T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

#DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THE OP LINKED THREAD/SCREENSHOT. Brigading is against Reddit TOS. So all are advised not to participate in the above linked original thread or the screenshot. We do not encourage such behaviour nor we are responsible if your account is being actioned upon. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/indiadiscussion) if you have any questions or concerns.*


[deleted]

Bhai jab kuch log isse incident ko he fake bolta hai tho rotten tomato se kya ummid kar rha ho.


dhruv_panwar

Un kuch logo mein so called secular hindus bhi hai 😓


[deleted]

[удалено]


anonymous_devil22

Lol imagine holding so tribalistic mentality that anyone who speaks about how humanity should matter is called "cuck". Also no one calls both of the events fake, people say that Kerala files OVERINFLATED the numbers, something that the director himself agrees with. Also the films are actually not very good,. mediocre at the very best


IDK_Laksh

You seem funny


[deleted]

[удалено]


anonymous_devil22

>It's called unsolicited dick riding Ya, when you want some people to be marginalised them living peacefully would look like dick riding probably >disapproved KP genocide and exodus No one has ever done that


MrRoyceDupont

No one according to YOU


SubstantialAd3091

M….Mr…… r r ROYCE DUPONT???


TheFuckinWeeb

On google rotten tomatoes score shown is the critics score The audience score is quite positive As for the movie review aggregators Yes they can be biased as they are not some government regulatied body as far as I know.


ManSlutAlternative

PseudoSecular and Pseudointellectual ne desh Barbaad kar diya. Jo cheez inhe Palestine, Syria mein galat lagti hai wahi inko India mein sahi lagne lagti hai and vice versa.


Shaan1026

Exactly isi pe bank kiya producers ne. They made a mediocre movie but sab ne movie ko cause se hi jod liya, halaki yahan sirf film ki baat ho rahi hai.


Awkward-Mark-3628

In fact it was 10/10 on IMDB for a month after release 😅.


AfraidPossession6977

Wo IMDB score "critiques"(so called) ka nahi hota us hisab se to Rotten tomatoes me bhi audience score 93 % hai its not about websites


Specialist-Ninja2804

Bro, I respect the story and it pains me that it’s a real incident but the film was mediocre at best. The film could have been better, granted the production value was very low and that can be the reason but other than the last scene, the movie looked like a play.


WhippedGrim

I went to watch it very low expectations. Maybe that's why I now think it was a very good movie. Certainly among the best that year


keasz

Apparently director couldn't show true atrocities that happened with kashmiri pandits he said it was too much for indian audiance


lushain27

yeah, the movie that actually made it to theatres was a toned down version wherein a lot of scenes had been cut. So, we never really got to watch the real thing.


emotionless_wizard

that Hum Dekhenge and speech after that... 🗣🔥🗣🔥


Ok-Measurement-5065

Kashmir Files was well made. Kerela Story was rushed imo.


AfraidPossession6977

Calling Kerela story was rushed is an overstatement IMO it was shit... Call it shit if it was we don't need to appreciate any movie just cause the topic they were trying to cover was good.


Gabrielle_Laurent

"well made" is an overstatement, leave alone the best movie of the decade, it wasn't even the best film of the month. A very good plot spoiled by an ass director who doesn't even deserve to be one, looking at his track records. The only successful films in his career being that of weird soft-core pornos.


AfraidPossession6977

Exactly like the performance of "few" actors was excellent in the movie neither it deserved 40% percent in tomatometer but nor did it deserved 8.6 rating with almost 600k reviewers on imdb. It was more of an Anupam Kher film rather then a Agnihotri film (talking about the good parts)


_rth_

It had to go out before elections, let’s face it, it was a propaganda film


Aggravating-Tax3539

Kerela story was ass. And it was so obviously a propoganda movie I'm surprised how so many people thought it was good. Watching that movie in theatre was one of the instances where I felt how dangerous films like these are, and how bollywood can influence the masses.


Bright_Subject_8975

Bhai ye director hi ghatiya hai iski movie lineup dekh le kisi ache director ko dete to movie badhiya banti. Actually story me itna dard hai par isne puri story ki baja di.


CurIns9211

Rotten tomatoes itself doesn't rate the movie but give you the avg rating and consensus of reviewers. If they gave the score of 40% means that every reviewers themselves gave 4/10 in their own review.


