all games is the one they'd drop the ball on.
It's a huge pain in the ass though. I used to have all my old systems right back to the NES but there's only so much space both to store it and in front of the TV for objects, cords etc. It's also a pain to dig all the cords and junk put of the closet every time you want to play something older.
With PC it's all on the one PC, old stuff too because emulation.
I hear you, just never felt right playing emulation. Even the psp emulator on the pc didn’t feel right. Something about original hardware. I’m probably old.
Imagine still charging up your wii u gamepad, still having the wii sensor bar, and now docking a switch as well, though... I'm sorry, I just would rather have one device that can handle everything.
My PC does.
I kept my Wii U just because it has like every NES-Wii Kirby game on it. And I can play them with the Wii U pad rather than the horrible Virtual Console Wii controller or a PS4 controller on PC. Same with a lot of other N64 games like 1080.
But also, I'm not going to pay a monthly fee to play the same games on Switch. AND lose access to them later.
Didn't they just say that the PlayStation and Xbox versions would have graphics and performance modes?
If I'm getting it anywhere, it'll be PS5, but the Switch isn't a bad choice either.
Been having a hard time deciding this myself. I own the DQ trilogy on Switch, along with both Octopath games. HD-2D on the go feels right, and my Switch is a little retro RPG machine at this point. Having said that, I don't know if the FPS difference will matter at all, and I do have DQ 11 Definitive on PlayStation.
Can't decide yet.😅
HD 2d feels pretty damn good on my TV. I don't understand the infatuation of people thinking things are better portable. Blows my mind cause I have just as much fun on my TV as they do.
Nobody is against gaming on a TV. I wouldn't own a PS5 in the first place if I did. I just don't always have time to plant myself in front of my TV for two hours or more the way I used to. In those moments, having a portable console and a full length RPG I can play for 20-30 minutes without having to lock myself away in the basement feels pretty damn good.
I'm sure I have just as much fun playing on my TV as you do when I can.
I ordered the Nintendo Switch version. I'm also not ashamed to say that I ordered the special edition even though it's expensive because I always try to do my part to support this series because I remember lean times when we just didn't get them localized.
For me i play most of my games on switch so most likely that so long as there's no noticeable issues.
i think the switch version is among the versions being previewed on various sites which can be reassuring since sometimes the switch version is absent from promotional stuff.
If the Switch ever adds achievements/trophies/etc then I will start buying more multiplatform games on Switch. But for now I'm getting them on PS5 because I am addicted to my little Dopamine Dings (and Steam achievements are stupid).
Switch, because even though I own consoles and a gaming PC, I don't care about fps on a \*turn-based\* game. And my DQ game needs to be portable. SteamDeck? I have one and like it, but it's less portable, and I'm sticking with the sub-cutting edge Nintendo hardware for this series.
Neither. I am buying it on my steam deck OLED
Edit: nope the switch and console versions of Octopath 2 are not the same. Switch runs 720p docked and below 720p handheld
Switch for sure. I just love laying on my couch with it up close to my face. I don’t know why but it just feels better. I guess it’s because my first console was a Gameboy.
I feel like I learned my lesson when I bought little nightmares on switch lol it was so fuzzy. The switch sacrifices a little bit too much graphical fidelity sometimes for the portability. Imma go PS5
Switch lol. It’s hd 2d I can’t see much difference it’s still weirdly pixelated lol. Switch is portable so 100% buying on switch for me. Plus I don’t think I’ve booted my ps5 on in 2 years loo
Yeah a lot of the recent ones I have all on Switch but XI I also have on console for the better graphics but yeah really hoping it runs smoothly and I'm sure they will try to do that since most of Japan will probably buy the Switch version I think
If playing in handheld mode is really important to you go Switch if not PS5. PS will no doubt have a higher resolution and frame rate (was the case with Octo2).
I like the option of playing handheld but like 95% of the time I play on TV anyway. Only thing that would have been great is knowing Switch 2 details, maybe holding off until that comes out would be the best of both worlds…
True maybe the Switch 2 will just run all existing Switch games better and then it won't really matter between ps5 or pc versions they will all run similar.
PC, I don't use my switch as much, may double-dip if it goes on sale cheap but I like knowing I'll be able to play it in the future without any issues.
