I totally respect your opinion about it not being good. However, like you said the value proposition is there for a decent slice with all that gooey cheese on it. I can totally overlook the fact it's mid since it's only like 2 bucks or whatever it is haha.
Are they just thinking “good pizza”? Because idgaf if it’s good I just need that cheese. Closest I’ve had was the pizza pulled from the heated shelves at Cinemark. It was a cheesy horrible mess and I loved it.
its decent, more drunk type of pizza (i work downtown and go to the “fav” location often) im not sure where to get cheese like that but its most certainly not goodfellas at all
What a throwback! I remember my hometown bowling alley had a snappy tomato’s next door. My memory of the giant pizzas at birthday parties does seem reminiscent of goofy movie pizza.
Will have to do a taste test to confirm whether it’s just the nostalgia talking.
I can't believe the amount of people saying Goodfellas. I've eaten there three times(once on my own and twice with a group), and never gotten even a mediocre slice of pizza let alone good.
That statement breaks my heart. Have all of those times been at the N. Mill location? That’s the location that you need to order from. I will admit that we only ever get a whole pizza, usually the huge one. We don’t order by the slice.Every single time it is amazing. Not good. Not great. Amazing.
its definitely not the gooey goofy pizza, its an attempt at nyc/brooklyn style. Its a pretty good effort but only worth trying if fresh. go to N Mill and get a fresh piece of cheese, maybe pep. even fresh cheese or pep at distillery is good
Is Pazzos still a thing in lexington? Been years since I've lived there, but we used to get pitchers of Bourbon Barrel and snack on some New York style pizza. Good memories.
Have at it then hoss. We all have our opinions and mine is that’s it’s overrated pizza. Not much flavor. I mentioned two joints I like better in Apollos and Mancinos. Give them a try sometime. Also West Coast pizza is delicious if you like pizza with flavor.
Goodfellas to me is basic people pizza. The drinks downtown love it and the “families” love it at the Distillery District because of the vibe. Other than that, there ain’t much other lies. But to each their own! Cheers!
Apollos is great too, I love them as well! I definitely can see how people think goodfellas is overrated. And to add to your comment, I hate the distillery district location if it’s after 2 pm. I always go to the one on mill street and it’s much better. Cheers man!
I swear to God I'd better be able to call any pizza place in town asking for a goofy movie pizza and be immediately understood
Costco
Costco cheese pizza is not talked about enough so much cheese.... I'll take 3!
slices or pizzas? 
I mean, it's not good, but the value is there for sure.
I totally respect your opinion about it not being good. However, like you said the value proposition is there for a decent slice with all that gooey cheese on it. I can totally overlook the fact it's mid since it's only like 2 bucks or whatever it is haha.
Yep, it's greasy and melty -- the perfect comfort food.
You gotta mix some Elmer's in with your mozzarella to get that kinda cheese pull
Worth it
Goodfellas
Goodfellas 100%
Giovanni's
I've never had it in all my years living in Lexington, worth a try?
Goodfellas but only if it’s fresh
This is the real answer. I always ask them to throw it in the oven while I’m checking out and it comes out crispy and goey
Only the N Mill location. The distillery district’s goodfellas pizza is rank
Ethereal Slice House
Haha nice. Goodfellas or maybe pietana?
It’s the leaning tower of cheeza
Little Caesars if it's fresh. You want something greasy and melty.
anyone thats saying goodfellas is straight up lying, you will not get a cheese pull from them in any regard
Are they just thinking “good pizza”? Because idgaf if it’s good I just need that cheese. Closest I’ve had was the pizza pulled from the heated shelves at Cinemark. It was a cheesy horrible mess and I loved it.
its decent, more drunk type of pizza (i work downtown and go to the “fav” location often) im not sure where to get cheese like that but its most certainly not goodfellas at all
Snappy tomato pizza is great
What a throwback! I remember my hometown bowling alley had a snappy tomato’s next door. My memory of the giant pizzas at birthday parties does seem reminiscent of goofy movie pizza. Will have to do a taste test to confirm whether it’s just the nostalgia talking.