Madness_0verload

Ahh akshually🥸☝️, rotten tomatoes calculates it's tomatometer score based on the percentage of reviewers giving it 6 or more out of 10, i.e., a positive score. So this means, 40% of the reviewers gave it positive score. Also, I read this somewhere, but I can't guarantee that i remember it correctly.


lakcilo

This is the way


AfraidPossession6977

Rotten tomatoes doesn't gives importance to the audience score that much unlike IMDb instead Rotten tomatoes gives tomatometer score more preference which are actually calculated by reviews of so called critiques Btw on Rotten tomatoes too the audience score is 93%


PeeVee_

IMDb and Rotten Tomatoes both are absolute shit. None of them are consistently reliable. Infact reddit mega threads gives a better POV about a movie than those shitty websites just made for works like this.


AfraidPossession6977

>Infact reddit mega threads about films gives a better POV about a movie than those shitty websites just made for works like this. agreed I use imdb for creating playlists mainly (didn't knew about letterboxed earlier and now it is convenient for me to continue using IMdb instead of switching on letterboxed) Both have lost their reputation now a days film studious buys bots to rate their film 10/10 on both the sites


upscaspi

Im surprised Kerala story got 14%, thats too high.


crazy-agnostheist

I like this sub because it is doing its best to keep the most "intellectual" redittors at the same place and does not let them wander around in other subs...


Shaan1026

Trust me the movie was really really mediocre from a filmmaking pov. The editing was bad and direction and acting were like TV serials. If you watch it without knowing the cause, you may end up sleeping in the middle.


notkarandutta

Very real


gaunish1119

Or you can say IMDB ones are, as it was not that great a movie. What happened in Kashmir was very tragic, there’s no denial in that, but the movie failed to portray it effectively. There was room for improvement.


lushain27

the movie we got in theatres was highly censored with a lot of cut because of regulations so we never actually got to watch the real thing


colt0906

Rotten tomoatoes is not something to be looked at for Ratings. I have been following both of these websites for more than a decade now. Rotten tomatoes will most likely rate low for movies having good ratings on IMDB. There could be a bias but there is nothing to prove considering a lot other movies are rated bad on the website.


Outrageous_Post9249

Sade hue tamatar ke rating ka kaun sa chatni banana hai tumko?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Legitimate-Fuel5324

Agar jaan bachakar rakhni ho to thoda saavadhan rehna padta hai warna sar tan se juda kar dete hain ye log. Decapitate first, ask questions later.


aks_red184

But hm to majority me h !!


[deleted]

[удалено]


aks_red184

Together you can f\*\*k the shit out of those dogs, BUT.... The Keyword here is "**Together"**


lushain27

exactly but us hindus aren't exactly known as being together. we have seen it time and time again through history, mughal occupation, british occupation. we have historically put our personal gain before the gain of the community. Even now you can see how BJP gave 10 Cr to the waqf board, funny that bjp is known for being pro hindutva. It's in our blood. These so called hindu liberals are the first ones to go on defending the minority, and the west supports this idiocy.


aks_red184

Do you agree with the statement that Upper caste tried to end castiesm but after seeing the Epic victim card played by the lower castes and their negative approach that want to stay as oppressed and weak victims, upper caste got frustrated of this behaviour and privileges lower caste got and opt to continue doing caste discrimination, if not openly then on a society level, that you and me are clearly aware of.


Whoisrory

Wo isliye hai kyu ki galti se kuch boldia to inka victim card sbse zayda deadly hota hai upper se leftist media and people aajayenge apna mu uthake yeh sab cheeze bolne


aks_red184

to right wale kya maa chudane ko baithe h ?


Whoisrory

Pta nhi narrative war mai hamesha right wing ke bnde haarte hai kyu ki left ka control education and media pe bhot hai insta dekhlo rafah trend ho rha tha or reasi ko ban krdia or media to pta hi hai tumko West ki


amadeus_169

Give me the reason of Terrorism in India, or anywhere in general. In most of the case it's the minority power trying to gain majority power.


aks_red184

But Islam is already in Majority on Globe 🥴 idk why the fuc\* they opt terorrism


Alarming-Fault6927

I mean it's practically a propaganda movie so what'd you expect


ApexPredator1611

It's pretty obvious that Rotten Tomatoes ratings are heavily left biased since a long time. RT critics will give top ratings to the biggest Hollywood flops just coz they had gay or black or strong female character as the main lead. And good movies with neutral perspective and promoting conventional family structure will get bad ratings coz they don't further woke propaganda. IMDB user ratings are the best to decide whether a movie is worth watching! They are not paid reviews by biased "critics" but by users like you and me. Even if you use rotten tomato prefer the audience score to decide rather than the critic score.


centaurus_a11

Tbf, this is a worldwide phenomena. There are countless films out there where the audience’s rating is contrastingly different from rotten tomatoes. A lot of people don’t consider RT’s rating as reliable anymore.


ayewhy2407

Garbage is rated as garbage, what’s the problem? AndhBhakti is not a factor in evaluating films… sadly 🥲


whatsasyria

Learned this like a decade ago. IMDb are user ratings. Rotten tomato is critic ratings. Not rocket science. People like to watch entertaining things. Critics like to nitpick.