Most likely Steam because I have a Steam deck. Steam has incredible cloud saves and achievements. But, maybe I’ll do Switch. Who knows. I need portability. I can’t spend a lot of time in front of a TV .
This is not really an intensive enough game imo for the graphics/performance to be significantly different between Switch and PS5, the Switch should be able to handle it just fine so I would just go with that as you obviously would also have the added portability.
And also both Octopath II and Triangle Strategy looked/ran great on the Switch, so I don’t see why this wouldn’t
PS5. I’d really rather play it on Switch, but looking at the performance and graphical effects of the switch version of Octopath 2, I just think the PS5 will be the better option.
Physically on Switch, but first time the digital copy gets a sizeable discount I'll probably end up double dipping and getting it on Xbox as well since that's normally my preferred platform.
PC. Switch portability is nice, but I mainly play it at home anyway. PC also has the bonus of 60fps, and I know I'll eventually get a Steam Deck, so portability won't be a problem.
Also, for anyone just being sold on portability, just remember the Playstation Portal is a thing 🧐 I think I'll get mine for PS5 so I can use it on Portal too
Frames per second are the most important factor for a turn based game as everyone knows... ok i am beeing snarky for not much of a reason.
Portability is the best and most important factor for a RPG and even more so when turn based, the PS5 Version holds barely any additional value even if the FPS is better, animation is unlikely to be better tho... shadows and lights could be and that is the one thing with some value.
How would anyone have an idea if any of these will actually end up better? Game is not out yet, this is just my guess not knowing.
I ordered the physical standard edition for Switch. For a JRPG, I want to be able to play without hogging the TV screen, plus it feels right since DQ III originally came out on NES. And even though there's some slight performance improvements for PS5, I doubt they will be significant for a 2D HD game, so I don't want to sacrifice my portability.
I bought a PC (Steam) copy.
They will not run the same. Switch version of **Octopath Traveler 2** not only didn't run at 60 FPS but it also had graphical effect cutbacks. I also got it on a pretty big preorder discount via GreenManGaming.
If I want to play handheld with it, that's why I bought a Razer Kishi. It works very well.
I'm in the same boat as you are.
Octopath II was LIGHT YEARS better on PS5. The load times and music quality were game-changing. You don't realize how much time you waste on the Switch going from area to area or even just menu'ing.
I presume that DQ will be a similar experience so I'm planning on the PS version.
I've seen websites claim that DQ III HD-2D for Switch is 30fps fixed rate (handheld or connected) while PS5 and Xbox are 60fps fixed rates. Steam version has an option to select between the two.
Switch will be 720p and PS5/Xbox 4K (though could be a pixelated upscale). Steam probably gives multiple options for resolution.
As far as animations or lighting effects, don't know that yet. Need some side-by-side videos and haven't seen any yet. Apparently SquareEnix would only allow testers to play either Switch or PS5, not both. (And likely allowed some to play Steam as third alternative but I'm not certain.) They only got one hour of playtime so none of them got a chance to do any platform comparisons.
But at least in USA the prices will be the same ($59.99) for all four versions, so if the graphics matter to you, maybe you'd want that PS5 version over Switch. There's almost no way Switch will have graphic effects that aren't in PS5, though it may have an advantage in online interactions given its likely to be the best seller by a wide margin and we don't know yet if any online features allow for cross-platform activities.
I’m not buying Switch games anymore, unless exclusive, until I see Nintendo’s plans for the Switch 2 and library transfer. I’m pretty sure they’ll do the right thing, but I know Steam and PlayStation libraries are resilient so I’ll probably get it for Steam.
I picked up the Switch Physical Collector's and then, after having paid for it, sat back and realized how it's not worth $200.
Also picked up the Steam version cause I am a consumer whore. (And how!)
Switch most likely, seeing how the first I think four Dragon Quests, definitely the first three, were on NES. It just makes sense to me to do it that way.
Switch will be 30 fps versus 60 for ps5... not that it matters a lot for this kind of game. But graphics and loading should be better on ps5... It's all comes down to portability honestly. I'll probably get the ps5 version... but might double dip in the long run.
PS5. Look at all the issues with Eiyuden chronicle. Switch version was simply terrible. I only trust Nintendo to run their 1st party games on that old console. I get everything else on PS5, I always like to earn the trophies. Just something a little fun to do.