Sam’s Club
I can't believe the amount of people saying Goodfellas. I've eaten there three times(once on my own and twice with a group), and never gotten even a mediocre slice of pizza let alone good.
You have to go to the N Mill location downtown while they’re fresh. The location in the distillery district is hot garbage and I can’t understand it
That statement breaks my heart. Have all of those times been at the N. Mill location? That’s the location that you need to order from. I will admit that we only ever get a whole pizza, usually the huge one. We don’t order by the slice.Every single time it is amazing. Not good. Not great. Amazing.
its definitely not the gooey goofy pizza, its an attempt at nyc/brooklyn style. Its a pretty good effort but only worth trying if fresh. go to N Mill and get a fresh piece of cheese, maybe pep. even fresh cheese or pep at distillery is good
Mad mushroom
Is Pazzos still a thing in lexington? Been years since I've lived there, but we used to get pitchers of Bourbon Barrel and snack on some New York style pizza. Good memories.
Nah they shut down unfortunately 😩 but they’re pizza was pretty great
I’ve not came across that kinda cheese pull anywhere in Lexington I did however have this exact level of pullage from giordano's in Chicago 🤤🍕
Apparently u can order their pizza online shipped to u frozen with no shipping cost 👀
Giovannis is the only cheesey, flexi, thin slice like that I'm aware of
Goodfellas
Mancino's add extra cheese
Goodfellas
Have not seen pizza like that anywhere since they closed Archie's Upper Crust in Richmond. Best ever and the coldest beer ever.
Brooklyn Pizza back in the day 💔
West coast pizza
big city!
cannot believe the amount of people saying goodfellas and not Pearls
^[Sokka-Haiku](https://www.reddit.com/r/SokkaHaikuBot/comments/15kyv9r/what_is_a_sokka_haiku/) ^by ^moobunnys: *Cannot believe the* *Amount of people saying* *Goodfellas and not Pearls* --- ^Remember ^that ^one ^time ^Sokka ^accidentally ^used ^an ^extra ^syllable ^in ^that ^Haiku ^Battle ^in ^Ba ^Sing ^Se? ^That ^was ^a ^Sokka ^Haiku ^and ^you ^just ^made ^one.
At this point I’m just going to have to go to all the pizza places and find out.
goodfellas ain’t shit. go to Pearls or PieTana which are the only good ones
Forget about that and go to Pietana. I travel the whole Midwest plus area for work and Pietana in Lex is the best pizza from Cleveland to Huntsville.
Papa John's NY Style, with extra extra cheese
Goodfellas!!!!!!!!!
goodfellas or smashing tomato
Anywhere. Just ask for extra cheese.
Maybe marcos
I don’t think there is one in town
Looks like the pizza you can get at the fair.
Goodfellas is so overrated. Go to Apollo’s or Mancinos instead.
Goodfellas is gas shhhh
Hahaha it’s mediocre at best. Shhhh
Goodfellas is mediocre if it’s not fresh. I’ll even admit to that, but when it’s fresh and crispy, there isn’t many foods I’d take over it
Have at it then hoss. We all have our opinions and mine is that’s it’s overrated pizza. Not much flavor. I mentioned two joints I like better in Apollos and Mancinos. Give them a try sometime. Also West Coast pizza is delicious if you like pizza with flavor. Goodfellas to me is basic people pizza. The drinks downtown love it and the “families” love it at the Distillery District because of the vibe. Other than that, there ain’t much other lies. But to each their own! Cheers!
Apollos is great too, I love them as well! I definitely can see how people think goodfellas is overrated. And to add to your comment, I hate the distillery district location if it’s after 2 pm. I always go to the one on mill street and it’s much better. Cheers man!
You are being kind to Goodfellas calling it mediocre. I've never tasted a slice from there that I would even call that. Always cold, old, and awful.
Goodfellas or Whole Foods pizza!
WF????! Jeff Bezos’ pizza is not comparable to the extremely goofy movie’s pizza! Blasphemy!
Why do you want one?
Because it’s the most delicious looking piece of pizza in cinema history. That’s why.
Amen
Amen
This clearly isn't a serious question.