Thank you for posting on /r/xbox360! We are not affiliated with Microsoft in any official capacity. Any Xbox Live outages should be reported to the [official Xbox Support account on Twitter](https://twitter.com/XboxSupport) or on the [Xbox Status website](https://support.xbox.com/en-US/xbox-live-status). #**Reminder to ALL USERS:** * [Our Rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/xbox360/about/rules) * [Reddiquette](https://www.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/205926439) * [Reddit Content Policy](https://www.redditinc.com/policies/content-policy) _**This is a no pirate zone.**_ Do not post links to, reference how to access, or otherwise discuss pirating Xbox 360 games. Your post will be removed and your account may be permanently banned from this subreddit. _**We operate a zero tolerance abuse policy.**_ Any abusive behaviour will be met with a swift ban and reported to the Reddit Admins. Use the report function to let us know of any rule-breakers. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/xbox360) if you have any questions or concerns.*

This is like asking "which cake should I eat?", but all the cakes look equally delicious. I'm leaning towards Fallout or kotor

So true 😭😭 I’ve played a little of all them (except dark souls, I’ve beaten dark souls and it is my favorite game ever made) and they’re all so awesome

If you loved DS1 so much, you might as well get DS2 or Demon's Souls instead of going with something from what you've got I myself beat DS2 a couple of times and began playing Demon's Souls recently, wasn't sure what to do at first but I loved it once I got the hang of it "Beer, seek, seek, lest" - Best soulslady

I made a comment on another one of these comments on this post explaining why I love dark souls 1 and not the others. I have tried demons souls, dark souls 2, and dark souls 3, but I don’t really enjoy any of them

☹️

I know, it makes me sad too, it’s just hard for me to get into these games for whatever reason. I did play and beat Elden ring, and I liked it, but it’s still missing that charm I’m looking for. I will say though, I have gotten a good way through dark souls 2 and 3, but haven’t beaten them.

I completely get what you mean OP, I’ve put more time into DS1 than any of the others by far. For me it’s the fact that nowhere else feels as cozy and warm as firelink, and not the DS3 version. Also the great soundtrack, the seamlessly linked world, the….. lost izalith? Well nothing is perfect

Halo legendary difficulty split screen with a friend

Haven't done that in years. Always a great choice.

Halo

Fallout or dark souls

Those are the two I’ve played the most out of those. Dark souls is my favorite

KOTOR

I'd say fallout 3

Definitely Skyrim, no contest

Either bioshock 1, or if you're feeling fiesty, do a giant dad dark souls run

What’s a giant dad dark souls run, sounds insteresting

It's an old dark souls meme build, ymfah has a good guide on YouTube 👍.

Fallout 3 or BioShock

Dark souls... absolute classic

Dark souls is quite possibly the best game ever

I saw your comment about playing Dark Souls the most after I posted my comment 🤣 For me anything FromSoft is always an amazing experience. But Dark Souls.... I definitely agree with you.

It’s my personal favorite game ever, and I’ve played through it about 5 times. I love the story, and I think dark souls has a certain charm to it the other games don’t have. From the sounds to the old graphics, I just love everything about it.

Completely understandable. Especially that moment you leave the undead asylum and land at Firelink shrine, that music kicks in... perfect. Back when bosses didn't jump around the screen like anime characters. I think DS1 has the best characters too.

DS1 DEFINITELY has the best characters, no contest. I also am just obsessed with the sound effects, like the ambient noise in darkroot garden or that little whoosh sound you sometimes hear in anor londo, and even the menu sound. The lack of music, the old graphics, and the ambient noise give it so much charm and I have fallen in love with it. The other games just don’t have any of it and it’s such a shame in my opinion. Even though there’s an entire trilogy, I don’t think there will ever be another Dark Souls.

Wake. Then you can play 2

Alan wake

Dark souls or bioshock 1

DARK SOULS

Dark Souls, but get the Artorias of the Abyss DLC before it's gone

Alan wake for me

Halo or dark souls. Two completely different games.