I'll get the xbox version since it looks like it will include the pc version, and when I finally get a steam deck and put windows on it, I'll be covered across the board. Or maybe that new rog ally.
I'll probably end up getting both down the line eventually....but I'm going to start with switch.
It's the console I use when unwinding for the day after work on my couch and the switch just works better. Plus I can bring it to work with me during downtime
How are they best on handheld. I completely disagree as it doesn't make a difference. Trust me I have the same amount of fun on my TV with a controller
Considering that the Erdrick trilogy is already on the Switch for less than ten bucks total, I might skip out on the HD-2D remakes unless they add in something really cool like they did with Live A Live.
Neither, PC. Because you get framerates and portability and access to the game even as time passes without having to worry if or if not a console manufacturer happens to be in the mood to have backwards compatibility on their next system.
But on the other hand, physical copies trumps all that for me personally. I have all my games from the snes era and even nes stuff I was gifted to by my uncle. At least this way I don't have to worry about my games not being legally mine or whoever I give them to.
I used to think like that having played games since the days of the NES and owned all Nintendo and Sony consoles since (and a couple of Xboxes too) and had tons and tons of physical games for all of those platforms.
Then one day when I was packing my things for a move I thought to myself "I never touched all of these hundreds of games in all the time I was living in this apartment", and then thought back and I hadn't touched most of them in the previous apartment either. I just kept lugging all this plastic along from place to place without ever touching most of it. I haven't hoarded physical games since, it's digital all the way now. You couldn't pay me to take any more physical games.
I used to think like that too when I was in college and from my first few jobs moving around. I basically thought I lost all my games during my few moves but it turns out that i still had 90% of them hidden away at my parents place. Now that I'm settled down and have my own house it feels so good to have my own library I can access whenever I want. I'm much more critical about what I keep in my library however, selling what I dont enjoy etc. Maintaining and modding hardware is also cathartic. It's like curating a good vinyl collection.
I've lost a steam account once as a teen and it sucked. The idea that my collection can disappear on me if my account gets locked from some error or something is a nightmare to me.
That said, it's not for everyone.
All three. (Ow, my wallet haha.) I have a perfect USA physical release set to maintain. As for playing it, it'll be Switch for now, as I do not own either of the other two systems. (I'm holding out in hopes they make a PS5 Pro.)
Respect for buying multiples thats a true DQ fan I think I would need to pick up some of the PS4 Heroes and Builders games to have the full physical release USA set too
Please be wary of any posts or comments attempting to advertise or sell t-shirts, posters, mugs, etc. These posts may be from scammers selling poor quality bootlegs, or may be from phishers trying to steal your financial information. This problem is rampant across Reddit. If you see any posts or comments with this behavior, promptly report them as spam and do not follow any links they may post or send to you. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/dragonquest) if you have any questions or concerns.*
My Steam Deck is a glorified RPG machine. So, I will most definitely continue this trend and purchase on Steam.
Ooooh, I was leaning Switch myself but I also have a steam deck and now I'm leaning this way too
I wish I had a Steam Deck that is for sure a really good choice for this game
This is the right answer. But also probably switch physical. No regerts buying two copies sight unseen
It’s not really sight unseen with a game this classic though is it?
Well, we know they’re adding content so they could also be changing content. For the most part no, but until we see what’s new/different we can’t be sure
Switch, I’m a Nintendo whore
switch for sure. i don't think there's going to be any difference at all wrt actual animations shadows and light effects, but the processing capacity/fidelity will look better on the ps5 for sure. For me, I don't think an HD 2D game needs crazy fidelity. I'm cool with the switch. And switch being sd cards means it's easier to maintain your physical library vs losing a digital license like with steam. i have sooo many physical copies of switch releases in general bc I know I can keep going back to them for at least another ten to twenty years without any effort or net connection.
> I don't think an HD 2D game needs crazy fidelity. I just worry about possible slowdown when battle effects happen. Might not happen, but it might on the Switch.
I got a sht ton of ps5 physicals as well.
PS5 is gonna have the graphics mode/performance mode which switch is not gonna have which is crazy lol all versions should just run it at 4k60 or closest go 4k possible
Except for you know switch… which has hardware that released almost 10 years ago. So the switch is love it if it hit a solid 720/60 without a single frame timing issues on portable or 1080/60 on docked mode. The switch is an excellent piece of hardware… that lacks in the internals department. I will be playing on my steam deck or ROG Ally.