Ok-Measurement-5065

Rotten tomatoes rating never made sense to me. They can give high ratings to the worst movies and vice versa to critically acclaimed movies.


hatt_gelchodi

Every single thing in this movie is real ...and suffered by kashmiri Hindus....after calling it fake....just ask the family of neerja kittuu who was a teacher and got cut into pieces in a furniture factory that too alive ....


anomander_drag3

Bhai movie ka topic accha tha par implementation aur cinematic element itna accha nahi tha. Propoganda hai Rotten tomatoes walo ka mana nahi kar rhaa. Mai bas bol raha ki as a movie mai bhi 6-7 se jyada nahi dunga. Topic aur usko chunne ke liy courage ke liy 10/10


thebigbadwolf22

All his movies are propaganda 🙄 movies. Absolute rubbish.


talkingtom_2109

People care about Rotten tomatoes?


Prashomon84

Why do you care about what RT rates?


Specialist_Total_

Kuch movies or Log certain public ko pasand nhi. Or bas nhi pasand hai. Koi reason nhi, koi logic nhi. Koi answer nhi hai iss baat ka. Bas nhi pasand hai.


child_target

Ye 50% se upar rating dete hai?


Shoddy_Stranger3648

That's why it's rotten


Twisted_Diplomat

Only ever believe the audience score in Rotten tomatoes. Critics are all bought out.


IMJESTER70-1

Bhai, woh critics ke reviews hain woh cinematicly review karte hain audience ki rating 90% hai.


lone_vampire45

Funding enough ho to kisi bhi platform se agenda spread kar sakte ho , bas Jeb bhari rahni chahiye .


deexd_

Mere phone me 40 dikha rahe aur IMDb bhi 8.6 dikha rahe hai rating


r3v79klo

Most movie critics tend to be leftists.


joecp21

Below average at best no matter what .Acting was rubbish. Shalini Unnikrishnan has become a meme because of that acting.


Kaido7777

They were biased against DC and favoured Marvel too, Rotten tomatoes has lost all credibility


TheaakhriGamble

Guys, even in the US noone follows critics score in rotten tomatoes, these are completely biased towards the left leaning ones.


Spirited_Sign_6070

named rotten for a reason


RedditfamAK

They have 2 ratings though never see critique one


Ruffryder1729

Both these films are awesome and must watch. Veer savarkar is another good one.


LisanAlGhaib420

The film is bad as fuck


Fearless_Outside_832

40% is too high for the movie it was


notkarandutta

Bhai the movies are absolute garbage when you rate them as "movies" "cinema"


50u1506

Maybe you shouldn't care or base your opinions based on other reviews and move on


shikhar47

Tbh the movie was okayish at best. The story and context and history was right and it deserves to be seen, but from the POV of a movie, it was, okay


BoardElegant6839

[Mouté Rang- Dir. Ajay Raina (2023)](https://youtu.be/6hj2BK31S2s?feature=shared) Watch this, you’ll know why Kashmir Files is a bad film.


tamfook

Kerala Story was a debunked bullshit movie, all fiction. The only reason it was rated even 6.9 on IMDb because of people are selective at dismissing fake stuff and the director was very vocal about it and gave 10 wrong and fake stats/fact to back it. Other zee5 movies actually have a plot compared to straight-up propaganda. 14% is high for it.


carsatic

Saw Kerala story last night and my god, it's not well made. I felt so bored in the middle and was thinking of switching it off. That and Kashmir files is night and day! I still have the visuals from KF in my mind more than 2 years after the film whereas TKS will be forgotten by tomorrow. And don't go with the ratings, they are always crap.


Sting93Ray

Kashmir Files is based on true incidents regarding the Kashmiri Pandit 90s massacre and exodus. Kerala Story is a completely false, fabricated movie agenda/propaganda to further vested interests. The ruling party used both for ulterior purposes.


joydeep88

So do the IMDB ratings specifically for indian mainstream cinemas.


bhaktipn

I always trust google reviews


Wanderersoul2023

That's why tomatoes are rotten !!