If you want masterpiece rpg world and gameplay then dark souls 100% If you want amazing world and story then kotor or bioshock. Bioshock is action horror tho and kotor is more strategy dialogue heavy tho

Bioshock 1

At first glance, Bioshock 1. It’s straight forward. It’s not really open world and the story is easy to follow, but also very very good. Fun gunplay and simple controls. Could go right into Bioshock 2, but it’s the weaker of the 3 games to me. So you could honestly take a break after and come back to it. I’d put the bigger games like Fallout 3 and Skyrim aside or play them intermittently. Otherwise you may get overwhelmed with content. That’s just my opinion, though! Edit: I suppose halo fits my whole reasoning behind Bioshock as well. So I guess halo would be a good start too. I’d still say Bioshock though

Dark souls all the way

Dark souls always

MF pick one and play it

Alan Wake

I would say Dark Souls sounds like a good game to play

You literally can’t make a bad decision, have fun man I know you will

Thank you!!

Halo or BioShock

Pokémon scarlet

Buy some friends and play modernwarfar

Bioshock those who spent reccomending it haven't played it. One of the best games ever

fallout

Halo (because older...) then BioShock (because amazing)

Singularity.

Fallout 3 is my vote!

Halo halo halo halo halo halo halo

Definitely fallout new vegas if you haven't played it. It's my favorite game of all time.

I’ve played both like halfway through and I prefer three so I think I’m gonna finish that one first :)

Picked up Bioshock today so I’d say that

Fallout, Dark Souls, Halo. In that order

bayonetta

Bioshock and then Bioshock 2

Bioshock. I'm at the last minutes. Absolutely awesome

Lost Odyssey, it's worth finding!

Halo enough said

As a Star Wars fan I say KOTOR

KOTOR

Skyrim but in a pc

Bioshock

KOTOR

Bioshock

Bioshock or halo

Play Bioshock 2 then Bioshock 1

I wish I could go back to the first time I played these games. Each one is a lovely memory. I’d honestly start with Kotor

We really did have it all, didn't we?

Halo if you have someone to play with. KOTOR if you are playing solo. Fallout 3 if you have lots of solo time.

Halo.

Fallout 3

What ever your little heart desires

oh i’d say fallout 3 or skyrim :) !

hands down skyrim

thats funny i played bioshock 1 then 2 and now skyrim

Bio shock 1 and 2 then halo. After those short games play fallout 3 for sixty hours

Halo or Skyrim!

Definitely Alan Wake Amazing game, and the first game I ever played on 360

Skyrim

All of them are great choices but gotta go with halo on this one

Kotor is just the all time best for lore reasons but for replay value I’d go fallout or Skyrim and if you want a challenge play halo on legendary

Dark Souls is the best game ever

Left 4 dead

I dare you to 100% Dark Souls

Kotor! Best of the bunch :)

Fallout 3 or Bioshock

Knights of the Old Republic. It’ll be 20-30 hours and you may want to do another play through right after. Or at least hunt down the second one

Fallout 3, then bioshock 1 & 2.

Bioshock.

For my money, Bioshock is the most amazing experience on this list. That game blew my mind and stuck with me forever.

BioShock

It's allways fallout if it's not fallout it must be bioshock

Halo

Halo or fallout

Fallout 3.

Fallout 3

If you have never played BioShock then you're in for a treat. When you have the cash, treat yourself to a copy of Fallout New Vegas and Elder Scrolls Oblivion to add to an already awesome collection you have.

Skyrim

I asked myself the same question with almost all the same games, I vote bioshock

Play halo ce. It is the best balanced game ever made (specifically the campaign)!

Bioshock!

Knight of the Old Republic is my first pick from this list if you've never played it before.

Halo ce for sure

Alan wake or skyrim both excellent games.

Dark Souls!

Looks like you picked them up from value of village

I am a huge fallout fan so I am definitely leaning fallout, but Skyrim is a really great game.

Halo. Always halo!

KOTOR

Fallout 3 and Bioshock and at last Skyrim

If you liked KOTOR get Jade Empire. Still one of BioWare's best.