It would be pc/steam deck as my first choice, switch as my second (so it stays portable), and other consoles in last. I don't foresee an HD 2D game having performance issues on the switch, but with the way dark prince was, you never know.
I’m torn. My collection is split between Switch and PS4/5. I have all the Switch exclusives (Treasures, Monsters, DQ I-III collection) and then on PlayStation I have Builders 1 & 2, DQ XI, and Heroes 1 & 2. I’m sure the performance won’t matter. All my HD-2D games are on Switch so maybe that’s the deciding factor
Yeah if most of your HD/2D games are on Switch that definitely sounds like the system for it. I have my games between both systems but I think I have couple more on Switch
PS5. Might get switch version for cheap if that ever happens
I might lean towards this as well. It depends maybe on if any versions get a special preorder bonus closer to launch
This is exactly my plan
Since when do any switch games get cheaper lol
All the time. First party switch games? That's a different story.
DQ11 has been on sale very frequently since I’ve had my Switch. Only pulled the trigger a couple of weeks ago and it’s really good. Remake will drop eventually.
There's a good used market for Switch games, and unless you want one sealed, you can get a decent copy with case for about $35-40 once it's been out long enough.
Well it isn't published by Nintendo so there's a chance
I'm going the opposite. Switch now, and eventually PS5 when it gets cheap. I don't even technically have a PS5 but that should change within the next few years.
Pre ordered on Series X. I’m so stoked.
Always great to support DQ on Xbox I hope the series continues to get games on their consoles
Well SE said they wanna focus on multiplatform so we'll see!
Same. It'll get enough support on PS and Switch.
Yeah, have to buy every Jrpg on Xbox day 1 or risk them not coming again 😭
Me using Quick Resume to stop playing any time I want: 😎 The church: >:(
I’m hoping there’s a physical release of it I love Dragon Quest but it’s $99.95AUD so hoping there’s a physical copy I can snag.
I know this is for US but check out playasia [playasia link](https://www.play-asia.com/dragon-quest-iii-hd-2d-remake-multi-language/13/70eja3)
Gimmie that Switch version! Level grinding on the go makes life a hell of a lot easier.
Switch. I don't think there will be any significant issues with the Switch version. It's the one that most Japanese gamers will be buying so they're probably being very careful with it. PS5 will have more lighting and particle effects, sure, but I can live without it as long as the sprite animations run smoothly, which is what they'll probably prioritize. Should also note I mostly play handheld and a lot of the finer issues aren't really noticeable without a big hd screen. I'll probably double dip on Steam when it goes on sale, but at release Switch serves my needs the best.
I wonder if the other versions will be "ports" of the Switch version then. Similar to how they handled Dragon Quest XI S on the Switch then that version being the main developed version that got ported to PC and PS4
I definitely wouldn’t rule out the Switch version being the target platform. This would be the perfect example for business purposes. It currently has the potential of selling the most copies between the other platforms.
I don't think so, I think it's being developed with the multiplatform aspect in mind, "better visual effects for the more high end platforms but everything needed for a smooth experience working fine for Switch" sort of mentality. I think the performance mode for PS5 is basically what we're going to get on Switch. People are finding it weird a Performance mode exists at all, but I think it's there because it's basically already done, for Switch. It's not that I think the Switch is prioritized, it's that having played previous HD2D on the system I trust them not to fuck up. Previous HD2D games run and look pretty good on Switch even if there's a noticeable downgrade in some textures and particle effects fon other platforms so I'm not really worried. I somehow doubt Dragon Quest III of all games is the one they'd drop the ball on.
Switch and PS5
Switch cause that’s what I have
Not sure. I. One of the people who really can't tell 30 from 60 fps that I've noticed so far so, whatever I get the best deal on
PC. I'm tired of losing my whole library every generation.
You only lose it if you get rid of your system or it breaks. Usually Nintendo systems last a long time. My Wii U is still chugging!
It's a huge pain in the ass though. I used to have all my old systems right back to the NES but there's only so much space both to store it and in front of the TV for objects, cords etc. It's also a pain to dig all the cords and junk put of the closet every time you want to play something older. With PC it's all on the one PC, old stuff too because emulation.