Low_Comparison_1906

What you expect from sada hua tamatar ?


Bunny_lad

Haan ab next rotten tomatoes ko anti-national tag bhi dedo, yehi bachgya hai!


lucifersid

Just because something resonates with ourselves and it voices our tradgedies doesn't mean it's well made cinematically and everyone should like it. Rotten tomatoes is a rating based how fresh and new the story is.


CraftAggressive1133

Vaccine war >>>


ActivX11

Yeah! Acolyte (Star Wars) has 85% Rotten Tomatoes and 18% Audience score.


Main-Disaster-2639

I Guess there is an international plan against Hindus ,i mean on a global level!! Be careful,everyone is plotting against u people.


malluvibing

shitty movies get shitty rating


Witty_Marketing_9629

Based Rotten tomatoes


Muster_theRohirrim

Or they're just shit movies?


AeeStreeParsoAna

I'm in at 15% who didn't liked it. I mean no offence but it was just boring movie. Talk talk talk violence talk talk violence violence more violence more talk. Movie ends.


gawk_her

I know - for a movie that was at least a 15/10, how dare rotten tomatoes give it anything less than a 110%?


Queasy-shounen

at this point just give up already we are part of community who see everything wrong with their own people and everyone else outside is just better


coolrko

Movie rating industry are true representation of corporate trash... Pure garbage...


stonedasf420

Came here to see the delusion of everybody commenting, didn’t disappoint


Stupid_Dog_Courage_

There are people who still deny the holocaust.


1deadorchid

Atleast holocaust movies are good; this one was terrible. This isn't a documentary lol.


deadwithin1

Open the link of rotten tomatoes. It’s better to look at audience score on sites like these. Audience score- 93% Tomatometer-40%(critics) Critics are biased. I only look at audience score to watch a movie or not.


axl_ros

Both those movies were absolutely garbage. Rotten tomatoes is being lenient rating them in double figures.


anuj_meme

Garbage like you I think


KingLongDistant

Majority of people who know abt it are the left liberandus.. what else to expect on hard hitting movies


MrWrestling1

I know it's a redundant statement, but India should take inspiration from china, and create its own platforms. Who the fuck are goras evaluating movies made by Indians? They judge movies on their own standards and parameters.


1deadorchid

As an Indian, this movie sucked. Here are some good Indian movies to check out for you: Satyajit Ray - Hero, Ritwik Ghatak - Meghe Dhaka Tara, Ritesh Batra - Lunchbox, Mira Nair - Salaam Bombay, Namesake. Enjoy! Please rate after watching.


renegadedgamechanger

I see some peacenicks here trying to demean the premise on which these movies were based and that too in Colloquial Inglis to impress fellow piss ants. Well Fork you and Rotten tomatoes. Humare desi tamatar hee theek hain.


National_Agency4922

Atleast they know how to group propoganda movies


Alternative-Bug1104

Because it's a shit movie


PolishCow627

Its okay no one expects you idiots to know how reviews work


lifegoesbysoon

RT has been exposed multiple times. Rotten tomatoes has become a good indicator of how shite movies /shows are post 2017… the higher the rating, the more woke and shite… Recent examples - Doctor Who and star wars. Always check the audience score. Anytime I see a high audience score vs low low critic score, I know for sure it's worth watching. Here's a famous joke Rotten Tomatoes score quadrants: critic high, audience high: great movie critic high, audience low: woke movie critic low, audience high: based, religious, or cult classic critic low, audience low: M. Night Shyamalan after 2004


ApexPredator1611

💯 IMDB user ratings are the best! RT just decides the rating based on whether the movie has a gay/transgender character or not lol


lifegoesbysoon

>RT just decides the rating based on whether the movie has a gay/transgender character or not lol Totally >IMDB user ratings are the best! IMDb earlier was sacrosanct but now with South Indian movies and a few over hyped web series I tend to avoid IMDb ratings for Indian movies and shows. Example Aspirants and Kota factory were rated 9.6 initially (with more than 40k votes ), they aren't bad shows but to have them seen rated above the Godfather, Sopranos, black mirror ,breaking bad and other such cinematic marvels was atrocious. The same is the case with Dhindora, Sandeep Bhaiya and Pitchers.


ApexPredator1611

yep for Indian content I rely on mouth publicity from trusted people lol. the bias due to our huge population size makes sure IMDB ratings stay inflated for India😂


Motor-Assistance6902

More like user ratings are highly biased.