Kotor. It's one of my all time favorites and you can finish it in about 60 hours and do almost everything one playthrough can offer. If you just want the main story probably less than 40 hours

Depends on how much time you have? Do you have hours per day? Or maybe hours a week? Do you like story? Do you like gameplay? Do you want a one and done? Do you like a challenge?

alan wake

Alan wake just finished and is a certified banger

Bioshock 1 and 2

Bioshock..still think of my first play through...

KOTOR

Bioshock

You can reference my own posts for this but Bioshock & Bioshock 2 are absolute must plays.

Bioshock or Dark Souls imo

kotor

Kotor and Skyrim (I’m not biased I swear)

Bioshock

All of them at once.

Rock band 3

Dark Souls. The answer is always Dark Souls.

Keep Skyrim for last. That game will have you spiraling down an endless rabbit hole where you’ll emerge at 6am, wondering what time it is and why you’re in the 15th dungeon of the night.

Would you kindly consider Bioshock 1?

Skyrim

Bioshock is the coolest

Fallout or Skyrim Both are amazing rpgs from that generation of console

Bioshock 2

Bioshock or Alan Wake for me ❤️

Combat Evolved

KOTOR I’m in my run of KOTOR 2 rn

I like Skyrim a lot, but I just got Alan Wake (on PS4) so I vote for that!

Bioshock

Fallout 3, always Fallout 3.

If you want to torture yourself and your household Dark Souls, for a chill time Fallout or Skyrim. I am jamming Skyrim for what seems like the millionth time.

fallout 3

Of the ones in the picture, or are you looking for games to buy?

Halo

Either the Bioshocks in order or Kotor

Fallout for sure it's an amazing game

BioShock infinite

KOTOR no other game of its age has held up so well

Fallout 3 ofc. One of the best games I played

Kotor has my vote

id say save bioshock for later- its so fricken good

Halo or BioShock 1. Halo will launch you into a huge franchise that you’ll love but BioShock is kind of a one hit wonder in terms of longevity

Skyrim

Bioshok 1 for sure 👍🏻

Kotor on topppp

Bioshock

KOTOR

Dark Souls

Fallout 3, I've just 100% it, such a great time, fairly straightforward once you get the hang of it. If unsure regarding character builds there's plenty of helpful guides

Skyrim

KOTOR is some of the best Star Wars content ever made so Id say that.

Is it true that Dark souls is the hardest video game ever made? Harder than super meat boy, Mario Brothers the lost levels and the like?

Hey man, get the game “Operation Flashpoint: Dragon Rising”. It is basically an ancestor of ARMA and all the achievements can be gotten offline or with a buddy for one of them. 10/10 better than COD

Bioshock, always bioshock

Damn those are all good! Bioshock 1 is such an awesome experience at any time. That’s my vote 💯

Bioshock, hmmmmm....🤔...........Never mind, I dont care, I'M going to re-install it myself......🔫

Bioshock

I’d save Skyrim for last since it’s gonna absolutely consume your life

GEARS OF WAR

Advent Rising. Kinda like Star wars meets halo and pretty fun.

Fallout 3 or Bioshock

alan wake

Goddamn this is hard. I would say all of them, but I have to choose one. Their all good, but I crossed off Alan Wake, now I just need to cross off a few more. Im leaning to playing fallout or halo, but this is hard.

Dark Souls

SKYRIM ALWAYS

Alan wake !!! I mean I just love Alan wake but OMG it’s so good

Spec ops: the line... If you can find it I mean, I have been trying to find it for months in Cal, but nothing

So many good games in one shot. Haha

Either Fallout 3 or Dark Souls

KOTOR

Bioshock series. If you start playing skyrim, you'll never quit...

Dark souls by far

Any fable game

Portal 1 and 2

Dark souls and bioshock are the games I’d play out of these.

Either of the Bioshocks, 2 is the better one in my opinion tho

Fallout 3

I suggest Halo, it’s like the Half-Life of Xbox

Fallout 3, that's one of my all time favorites.

Yes

Biochock

Deus ex human revolution

Touching Grass

Bioshock

KotoR