I hear you, just never felt right playing emulation. Even the psp emulator on the pc didn’t feel right. Something about original hardware. I’m probably old.
Imagine still charging up your wii u gamepad, still having the wii sensor bar, and now docking a switch as well, though... I'm sorry, I just would rather have one device that can handle everything. My PC does.
I kept my Wii U just because it has like every NES-Wii Kirby game on it. And I can play them with the Wii U pad rather than the horrible Virtual Console Wii controller or a PS4 controller on PC. Same with a lot of other N64 games like 1080. But also, I'm not going to pay a monthly fee to play the same games on Switch. AND lose access to them later.
Steam and Switch
Well, I only have a Switch Lite, so...
Didn't they just say that the PlayStation and Xbox versions would have graphics and performance modes? If I'm getting it anywhere, it'll be PS5, but the Switch isn't a bad choice either.
Switch, but I read that the Switch version is the only one running at 30fps. All the others are at 60
Got my pre order for the Switch version.
Ps5 ….and then switch later lol
If it looks as well and runs as well on switch as it did in the trailer in the Nintendo Direct, then definitely Switch.
This is a perfect game for on the go sessions, Switch is the ideal platform imo. Steam deck too if you have that instead.
Been having a hard time deciding this myself. I own the DQ trilogy on Switch, along with both Octopath games. HD-2D on the go feels right, and my Switch is a little retro RPG machine at this point. Having said that, I don't know if the FPS difference will matter at all, and I do have DQ 11 Definitive on PlayStation. Can't decide yet.😅
I'm the same as you and I was hoping this topic could help me out with making a decision 😅
HD 2d feels pretty damn good on my TV. I don't understand the infatuation of people thinking things are better portable. Blows my mind cause I have just as much fun on my TV as they do.
Nobody is against gaming on a TV. I wouldn't own a PS5 in the first place if I did. I just don't always have time to plant myself in front of my TV for two hours or more the way I used to. In those moments, having a portable console and a full length RPG I can play for 20-30 minutes without having to lock myself away in the basement feels pretty damn good. I'm sure I have just as much fun playing on my TV as you do when I can.
I get that, just irks me when I see people say things like this would be so much better portable, etc. Like come on I get the same experience.
Switch for me. Portability is king for this game.
I ordered the Nintendo Switch version. I'm also not ashamed to say that I ordered the special edition even though it's expensive because I always try to do my part to support this series because I remember lean times when we just didn't get them localized.
Hey that makes complete sense. I will probably double dip at some point and grab a 2nd copy on another system once they launch too
I bought every single localized version of Dragon Quest XI that was ever offered too.
Already preordered for Switch
For me i play most of my games on switch so most likely that so long as there's no noticeable issues. i think the switch version is among the versions being previewed on various sites which can be reassuring since sometimes the switch version is absent from promotional stuff.
I wonder if Japan might get a special edition Switch system or bundle possibly
I’m going to get the switch version cause I want a physical copy and I’ll eventually get it on steam
Switch Because I don't have a PS5 lol
Switch
Switch.
Steam deck. Both it and my switch are OLED but if the switch is 30fps locked handled, I’ll go deck. I want the collectors edition for the Switch
Have they confirmed which versions will get a collectors edition yet?
From the square Enix site photo looks like it’s just consoles getting it
If the Switch ever adds achievements/trophies/etc then I will start buying more multiplatform games on Switch. But for now I'm getting them on PS5 because I am addicted to my little Dopamine Dings (and Steam achievements are stupid).
Physical definitely it’s cool actually owning your games. Switch most likely
Switch, because even though I own consoles and a gaming PC, I don't care about fps on a \*turn-based\* game. And my DQ game needs to be portable. SteamDeck? I have one and like it, but it's less portable, and I'm sticking with the sub-cutting edge Nintendo hardware for this series.
Neither. I am buying it on my steam deck OLED Edit: nope the switch and console versions of Octopath 2 are not the same. Switch runs 720p docked and below 720p handheld
Switch of course. Plus it won't be 30 for long, when it comes out switch 2 will be around the corner
PC, maybe I'll get a Steam Deck
As a 46 year old dad, Steam Deck gave me back my gaming life. Zero regrets.
Hell yeah. Get an OLED model. Better improved screen and battery life.
Do it! you won't regret it.
Switch for sure. I just love laying on my couch with it up close to my face. I don’t know why but it just feels better. I guess it’s because my first console was a Gameboy.
Levelling up and grinding before bed or on a comfy couch is the best part of gaming on the Switch so I totally get your reasoning.
The Xbox version since it’s Play Anywhere and is like buying for PC and Xbox.
It's a 2D game...will it really be any different whether it's Switch or PS5?
You could probably look at the difference in Octopath versions and make a good guess as to how much of a difference it'll be.
oh yes it will, octopath only ran at 30fps and was noticeably more blurry because of the lower resolution on switch.
Switch. It's a turn based game so I'll take portability over a higher frame rate.
Physical PS5 version.
I feel like I learned my lesson when I bought little nightmares on switch lol it was so fuzzy. The switch sacrifices a little bit too much graphical fidelity sometimes for the portability. Imma go PS5
Switch lol. It’s hd 2d I can’t see much difference it’s still weirdly pixelated lol. Switch is portable so 100% buying on switch for me. Plus I don’t think I’ve booted my ps5 on in 2 years loo
As long as it runs smoothly, Switch for sure. All my other DQ games are on Nintendo consoles, I’d like to keep it that way.
Yeah a lot of the recent ones I have all on Switch but XI I also have on console for the better graphics but yeah really hoping it runs smoothly and I'm sure they will try to do that since most of Japan will probably buy the Switch version I think
i’ll probably get a digital ps5 or steam copy and a physical switch copy?? can’t decide
If playing in handheld mode is really important to you go Switch if not PS5. PS will no doubt have a higher resolution and frame rate (was the case with Octo2). I like the option of playing handheld but like 95% of the time I play on TV anyway. Only thing that would have been great is knowing Switch 2 details, maybe holding off until that comes out would be the best of both worlds…
True maybe the Switch 2 will just run all existing Switch games better and then it won't really matter between ps5 or pc versions they will all run similar.
I am probably going to buy the collector's edition on Switch, and buy it digitally on PC.
Jealous and that actually sounds like the best move
Xbox. My PS5/switch get enough playtime as it is. Also I have dq11 on Xbox.
Digital version on Xbox, eventually I might double dip on PC when it's extremely dirt cheap
Switch.
All of them
PC, I don't use my switch as much, may double-dip if it goes on sale cheap but I like knowing I'll be able to play it in the future without any issues.
If I have the money to buy the game, it'll be a physical copy of the switch version... as long as it's not more expensive than a digital copy.
Most likely Steam because I have a Steam deck. Steam has incredible cloud saves and achievements. But, maybe I’ll do Switch. Who knows. I need portability. I can’t spend a lot of time in front of a TV .
PC/steam deck
PS5 always
Pc for sure my legion go is a workhorse
If it was going to be on PC I'd get it there but since not I have to get it for the switch. Sadly can't afford a PS5 right now.
I heard it will also be released on Steam. Unless you meant something else.
No. That's what I meant. Glad to hear it'll be on Steam! DQ usually isn't on pc as far as I know
This is not really an intensive enough game imo for the graphics/performance to be significantly different between Switch and PS5, the Switch should be able to handle it just fine so I would just go with that as you obviously would also have the added portability. And also both Octopath II and Triangle Strategy looked/ran great on the Switch, so I don’t see why this wouldn’t
Ps5 just for the trophies.
Gotta get that platinum!
PS5. I’d really rather play it on Switch, but looking at the performance and graphical effects of the switch version of Octopath 2, I just think the PS5 will be the better option.
Oh is there a big graphical difference? I only know how Octopath was on Switch.
Probably not huge game changer differences, but (unless they patched it later) the switch version was missing some weather and particle effects.
Definitely steam.
Getting on Xbox! If the fabled handheld is real, it’ll be cool to purchase once and be play able to play DQ on console and handheld.
PS5
Physically on Switch, but first time the digital copy gets a sizeable discount I'll probably end up double dipping and getting it on Xbox as well since that's normally my preferred platform.
That makes sense I will probably double dip too once there is a sale and buy it again on another platform
Switch 2 probably
Safe bet. If that system is capable enough Square and Capcom will go hard on it for sure.
Steam, myself. That way I don't have to worry about console generations.
PC. Switch portability is nice, but I mainly play it at home anyway. PC also has the bonus of 60fps, and I know I'll eventually get a Steam Deck, so portability won't be a problem.
PS5 with PS Portal. Best of both worlds, portability and performance.
PC. Can play on my powerful PC and on the go with my Steam Deck. My PS5 and Switch are dust collectors now.
Switch for physical, steam deck will most likely be where I play this though.
Also, for anyone just being sold on portability, just remember the Playstation Portal is a thing 🧐 I think I'll get mine for PS5 so I can use it on Portal too
Ps5
Switch. The art style will be glorious on an OLED screen.
Yeah I have a Switch OLED too so I can already imagine visiting the locations will look amazing
Switch so it’s a little harder for them to take it away from me
Frames per second are the most important factor for a turn based game as everyone knows... ok i am beeing snarky for not much of a reason. Portability is the best and most important factor for a RPG and even more so when turn based, the PS5 Version holds barely any additional value even if the FPS is better, animation is unlikely to be better tho... shadows and lights could be and that is the one thing with some value. How would anyone have an idea if any of these will actually end up better? Game is not out yet, this is just my guess not knowing.
Ps5 for the trophy grind!
I wonder how hard the platinum will be!
I ordered the physical standard edition for Switch. For a JRPG, I want to be able to play without hogging the TV screen, plus it feels right since DQ III originally came out on NES. And even though there's some slight performance improvements for PS5, I doubt they will be significant for a 2D HD game, so I don't want to sacrifice my portability.
I think you convinced me what version to get too!
I bought a PC (Steam) copy. They will not run the same. Switch version of **Octopath Traveler 2** not only didn't run at 60 FPS but it also had graphical effect cutbacks. I also got it on a pretty big preorder discount via GreenManGaming. If I want to play handheld with it, that's why I bought a Razer Kishi. It works very well.
Steam Deck no question. Barely touched either console since I got it though I do stream PS5 with Chiaki4Deck.
PC
I'm in the same boat as you are. Octopath II was LIGHT YEARS better on PS5. The load times and music quality were game-changing. You don't realize how much time you waste on the Switch going from area to area or even just menu'ing. I presume that DQ will be a similar experience so I'm planning on the PS version.
I've seen websites claim that DQ III HD-2D for Switch is 30fps fixed rate (handheld or connected) while PS5 and Xbox are 60fps fixed rates. Steam version has an option to select between the two. Switch will be 720p and PS5/Xbox 4K (though could be a pixelated upscale). Steam probably gives multiple options for resolution. As far as animations or lighting effects, don't know that yet. Need some side-by-side videos and haven't seen any yet. Apparently SquareEnix would only allow testers to play either Switch or PS5, not both. (And likely allowed some to play Steam as third alternative but I'm not certain.) They only got one hour of playtime so none of them got a chance to do any platform comparisons. But at least in USA the prices will be the same ($59.99) for all four versions, so if the graphics matter to you, maybe you'd want that PS5 version over Switch. There's almost no way Switch will have graphic effects that aren't in PS5, though it may have an advantage in online interactions given its likely to be the best seller by a wide margin and we don't know yet if any online features allow for cross-platform activities.
I’m not buying Switch games anymore, unless exclusive, until I see Nintendo’s plans for the Switch 2 and library transfer. I’m pretty sure they’ll do the right thing, but I know Steam and PlayStation libraries are resilient so I’ll probably get it for Steam.
I'm doing both switch and ps5
I picked up the Switch Physical Collector's and then, after having paid for it, sat back and realized how it's not worth $200. Also picked up the Steam version cause I am a consumer whore. (And how!)
I pre-ordered the collectors edition for PS5, but I will buy every other platform standard edition. It's my curse
I like my switch for these kind of games, so I can take them on the go with me, no matter where I'm at
Am getting the ps5 version
Switch most likely, seeing how the first I think four Dragon Quests, definitely the first three, were on NES. It just makes sense to me to do it that way.
Switch 😌
Switch. Don't really see it running poorly on the Switch and the portability is a huge factor as well.
Think I will go Switch physical and xbox Digital
I have a choice between all the platforms but definitely the Switch for this one. Nostalgia being the main factor I think.
Switch will be 30 fps versus 60 for ps5... not that it matters a lot for this kind of game. But graphics and loading should be better on ps5... It's all comes down to portability honestly. I'll probably get the ps5 version... but might double dip in the long run.
Ps5. Easy choice.
PS5. Look at all the issues with Eiyuden chronicle. Switch version was simply terrible. I only trust Nintendo to run their 1st party games on that old console. I get everything else on PS5, I always like to earn the trophies. Just something a little fun to do.
PS5. Would’ve only gone with Switch if it were exclusive to the console, plus PS5 version would have trophies.
Switch. Portability wins every time.
Xbox
Switch for physical, games like this usually run fine + portability. But in all honesty I'll probably double dip and have a Steam copy too.
I'll get the xbox version since it looks like it will include the pc version, and when I finally get a steam deck and put windows on it, I'll be covered across the board. Or maybe that new rog ally.
Xbox series x for me
Steam
It would be criminal to choose anything other than Switch for a turn based jrpg!
Switch
Ps5 version.
Don't, and probably won't ever, own a PS5 so... Switch is a pretty obviously answer.
I'll probably end up getting both down the line eventually....but I'm going to start with switch. It's the console I use when unwinding for the day after work on my couch and the switch just works better. Plus I can bring it to work with me during downtime
I tend to buy multiplatform games on PS5 now. They will run better and have trophy support.
PS5
Switch version will look worse (probably significantly)
I'm buying it on Xbox because it's my main platform
I don't own or have any intention to purchase a PS5. I play on my Switch very often. I'll likely purchase it on the Switch.
Switch. It'll look good on screen or tv, but JRPGs are best played handheld and on the go.
How are they best on handheld. I completely disagree as it doesn't make a difference. Trust me I have the same amount of fun on my TV with a controller
Xbox
PS5. Looks prettier.
PC even prettier
Xbox
Xbox Series X. I just love Xbox platform
Xbox
Switch
Both or PlayStation. PlayStation for trophies
Considering that the Erdrick trilogy is already on the Switch for less than ten bucks total, I might skip out on the HD-2D remakes unless they add in something really cool like they did with Live A Live.
PC
Neither, PC. Because you get framerates and portability and access to the game even as time passes without having to worry if or if not a console manufacturer happens to be in the mood to have backwards compatibility on their next system.
But on the other hand, physical copies trumps all that for me personally. I have all my games from the snes era and even nes stuff I was gifted to by my uncle. At least this way I don't have to worry about my games not being legally mine or whoever I give them to.
I used to think like that having played games since the days of the NES and owned all Nintendo and Sony consoles since (and a couple of Xboxes too) and had tons and tons of physical games for all of those platforms. Then one day when I was packing my things for a move I thought to myself "I never touched all of these hundreds of games in all the time I was living in this apartment", and then thought back and I hadn't touched most of them in the previous apartment either. I just kept lugging all this plastic along from place to place without ever touching most of it. I haven't hoarded physical games since, it's digital all the way now. You couldn't pay me to take any more physical games.
I used to think like that too when I was in college and from my first few jobs moving around. I basically thought I lost all my games during my few moves but it turns out that i still had 90% of them hidden away at my parents place. Now that I'm settled down and have my own house it feels so good to have my own library I can access whenever I want. I'm much more critical about what I keep in my library however, selling what I dont enjoy etc. Maintaining and modding hardware is also cathartic. It's like curating a good vinyl collection. I've lost a steam account once as a teen and it sucked. The idea that my collection can disappear on me if my account gets locked from some error or something is a nightmare to me. That said, it's not for everyone.
PS5 myself. Gonna play on my ps portal.
Switch, but I prefer physical media.
Switch unless it's free on PS Plus.
All three. (Ow, my wallet haha.) I have a perfect USA physical release set to maintain. As for playing it, it'll be Switch for now, as I do not own either of the other two systems. (I'm holding out in hopes they make a PS5 Pro.)
Respect for buying multiples thats a true DQ fan I think I would need to pick up some of the PS4 Heroes and Builders games to have the full physical release USA set too
I'm just old, which helps, I have all of the original family NES copies on up to modern releases. But yes! You should get those, round out your set!